In its judgement of 9 April 2026 (case number VI R 12/24), the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has made a significant U‑turn: Employees can no longer rely on a direct claim for a refund in the case of wrongfully withheld income tax by way of analogous application of section 50d(1), second sentence, of the Income Tax Act (EStG). This applies even if the employer withheld and paid the income tax in contravention of a double taxation agreement (DTA) or without any legal basis whatsoever.
What was the case about?
A Swiss resident was employed by a German GmbH in 2018. In May 2018, his employment was terminated by mutual agreement with effect from the end of the year. From 18 May 2018, he was irrevocably on leave, but continued to receive his salary. Prior to being placed on leave, he had actually worked in Germany on 47 days, 35 of which were spent without returning to Switzerland.
The employer withheld and paid income tax for the whole year. The employee applied for a refund of a large part of this tax on the grounds that he should be classified as a cross-border worker within the meaning of the Germany–Switzerland double taxation agreement. As a cross-border worker, the right of taxation would, in principle, lie solely with Switzerland, meaning that Germany would, at most, be permitted to levy a withholding tax of 4.5 per cent.
What did the Federal Fiscal Court rule?
The court first clarified that Germany has the right to tax the claimant only for the 47 days on which he actually worked in Germany. For the remainder of the period – in particular the period of leave, as well as the days spent working from home and on holiday – Germany has no right of taxation. Furthermore, the claimant was not a cross-border worker within the meaning of the agreement, as he had failed to return home to Switzerland on more than the permitted number of working days.
Nevertheless, he could not simply reclaim the excess income tax that had been withheld. The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) expressly departed from previous case law, under which an employee’s direct claim for a refund had been recognised in such cases by way of analogous application of Section 50d of the Income Tax Act (EStG). In the court’s view, such an analogous application is out of the question.
Exception: Protection of legitimate expectations for applications already submitted
However, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) made an important exception. Anyone who had submitted their claim for a refund by the date of publication of this decision (9 July 2026) may still rely on the old principles. In this specific case, the claimant was therefore found to be at least partially in the right and was reimbursed the income tax attributable to the portion of their wages exceeding 47 working days.
What path will employees have to take in future?
Anyone wishing to reclaim income tax that has been wrongly withheld must, following this ruling, take a different course of action. The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) points out that the employee may challenge the employer’s income tax return submitted to the relevant tax office or apply for it to be amended. Only once this return has been successfully challenged does a claim for a refund arise. By contrast, a standalone application for a refund is not sufficient under procedural law.
What does this mean for employees with links to other countries?
Anyone working in a border region or employed in Germany but living abroad should have the tax treatment of their wages carefully reviewed. The correct allocation of working days, the question of cross-border worker status and the correct procedure to follow in the event of incorrect withholding tax are complex issues where tax advice tailored to individual circumstances is essential.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.