Anyone who lets out a property and incurs losses over a period of years must expect the tax authorities to refuse to recognise these losses for tax purposes. The key term here is ‘hobby’: If the tax authorities conclude that someone is carrying out an activity without a serious intention of generating income, the losses are simply disregarded for tax purposes. The Düsseldorf Tax Court has now ruled in an interesting case that this threshold is not automatically exceeded even in the case of a chartered private jet.
What were the proceedings about?
In 2006, a testator had purchased an aircraft capable of carrying six to nine passengers and offered it for hire on the market through a commercial charter company. Over a period of around eight years, this resulted in substantial losses, which the testator claimed in his income tax return as excess income-related expenses against income from letting and leasing. The tax office did not recognise the losses for the disputed years 2012 to 2014. It saw no intention to generate a surplus and considered the total surplus forecast, drawn up retrospectively, to be unsound.
The claimants, acting as the deceased’s heirs, contested this assessment. They pointed to the financial crisis as the main cause of the financial failure, as well as to the fact that the deceased had actively responded to the adverse developments: first, he changed the charterer; later, he sold the aircraft.
The decision of the Tax Court
The Düsseldorf Fiscal Court ruled in favour of the claimants and affirmed that there was an intention to generate income. The court based its decision on several circumstances which, taken together, painted a clear picture:
- The aircraft was never used for private purposes.
- No evidence could be found of personal motives such as prestige, a hobby or the intention to optimise tax arrangements.
- The testator had responded to the ongoing losses in a commercially reasonable manner by changing the charterer and ultimately selling the aircraft.
- Over a 30-year period, the court considered it possible that there would be an overall surplus.
The court ordered that the income tax assessment notices and loss determination notices be amended accordingly. An appeal was not allowed, and no application for leave to appeal was lodged. The judgement is therefore final.
What does this mean for landlords and investors?
This case demonstrates that the question of the intention to generate income must always be assessed in its entirety. Years of losses alone do not constitute a hobby. The specific circumstances are decisive: was the asset used exclusively for the purpose of generating income? Did the landlord respond to financial setbacks? And does a long-term forecast suggest that an overall surplus is even possible?
This applies not only to unusual items such as an aeroplane, but also to holiday homes, sailing boats or other assets which the tax office is quick to classify as a hobby. Anyone who finds themselves in such a dispute should draw up a robust forecast of total surplus at an early stage and carefully document that there is no private use.
The judgement was handed down on 21 January 2026 under case number 9 K 1503/24 E,F at the Düsseldorf Finance Court. In similar circumstances, it is advisable to seek individual tax advice, as the assessment of the intention to generate income always depends on the specific details of the individual case.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.