Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Federal Court of Justice: Message sent to ex-colleague by mistake gives rise to GDPR damages

Federal Court of Justice: Message sent to ex-colleague by mistake gives rise to GDPR damages

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce has now ruled on a legal dis­pu­te bet­ween a job appli­cant and a pri­va­te bank in Ber­lin, which has been ongo­ing sin­ce 2019, in a land­mark jud­ge­ment. The out­co­me is clear: anyo­ne who loses con­trol over their per­so­nal data as a result of a data-pro­ces­sing error may cla­im com­pen­sa­ti­on for non-pecu­nia­ry dama­ge under the Gene­ral Data Pro­tec­tion Regu­la­ti­on. This appli­es even if the actu­al dama­ge appears to be rela­tively minor.

What had happened?

The clai­mant had appli­ed for a job at a pri­va­te bank in Ber­lin and had sta­ted his desi­red sala­ry. The bank con­side­red this to be too high and wis­hed to reject the appli­cant via the Xing plat­form and make him a lower sala­ry offer. Howe­ver, due to a simp­le admi­nis­tra­ti­ve error, this mes­sa­ge did not reach the appli­cant hims­elf, but ins­tead went to a for­mer col­le­ague of his. Alt­hough this col­le­ague for­ward­ed the mes­sa­ge, the dama­ge had alre­a­dy been done: a third par­ty had lear­nt that the clai­mant had appli­ed for a job else­whe­re and had been rejec­ted becau­se of his sala­ry expectations.

The appli­cant sub­se­quent­ly deman­ded that the bank pro­vi­de a cea­se-and-desist decla­ra­ti­on sub­ject to a penal­ty clau­se, full details of how his data had been pro­ces­sed, and com­pen­sa­ti­on for non-pecu­nia­ry dama­ge amoun­ting to at least 2,500 euros.

The ECJ and the Federal Court of Justice strengthen the rights of those affected

As the legal posi­ti­on was unclear, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) initi­al­ly refer­red the ques­ti­on to the Euro­pean Court of Jus­ti­ce as to whe­ther such a set of facts could, in any event, give rise to a cla­im for dama­ges under Artic­le 82 of the GDPR. The ECJ express­ly con­firm­ed this. Accor­din­gly, for non-mate­ri­al dama­ge within the mea­ning of the GDPR, it is suf­fi­ci­ent if the incor­rect data pro­ces­sing trig­gers nega­ti­ve fee­lings in the data sub­ject, such as the fee­ling that unaut­ho­ri­sed per­sons have gai­ned access to per­so­nal information.

On the basis of this ruling by the ECJ, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) has now han­ded down a land­mark jud­ge­ment in favour of the clai­mant. The scope of the GDPR appli­es becau­se the mes­sa­ge, which was for­ward­ed by mista­ke, con­tai­ned per­so­nal data rela­ting to the ongo­ing recruit­ment pro­cess. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce regard­ed the fact that the data had ended up with a for­mer col­le­ague, of all peo­p­le, as a par­ti­cu­lar­ly aggravating fac­tor. The clai­mant felt he had been humi­lia­ted in front of someone he trus­ted by having his rejec­ted sala­ry expec­ta­ti­ons dis­c­lo­sed, which cle­ar­ly con­sti­tu­ted non-pecu­nia­ry damage.

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce has not yet ruled on the spe­ci­fic amount of dama­ges. In accordance with Sec­tion 287 of the Code of Civil Pro­ce­du­re (ZPO), it refer­red this assess­ment to the com­pe­tent Hig­her Regio­nal Court as the tri­al court.

No right to an injunction under the GDPR

Howe­ver, the clai­mant was unsuc­cessful on one point. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) dis­missed the cla­im for an injunc­tion. The GDPR its­elf does not pro­vi­de for such a cla­im. A cla­im for an injunc­tion based on the ana­log­ous appli­ca­ti­on of Sec­tions 1004 and 823 of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB) fai­led becau­se, fol­lo­wing the con­clu­si­on of the recruit­ment pro­cess, the­re was no lon­ger any risk of a repeat offence. It is inte­res­t­ing to note that the BGH reco­g­nis­ed Artic­le 6 of the GDPR in prin­ci­ple as a pro­tec­ti­ve sta­tu­te within the mea­ning of the BGB and con­siders a cla­im for an injunc­tion to be pos­si­ble in other circumstances.

What does this mean for businesses and those affected?

The ruling shows that even see­mingly minor data brea­ches can have signi­fi­cant legal con­se­quen­ces. Com­pa­nies should careful­ly orga­ni­se their inter­nal pro­ce­du­res for digi­tal com­mu­ni­ca­ti­on in order to pre­vent acci­den­tal mis­rou­ting of mes­sa­ges. For tho­se affec­ted, the ruling means that a loss of con­trol over one’s own data can, in its­elf, con­sti­tu­te grounds for a cla­im for dama­ges, wit­hout the need to pro­ve any spe­ci­fic finan­cial loss.

Anyo­ne who belie­ves they have been affec­ted by a simi­lar data pro­tec­tion breach should seek legal advice to assess their claims.

Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH), jud­ge­ment of 23 June 2026, Case No. VI ZR 97/22

Source: Hau­fe: Law

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this