Many businesses that received bridging aid during the coronavirus pandemic are currently facing a difficult situation: as part of the final settlement, fixed-cost items are emerging that were not included in the original application. The Würzburg Administrative Court has now ruled in a recent judgement that such cost items claimed retrospectively cannot, in principle, be recognised.
What was the case about?
An event caterer had applied for Bridging Aid III in early 2021 and had been provisionally granted around 6,800 euros. In the final statement of accounts dated June 2023, the appointed tax adviser included costs for so-called start-up aid for the first time and claimed a total of just under 17,000 euros. The approving authority, the Chamber of Industry and Commerce for Munich and Upper Bavaria, recognised only around 7,750 euros and rejected the remainder. The legal action brought against this decision was unsuccessful. The Würzburg Administrative Court dismissed the appeal in its judgement of 29 June 2026 (Ref. W 8 K 25.160).
How did the court justify its decision?
The court based its decision on two separate lines of reasoning.
Firstly, it pointed out that there is no statutory entitlement to coronavirus support. What applicants can claim depends solely on the actual administrative practice of the relevant approving authority. The practice of the Chamber of Industry and Commerce for Munich and Upper Bavaria permits new fixed-cost items to be included in the final statement only in two exceptional cases: if the item was included in the initial application but listed in the wrong place or with a value of zero, or if the third-party auditor proactively reported their own error and the approving authority has confirmed that it will be taken into account.
The court cited EU state aid law as its second ground for the ruling. In doing so, it drew on the case law of the courts in North Rhine-Westphalia, in particular that of the Higher Administrative Court in Münster. According to this, grants based on the federal ‘Small Grants 2020’ scheme could only be awarded until 30 June 2022. Anyone who had not yet received a binding approval by that date can no longer claim new cost items retrospectively.
Why is the decision controversial?
The judgement is not yet final. An appeal against the decision may be lodged with the Bavarian Administrative Court.
Experts consider the justification under state aid law to be open to challenge. In this specific case, the original grant approval notice had already been issued in April 2021, i.e. more than a year before the cut-off date. The question of which fixed costs were actually incurred relates to the calculation of the grant amount, not the date of approval. Furthermore, a letter from the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs dated 2023 expressly permits the granting authorities to recognise new fixed costs in justified individual cases. This would be hardly compatible with an absolute ban under state aid law.
What does this mean for those affected?
In the event of a dispute, companies and their tax advisers should first carefully check whether a cost item is genuinely new or whether it constitutes a correction to information already submitted. According to the practice described, the latter does not fall under the exclusion. Furthermore, it may be important to document why certain costs were simply not yet known at the time of the initial claim, for example because service charge statements or insurance premiums were not finalised until later.
As the final word has not yet been spoken, and the European Court of Justice is also considering the classification of COVID-19 aid under state aid law following a referral from the Hamburg Administrative Court, it is worth not giving up on ongoing proceedings too hastily. In individual cases, it is advisable to seek advice from a solicitor specialising in administrative or tax law.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.