Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Federal Court of Justice: A refurbished old building may be exempt from the rent cap

Federal Court of Justice: A refurbished old building may be exempt from the rent cap

Anyo­ne who res­to­res a com­ple­te­ly dila­pi­da­ted, unin­ha­bi­ta­ble buil­ding at con­sidera­ble expen­se may, under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, invo­ke the ‘new-build exemp­ti­on’ from the rent cap. This was ruled by the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce in a jud­ge­ment of 1 July 2026 (Case No. VIII ZR 50/23).

What was the case about?

In 2015, a land­la­dy had purcha­sed a buil­ding in Ber­lin, built befo­re 1918, which was in a dila­pi­da­ted sta­te. Win­dows had been bri­cked up or board­ed up with chip­board, plas­ter was fal­ling from the cei­lings and walls, the­re were no elec­tri­cal or hea­ting sys­tems whatsoe­ver, the­re were no sta­ir rai­lings and the flat doors had been unhin­ged. In short: the buil­ding was uninhabitable.

The owner inves­ted more than two mil­li­on euros in the refur­bish­ment. She reno­va­ted the roof, faça­de, win­dows, all inte­ri­or walls, the enti­re hea­ting and elec­tri­cal sys­tems, as well as the bath­rooms and kit­chens. She then let one of the flats from June 2017 to Febru­ary 2021. The ten­ant paid rent that excee­ded the limit per­mit­ted under the rent con­trol sche­me – ten per cent abo­ve the local com­pa­ra­ti­ve rent. He deman­ded a refund of what he con­side­red to be the excess rent he had paid.

What does the new-build exemption say?

In accordance with Sec­tion 556f, first sen­tence, of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB), the rent con­trol sche­me does not app­ly to resi­den­ti­al pro­per­ty that is first occu­p­ied and let after 1 Octo­ber 2014. This pro­vi­si­on is inten­ded to crea­te an incen­ti­ve for invest­ment and to pro­mo­te the con­s­truc­tion of new flats wit­hout hin­de­ring it through sta­te-impo­sed rent caps.

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) has now cla­ri­fied that this con­cept of ‘new build’ is to be inter­pre­ted more broad­ly than pre­vious­ly assu­med. The excep­ti­on appli­es not only to buil­dings con­s­truc­ted enti­re­ly from scratch, but also to resi­den­ti­al accom­mo­da­ti­on which, due to seve­re dama­ge, sim­ply no lon­ger exis­ted and has been per­ma­nent­ly res­to­red through exten­si­ve buil­ding works. The decisi­ve fac­tor is that the buil­ding works result in resi­den­ti­al accom­mo­da­ti­on that was not pre­vious­ly available.

What are the requirements?

In dra­wing this distinc­tion, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) bases its approach on the prin­ci­ples of the Housing Pro­mo­ti­on Act. Accor­ding to this, the finan­cial out­lay for the res­to­ra­ti­on must amount to at least one third of the cos­ts that would be incur­red for a com­pa­ra­ble new-build flat, exclu­ding the cost of the land. Mere moder­ni­sa­ti­on of housing that remains habi­ta­ble, on the other hand, does not fall under this excep­ti­on, but at most under the sepa­ra­te moder­ni­sa­ti­on excep­ti­on pro­vi­ded for in the Act.

What about wilful damage?

One pos­si­ble objec­tion is: Could a land­lord deli­bera­te­ly dama­ge a buil­ding in order to later invo­ke the new-build excep­ti­on? The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) con­siders this to be a very rare excep­tio­nal case, as the reno­va­ti­on cos­ts invol­ved are usual­ly so high that such a cour­se of action makes no eco­no­mic sen­se. In cases of genui­ne abu­se of rights, the prin­ci­ple of good faith remains in place as a cor­rec­ti­ve measure.

In this spe­ci­fic case, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce was unable to reach a final decis­i­on becau­se the­re were no pre­cise fin­dings regar­ding the actu­al reno­va­ti­on cos­ts. The Regio­nal Court must the­r­e­fo­re rehear the case.

What does this mean for landlords and tenants?

The ruling is signi­fi­cant for land­lords who purcha­se and refur­bish pro­per­ties in serious need of reno­va­ti­on. Tho­se who can pro­vi­de evi­dence of the cos­ts incur­red may not be sub­ject to the rent cap. Ten­ants should be awa­re that mere­ly clai­ming that exten­si­ve refur­bish­ment has taken place is not suf­fi­ci­ent. The actu­al cos­ts must be sub­stan­tia­ted with con­cre­te evi­dence. Any land­lord or ten­ant who needs cla­ri­ty regar­ding their own situa­ti­on should seek legal advice.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this