Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

BFH: No direct entitlement to a pay-as-you-earn tax refund in the event of incorrect tax deduction

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) over­turns pre­vious case law: employees have no direct right to a refund in the event of incor­rect with­hol­ding of inco­me tax. 
BFH: No direct entitlement to a pay-as-you-earn tax refund in the event of incorrect tax deduction

BFH: No direct entitlement to a pay-as-you-earn tax refund in the event of incorrect tax deduction

In its jud­ge­ment of 9 April 2026 (case num­ber VI R 12/24), the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) has made a signi­fi­cant U‑turn: Employees can no lon­ger rely on a direct cla­im for a refund in the case of wrongful­ly with­held inco­me tax by way of ana­log­ous appli­ca­ti­on of sec­tion 50d(1), second sen­tence, of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG). This appli­es even if the employ­er with­held and paid the inco­me tax in con­tra­ven­ti­on of a dou­ble taxa­ti­on agree­ment (DTA) or wit­hout any legal basis whatsoever.

What was the case about?

A Swiss resi­dent was employ­ed by a Ger­man GmbH in 2018. In May 2018, his employ­ment was ter­mi­na­ted by mutu­al agree­ment with effect from the end of the year. From 18 May 2018, he was irre­vo­ca­bly on lea­ve, but con­tin­ued to recei­ve his sala­ry. Pri­or to being pla­ced on lea­ve, he had actual­ly work­ed in Ger­ma­ny on 47 days, 35 of which were spent wit­hout retur­ning to Switzerland.

The employ­er with­held and paid inco­me tax for the who­le year. The employee appli­ed for a refund of a lar­ge part of this tax on the grounds that he should be clas­si­fied as a cross-bor­der worker within the mea­ning of the Germany–Switzerland dou­ble taxa­ti­on agree­ment. As a cross-bor­der worker, the right of taxa­ti­on would, in prin­ci­ple, lie sole­ly with Switz­er­land, mea­ning that Ger­ma­ny would, at most, be per­mit­ted to levy a with­hol­ding tax of 4.5 per cent.

What did the Federal Fiscal Court rule?

The court first cla­ri­fied that Ger­ma­ny has the right to tax the clai­mant only for the 47 days on which he actual­ly work­ed in Ger­ma­ny. For the rema­in­der of the peri­od – in par­ti­cu­lar the peri­od of lea­ve, as well as the days spent working from home and on holi­day – Ger­ma­ny has no right of taxa­ti­on. Fur­ther­mo­re, the clai­mant was not a cross-bor­der worker within the mea­ning of the agree­ment, as he had fai­led to return home to Switz­er­land on more than the per­mit­ted num­ber of working days.

Nevert­hel­ess, he could not sim­ply recla­im the excess inco­me tax that had been with­held. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) express­ly depar­ted from pre­vious case law, under which an employee’s direct cla­im for a refund had been reco­g­nis­ed in such cases by way of ana­log­ous appli­ca­ti­on of Sec­tion 50d of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG). In the court’s view, such an ana­log­ous appli­ca­ti­on is out of the question.

Exception: Protection of legitimate expectations for applications already submitted

Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) made an important excep­ti­on. Anyo­ne who had sub­mit­ted their cla­im for a refund by the date of publi­ca­ti­on of this decis­i­on (9 July 2026) may still rely on the old prin­ci­ples. In this spe­ci­fic case, the clai­mant was the­r­e­fo­re found to be at least par­ti­al­ly in the right and was reim­bur­sed the inco­me tax attri­bu­ta­ble to the por­ti­on of their wages excee­ding 47 working days.

What path will employees have to take in future?

Anyo­ne wis­hing to recla­im inco­me tax that has been wron­gly with­held must, fol­lo­wing this ruling, take a dif­fe­rent cour­se of action. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) points out that the employee may chall­enge the employer’s inco­me tax return sub­mit­ted to the rele­vant tax office or app­ly for it to be amen­ded. Only once this return has been suc­cessful­ly chal­len­ged does a cla­im for a refund ari­se. By con­trast, a stan­da­lo­ne appli­ca­ti­on for a refund is not suf­fi­ci­ent under pro­ce­du­ral law.

What does this mean for employees with links to other countries?

Anyo­ne working in a bor­der regi­on or employ­ed in Ger­ma­ny but living abroad should have the tax tre­at­ment of their wages careful­ly review­ed. The cor­rect allo­ca­ti­on of working days, the ques­ti­on of cross-bor­der worker sta­tus and the cor­rect pro­ce­du­re to fol­low in the event of incor­rect with­hol­ding tax are com­plex issues whe­re tax advice tail­o­red to indi­vi­du­al cir­cum­s­tances is essential.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this