Anyone who holds a stake in a GmbH via a so-called sub-holding has no right to expect the tax office to determine the tax bases for that sub-holding company separately and uniformly. This was clarified by the Federal Fiscal Court in its judgement of 19 May 2026 (Ref. VIII R 33/24).
What is a sub-participation?
An indirect shareholding exists where a person does not hold a direct stake in a GmbH, but holds it indirectly via another shareholder, known as the principal shareholder. The principal shareholder formally holds the GmbH share but contractually grants the indirect shareholder an economic interest in it. This may, for example, be appropriate in the context of succession planning or a business partnership.
Generally speaking, there are two types: In the case of the typical under-representationthe minority shareholder merely shares in the profits without having any influence over the company. In the case of the atypical under-participationthe sub-participant is treated for financial purposes as a co-shareholder and is, in effect, a co-owner of the GmbH share.
What was the point of contention?
In this specific case, two individuals jointly planned to market a piece of software. To this end, the intervener acquired a share in a GmbH and entered into a sub-shareholding agreement with the claimant’s son. The son is said to have acted as a trustee on behalf of his father. The GmbH withheld capital gains tax and issued the relevant tax certificates solely to the intervener.
The claimant sought to have this withholding tax on capital gains set off against his own income tax. To this end, he submitted declarations of assessment for the sub-holding company to the tax office. The tax office refused to issue the corresponding assessment notices. The appeal and the legal action were unsuccessful, and the appeal to the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) was also unsuccessful.
The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) upheld the tax office’s view. A separate and uniform assessment under the Tax Code requires that several persons joint incomefrom the same source of income. This is precisely what is lacking in the case of a minority shareholding in a company.
- In a typical sub-participation arrangement, the sub-participant derives income from capital assets on a different legal basis from the principal participant. They therefore do not share in the same income.
- In the case of atypical partial ownership, the partial owner is, in economic terms, regarded as a co-owner of the GmbH share and derives investment income. Nevertheless, there is no common source of income within the meaning of the law.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) also rejected an analogous application of the relevant provisions of the Tax Code. The court expressly stated that considerations of practical expediency cannot replace the absence of a statutory basis for a multi-stage assessment procedure.
What does this mean for those affected?
Anyone who holds an economic interest in a GmbH via a sub-participating company must have their tax position clarified on a case-by-case basis in their own tax assessment notice. There is no separate assessment procedure available for the company holding the sub-shareholding. Issues relating to the crediting of capital gains tax, in particular, can be complex. Anyone in a similar situation should seek tax advice at an early stage.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.