Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

BFH: No separate assessment in the case of partial ownership of shares in a GmbH

BFH: No separate assessment in the case of partial ownership of shares in a GmbH

Anyo­ne who holds a sta­ke in a GmbH via a so-cal­led sub-hol­ding has no right to expect the tax office to deter­mi­ne the tax bases for that sub-hol­ding com­pa­ny sepa­ra­te­ly and uni­form­ly. This was cla­ri­fied by the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court in its jud­ge­ment of 19 May 2026 (Ref. VIII R 33/24).

What is a sub-participation?

An indi­rect share­hol­ding exists whe­re a per­son does not hold a direct sta­ke in a GmbH, but holds it indi­rect­ly via ano­ther share­hol­der, known as the prin­ci­pal share­hol­der. The prin­ci­pal share­hol­der for­mal­ly holds the GmbH share but con­trac­tual­ly grants the indi­rect share­hol­der an eco­no­mic inte­rest in it. This may, for exam­p­le, be appro­pria­te in the con­text of suc­ces­si­on plan­ning or a busi­ness partnership.

Gene­ral­ly spea­king, the­re are two types: In the case of the typi­cal under-repre­sen­ta­ti­onthe mino­ri­ty share­hol­der mere­ly shares in the pro­fits wit­hout having any influence over the com­pa­ny. In the case of the aty­pi­cal under-par­ti­ci­pa­ti­onthe sub-par­ti­ci­pant is trea­ted for finan­cial pur­po­ses as a co-share­hol­der and is, in effect, a co-owner of the GmbH share.

What was the point of contention?

In this spe­ci­fic case, two indi­vi­du­als joint­ly plan­ned to mar­ket a pie­ce of soft­ware. To this end, the inter­ve­ner acqui­red a share in a GmbH and ente­red into a sub-share­hol­ding agree­ment with the claimant’s son. The son is said to have acted as a trus­tee on behalf of his father. The GmbH with­held capi­tal gains tax and issued the rele­vant tax cer­ti­fi­ca­tes sole­ly to the intervener.

The clai­mant sought to have this with­hol­ding tax on capi­tal gains set off against his own inco­me tax. To this end, he sub­mit­ted decla­ra­ti­ons of assess­ment for the sub-hol­ding com­pa­ny to the tax office. The tax office refu­sed to issue the cor­re­spon­ding assess­ment noti­ces. The appeal and the legal action were unsuc­cessful, and the appeal to the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) was also unsuccessful.

The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) upheld the tax office’s view. A sepa­ra­te and uni­form assess­ment under the Tax Code requi­res that seve­ral per­sons joint inco­mefrom the same source of inco­me. This is pre­cis­e­ly what is lack­ing in the case of a mino­ri­ty share­hol­ding in a company.

  • In a typi­cal sub-par­ti­ci­pa­ti­on arran­ge­ment, the sub-par­ti­ci­pant deri­ves inco­me from capi­tal assets on a dif­fe­rent legal basis from the prin­ci­pal par­ti­ci­pant. They the­r­e­fo­re do not share in the same income.
  • In the case of aty­pi­cal par­ti­al owner­ship, the par­ti­al owner is, in eco­no­mic terms, regard­ed as a co-owner of the GmbH share and deri­ves invest­ment inco­me. Nevert­hel­ess, the­re is no com­mon source of inco­me within the mea­ning of the law.

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) also rejec­ted an ana­log­ous appli­ca­ti­on of the rele­vant pro­vi­si­ons of the Tax Code. The court express­ly sta­ted that con­side­ra­ti­ons of prac­ti­cal expe­di­en­cy can­not replace the absence of a sta­tu­to­ry basis for a mul­ti-stage assess­ment procedure.

What does this mean for those affected?

Anyo­ne who holds an eco­no­mic inte­rest in a GmbH via a sub-par­ti­ci­pa­ting com­pa­ny must have their tax posi­ti­on cla­ri­fied on a case-by-case basis in their own tax assess­ment noti­ce. The­re is no sepa­ra­te assess­ment pro­ce­du­re available for the com­pa­ny hol­ding the sub-share­hol­ding. Issues rela­ting to the cre­diting of capi­tal gains tax, in par­ti­cu­lar, can be com­plex. Anyo­ne in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should seek tax advice at an ear­ly stage.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this