Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

No input VAT deduction when a flat-rate allowance is calculated both ways

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) refu­ses to allow input VAT deduc­tion: anyo­ne who mere­ly adds up and deducts a flat-rate expen­se allo­wan­ce is not pro­vi­ding a ser­vice for VAT purposes. 
No input VAT deduction when a flat-rate allowance is calculated both ways

No input VAT deduction when a flat-rate allowance is calculated both ways

In its jud­ge­ment of 16 April 2026, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) ruled that a tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy may not deduct input VAT from invoices if a flat-rate fee is not, in rea­li­ty, based on a genui­ne exch­an­ge of ser­vices. The case refe­rence is V R 1/25, published on 13 August 2026.

What was the case about?

A tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy (the clai­mant) sup­pli­ed staff to a public limi­t­ed com­pa­ny (AG) to work in its staff can­teens. Under a sup­ple­men­ta­ry agree­ment to the tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment con­tract, the sup­pli­ed staff were per­mit­ted to use the AG’s can­teens on the same pre­fe­ren­ti­al terms as the AG’s own employees.

For this can­teen access, the cli­ent com­pa­ny invoi­ced the tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy a flat-rate fee per employee and per day of assign­ment, shown with VAT ite­mi­sed sepa­ra­te­ly. Inso­far as the tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy clai­med the input VAT on this in its VAT return, this initi­al­ly see­med logi­cal. What was unu­su­al about this arran­ge­ment, howe­ver, was that the tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy imme­dia­te­ly char­ged exact­ly the same amount back to the AG, included within the total remu­ne­ra­ti­on for the pro­vi­si­on of staff.

During seve­ral tax audits cove­ring the years 2010 to 2017, the tax office refu­sed to allow input tax deduc­tion. The Tax Court initi­al­ly upheld the cla­im. Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court over­tur­ned this jud­ge­ment and ruled in favour of the tax office.

The Federal Fiscal Court’s reasoning

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) made it clear that an input tax deduc­tion requi­res that a ser­vice has actual­ly been pro­vi­ded. It is not suf­fi­ci­ent sim­ply to have an invoice show­ing VAT. The tax must also actual­ly be legal­ly paya­ble in respect of a ser­vice provided.

In this spe­ci­fic case, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) held that the­re was no genui­ne exch­an­ge of ser­vices bet­ween the parent com­pa­ny and the tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy. The reason: when all the con­tracts were con­side­red from an over­all eco­no­mic per­spec­ti­ve, the parent com­pa­ny was inten­ded to bear the can­teen cos­ts alo­ne. Alt­hough the lump sum was initi­al­ly char­ged to the tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy, it was then imme­dia­te­ly re-char­ged back in the same amount. The tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy mere­ly acted as an inter­me­dia­ry in the parent company’s inter­nal cost allo­ca­ti­on process.

A bene­fit pro­vi­ded by the clai­mant to its own employees was also ruled out becau­se the AG gran­ted the dis­coun­ted can­teen faci­li­ties direct­ly and inde­pendent­ly to the employees on secondment.

Further consequence: incorrect tax statement

As the invoices issued by the public limi­t­ed com­pa­ny to the tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy did not cor­re­spond to any actu­al ser­vice pro­vi­ded, the same appli­es, con­ver­se­ly, to the cre­dit note invoices issued by the tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy to the public limi­t­ed com­pa­ny. The tem­po­ra­ry employ­ment agen­cy show­ed VAT as paya­ble on the­se invoices, even though no ser­vice had been pro­vi­ded. The con­se­quence is that it is nevert­hel­ess lia­ble for this VAT under the pro­vi­si­ons gover­ning the unaut­ho­ri­sed show­ing of tax (Sec­tion 14c(2) of the Value Added Tax Act), but can­not simul­ta­neous­ly deduct it as input tax.

What does this mean in practice?

The jud­ge­ment high­lights how dan­ge­rous con­trac­tu­al arran­ge­ments can be whe­re cos­ts are for­mal­ly pas­sed on but, in eco­no­mic terms, no genui­ne flow of ser­vices takes place. Par­ti­cu­lar­ly in the case of tem­po­ra­ry agen­cy work con­tracts with sup­ple­men­ta­ry agree­ments, it is worth car­ry­ing out a detail­ed VAT review of the over­all struc­tu­re. Com­pa­nies that use simi­lar arran­ge­ments should have their con­tracts and the tax tre­at­ment careful­ly reviewed.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this