Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Losses from aircraft leasing recognised for tax purposes: Düsseldorf Fiscal Court backs lessors

Düs­sel­dorf Fis­cal Court: Los­ses ari­sing from air­craft lea­sing may be reco­g­nis­ed for tax pur­po­ses if the­re is no evi­dence of pri­va­te use or com­mer­cial activity. 
Losses from aircraft leasing recognised for tax purposes: Düsseldorf Fiscal Court backs lessors

Losses from aircraft leasing recognised for tax purposes: Düsseldorf Fiscal Court backs lessors

Anyo­ne who lets out a pro­per­ty and incurs los­ses over a peri­od of years must expect the tax aut­ho­ri­ties to refu­se to reco­g­ni­se the­se los­ses for tax pur­po­ses. The key term here is ‘hob­by’: If the tax aut­ho­ri­ties con­clude that someone is car­ry­ing out an acti­vi­ty wit­hout a serious inten­ti­on of gene­ra­ting inco­me, the los­ses are sim­ply dis­re­gard­ed for tax pur­po­ses. The Düs­sel­dorf Tax Court has now ruled in an inte­res­t­ing case that this thres­hold is not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly excee­ded even in the case of a char­te­red pri­va­te jet.

What were the proceedings about?

In 2006, a test­a­tor had purcha­sed an air­craft capa­ble of car­ry­ing six to nine pas­sen­gers and offe­red it for hire on the mar­ket through a com­mer­cial char­ter com­pa­ny. Over a peri­od of around eight years, this resul­ted in sub­stan­ti­al los­ses, which the test­a­tor clai­med in his inco­me tax return as excess inco­me-rela­ted expen­ses against inco­me from let­ting and lea­sing. The tax office did not reco­g­ni­se the los­ses for the dis­pu­ted years 2012 to 2014. It saw no inten­ti­on to gene­ra­te a sur­plus and con­side­red the total sur­plus fore­cast, drawn up retro­s­pec­tively, to be unsound.

The clai­mants, acting as the deceased’s heirs, con­tes­ted this assess­ment. They poin­ted to the finan­cial cri­sis as the main cau­se of the finan­cial fail­ure, as well as to the fact that the decea­sed had actively respon­ded to the adver­se deve­lo­p­ments: first, he chan­ged the char­te­rer; later, he sold the aircraft.

The decision of the Tax Court

The Düs­sel­dorf Fis­cal Court ruled in favour of the clai­mants and affirm­ed that the­re was an inten­ti­on to gene­ra­te inco­me. The court based its decis­i­on on seve­ral cir­cum­s­tances which, taken tog­e­ther, pain­ted a clear picture:

  • The air­craft was never used for pri­va­te purposes.
  • No evi­dence could be found of per­so­nal moti­ves such as pres­ti­ge, a hob­by or the inten­ti­on to opti­mi­se tax arrangements.
  • The test­a­tor had respon­ded to the ongo­ing los­ses in a com­mer­ci­al­ly reasonable man­ner by chan­ging the char­te­rer and ulti­m­ate­ly sel­ling the aircraft.
  • Over a 30-year peri­od, the court con­side­red it pos­si­ble that the­re would be an over­all surplus.

The court orde­red that the inco­me tax assess­ment noti­ces and loss deter­mi­na­ti­on noti­ces be amen­ded accor­din­gly. An appeal was not allo­wed, and no appli­ca­ti­on for lea­ve to appeal was lodged. The jud­ge­ment is the­r­e­fo­re final.

What does this mean for landlords and investors?

This case demons­tra­tes that the ques­ti­on of the inten­ti­on to gene­ra­te inco­me must always be asses­sed in its enti­re­ty. Years of los­ses alo­ne do not con­sti­tu­te a hob­by. The spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances are decisi­ve: was the asset used exclu­si­ve­ly for the pur­po­se of gene­ra­ting inco­me? Did the land­lord respond to finan­cial set­backs? And does a long-term fore­cast sug­gest that an over­all sur­plus is even possible?

This appli­es not only to unu­su­al items such as an aero­pla­ne, but also to holi­day homes, sai­ling boats or other assets which the tax office is quick to clas­si­fy as a hob­by. Anyo­ne who finds them­sel­ves in such a dis­pu­te should draw up a robust fore­cast of total sur­plus at an ear­ly stage and careful­ly docu­ment that the­re is no pri­va­te use.

The jud­ge­ment was han­ded down on 21 Janu­ary 2026 under case num­ber 9 K 1503/24 E,F at the Düs­sel­dorf Finan­ce Court. In simi­lar cir­cum­s­tances, it is advi­sa­ble to seek indi­vi­du­al tax advice, as the assess­ment of the inten­ti­on to gene­ra­te inco­me always depends on the spe­ci­fic details of the indi­vi­du­al case.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this