Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Coronavirus support: Würzburg Administrative Court rejects new fixed costs in the final settlement

The Würz­burg Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court has rejec­ted the inclu­si­on of new fixed cos­ts in the final sett­le­ment of coro­na­vi­rus aid – and has based its decis­i­on on the approach taken in North Rhine-Westphalia. 
Coronavirus support: Würzburg Administrative Court rejects new fixed costs in the final settlement

Coronavirus support: Würzburg Administrative Court rejects new fixed costs in the final settlement

Many busi­nesses that recei­ved bridging aid during the coro­na­vi­rus pan­de­mic are curr­ent­ly facing a dif­fi­cult situa­ti­on: as part of the final sett­le­ment, fixed-cost items are emer­ging that were not included in the ori­gi­nal appli­ca­ti­on. The Würz­burg Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court has now ruled in a recent jud­ge­ment that such cost items clai­med retro­s­pec­tively can­not, in prin­ci­ple, be recognised.

What was the case about?

An event cate­rer had appli­ed for Bridging Aid III in ear­ly 2021 and had been pro­vi­sio­nal­ly gran­ted around 6,800 euros. In the final state­ment of accounts dated June 2023, the appoin­ted tax advi­ser included cos­ts for so-cal­led start-up aid for the first time and clai­med a total of just under 17,000 euros. The appro­ving aut­ho­ri­ty, the Cham­ber of Indus­try and Com­mer­ce for Munich and Upper Bava­ria, reco­g­nis­ed only around 7,750 euros and rejec­ted the rema­in­der. The legal action brought against this decis­i­on was unsuc­cessful. The Würz­burg Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court dis­missed the appeal in its jud­ge­ment of 29 June 2026 (Ref. W 8 K 25.160).

How did the court justify its decision?

The court based its decis­i­on on two sepa­ra­te lines of reasoning.

First­ly, it poin­ted out that the­re is no sta­tu­to­ry entit­le­ment to coro­na­vi­rus sup­port. What appli­cants can cla­im depends sole­ly on the actu­al admi­nis­tra­ti­ve prac­ti­ce of the rele­vant appro­ving aut­ho­ri­ty. The prac­ti­ce of the Cham­ber of Indus­try and Com­mer­ce for Munich and Upper Bava­ria per­mits new fixed-cost items to be included in the final state­ment only in two excep­tio­nal cases: if the item was included in the initi­al appli­ca­ti­on but lis­ted in the wrong place or with a value of zero, or if the third-par­ty audi­tor proac­tively repor­ted their own error and the appro­ving aut­ho­ri­ty has con­firm­ed that it will be taken into account.

The court cited EU sta­te aid law as its second ground for the ruling. In doing so, it drew on the case law of the courts in North Rhi­ne-West­pha­lia, in par­ti­cu­lar that of the Hig­her Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court in Müns­ter. Accor­ding to this, grants based on the fede­ral ‘Small Grants 2020’ sche­me could only be award­ed until 30 June 2022. Anyo­ne who had not yet recei­ved a bin­ding appr­oval by that date can no lon­ger cla­im new cost items retrospectively.

Why is the decision controversial?

The jud­ge­ment is not yet final. An appeal against the decis­i­on may be lodged with the Bava­ri­an Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court.

Experts con­sider the jus­ti­fi­ca­ti­on under sta­te aid law to be open to chall­enge. In this spe­ci­fic case, the ori­gi­nal grant appr­oval noti­ce had alre­a­dy been issued in April 2021, i.e. more than a year befo­re the cut-off date. The ques­ti­on of which fixed cos­ts were actual­ly incur­red rela­tes to the cal­cu­la­ti­on of the grant amount, not the date of appr­oval. Fur­ther­mo­re, a let­ter from the Fede­ral Minis­try for Eco­no­mic Affairs dated 2023 express­ly per­mits the gran­ting aut­ho­ri­ties to reco­g­ni­se new fixed cos­ts in jus­ti­fied indi­vi­du­al cases. This would be hard­ly com­pa­ti­ble with an abso­lu­te ban under sta­te aid law.

What does this mean for those affected?

In the event of a dis­pu­te, com­pa­nies and their tax advi­sers should first careful­ly check whe­ther a cost item is genui­ne­ly new or whe­ther it con­sti­tu­tes a cor­rec­tion to infor­ma­ti­on alre­a­dy sub­mit­ted. Accor­ding to the prac­ti­ce descri­bed, the lat­ter does not fall under the exclu­si­on. Fur­ther­mo­re, it may be important to docu­ment why cer­tain cos­ts were sim­ply not yet known at the time of the initi­al cla­im, for exam­p­le becau­se ser­vice char­ge state­ments or insu­rance pre­mi­ums were not fina­li­sed until later.

As the final word has not yet been spo­ken, and the Euro­pean Court of Jus­ti­ce is also con­side­ring the clas­si­fi­ca­ti­on of COVID-19 aid under sta­te aid law fol­lo­wing a refer­ral from the Ham­burg Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court, it is worth not giving up on ongo­ing pro­cee­dings too hasti­ly. In indi­vi­du­al cases, it is advi­sa­ble to seek advice from a soli­ci­tor spe­cia­li­sing in admi­nis­tra­ti­ve or tax law.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this