A 50 per cent shareholding is often regarded as a guarantee of entrepreneurial independence. However, the Federal Social Court has clarified in a recent judgement that this assumption can be misleading. What matters is not the size of the shareholding, but the actual legal power to prevent unwanted decisions.
What had happened?
Two managing directors, who were also shareholders, each held 50 per cent of the shares in a limited liability company (GmbH). The articles of association included a so-called casting vote clause: in the event of a tied vote, a neutral third party was to make the decision. The pension insurance authority investigated the circumstances and classified both managing directors as employees. This resulted in a back payment claim of around 127,000 euros. The GmbH challenged this decision, arguing that their 50 per cent shareholding constituted self-employment. Furthermore, they contended that the clause was invalid in any case.
The court does not consider that there is sufficient legal authority
The Federal Social Court dismissed the claim and upheld the decision of the Lower Saxony-Bremen Regional Social Court. The court’s key finding was that, whilst a shareholder holding 50 per cent of the shares can, in principle, block any resolution requiring a simple majority, However, if there is a casting vote clause which allows a third party to decide in the event of a deadlock, this very ability to block decisions is absent. Neither managing director could reliably prevent decisions being taken against their will.
The Federal Social Court (BSG) also emphasised that, for the purposes of assessment under social security law, foreseeability is required. The legal authority must be clearly recognisable and reliable. If, on the other hand, it depends on the outcome of legal proceedings or a subsequent challenge, this is not sufficient. According to the court, a challenge presupposes that a decision has first been taken. It does not prevent such a decision from being taken.
The validity of the clause is not in question
The BSG did not accept the GmbH’s argument that the casting vote clause was invalid. There was no doubt as to the validity of the provision. And even if the clause had never actually been applied, this would make no difference: its mere existence in the articles of association is sufficient to rule out the right to veto.
What does this mean in practice?
This ruling has significant practical implications for shareholder-managing directors and their limited liability companies (GmbHs). Many articles of association contain similar provisions for resolving conflicts in the event of a tie, without the parties involved being aware of the consequences under social security law.
- A 50 per cent shareholding does not automatically preclude the employment from being classified as dependent employment.
- Tie-breaking clauses may mean that you are required to pay social security contributions even though you are a co-shareholder.
- Additional contributions may amount to substantial sums and may be claimed retrospectively.
- Articles of association should be reviewed for such clauses before a tax audit takes place.
Anyone acting as a managing director who is also a shareholder, or running a limited liability company (GmbH) with several shareholders, should have the articles of association and their social security status carefully reviewed. If in doubt, it is advisable to seek legal advice.
Federal Social Court (BSG), judgment of 23 July 2026, Case No. B 12 BA 10/24 R
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.