The Federal Court of Justice has now ruled on a legal dispute between a job applicant and a private bank in Berlin, which has been ongoing since 2019, in a landmark judgement. The outcome is clear: anyone who loses control over their personal data as a result of a data-processing error may claim compensation for non-pecuniary damage under the General Data Protection Regulation. This applies even if the actual damage appears to be relatively minor.
What had happened?
The claimant had applied for a job at a private bank in Berlin and had stated his desired salary. The bank considered this to be too high and wished to reject the applicant via the Xing platform and make him a lower salary offer. However, due to a simple administrative error, this message did not reach the applicant himself, but instead went to a former colleague of his. Although this colleague forwarded the message, the damage had already been done: a third party had learnt that the claimant had applied for a job elsewhere and had been rejected because of his salary expectations.
The applicant subsequently demanded that the bank provide a cease-and-desist declaration subject to a penalty clause, full details of how his data had been processed, and compensation for non-pecuniary damage amounting to at least 2,500 euros.
The ECJ and the Federal Court of Justice strengthen the rights of those affected
As the legal position was unclear, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) initially referred the question to the European Court of Justice as to whether such a set of facts could, in any event, give rise to a claim for damages under Article 82 of the GDPR. The ECJ expressly confirmed this. Accordingly, for non-material damage within the meaning of the GDPR, it is sufficient if the incorrect data processing triggers negative feelings in the data subject, such as the feeling that unauthorised persons have gained access to personal information.
On the basis of this ruling by the ECJ, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has now handed down a landmark judgement in favour of the claimant. The scope of the GDPR applies because the message, which was forwarded by mistake, contained personal data relating to the ongoing recruitment process. The Federal Court of Justice regarded the fact that the data had ended up with a former colleague, of all people, as a particularly aggravating factor. The claimant felt he had been humiliated in front of someone he trusted by having his rejected salary expectations disclosed, which clearly constituted non-pecuniary damage.
The Federal Court of Justice has not yet ruled on the specific amount of damages. In accordance with Section 287 of the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO), it referred this assessment to the competent Higher Regional Court as the trial court.
No right to an injunction under the GDPR
However, the claimant was unsuccessful on one point. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) dismissed the claim for an injunction. The GDPR itself does not provide for such a claim. A claim for an injunction based on the analogous application of Sections 1004 and 823 of the German Civil Code (BGB) failed because, following the conclusion of the recruitment process, there was no longer any risk of a repeat offence. It is interesting to note that the BGH recognised Article 6 of the GDPR in principle as a protective statute within the meaning of the BGB and considers a claim for an injunction to be possible in other circumstances.
What does this mean for businesses and those affected?
The ruling shows that even seemingly minor data breaches can have significant legal consequences. Companies should carefully organise their internal procedures for digital communication in order to prevent accidental misrouting of messages. For those affected, the ruling means that a loss of control over one’s own data can, in itself, constitute grounds for a claim for damages, without the need to prove any specific financial loss.
Anyone who believes they have been affected by a similar data protection breach should seek legal advice to assess their claims.
Federal Court of Justice (BGH), judgement of 23 June 2026, Case No. VI ZR 97/22
Source: Haufe: Law
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.