Anyone who restores a completely dilapidated, uninhabitable building at considerable expense may, under certain circumstances, invoke the ‘new-build exemption’ from the rent cap. This was ruled by the Federal Court of Justice in a judgement of 1 July 2026 (Case No. VIII ZR 50/23).
What was the case about?
In 2015, a landlady had purchased a building in Berlin, built before 1918, which was in a dilapidated state. Windows had been bricked up or boarded up with chipboard, plaster was falling from the ceilings and walls, there were no electrical or heating systems whatsoever, there were no stair railings and the flat doors had been unhinged. In short: the building was uninhabitable.
The owner invested more than two million euros in the refurbishment. She renovated the roof, façade, windows, all interior walls, the entire heating and electrical systems, as well as the bathrooms and kitchens. She then let one of the flats from June 2017 to February 2021. The tenant paid rent that exceeded the limit permitted under the rent control scheme – ten per cent above the local comparative rent. He demanded a refund of what he considered to be the excess rent he had paid.
What does the new-build exemption say?
In accordance with Section 556f, first sentence, of the German Civil Code (BGB), the rent control scheme does not apply to residential property that is first occupied and let after 1 October 2014. This provision is intended to create an incentive for investment and to promote the construction of new flats without hindering it through state-imposed rent caps.
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has now clarified that this concept of ‘new build’ is to be interpreted more broadly than previously assumed. The exception applies not only to buildings constructed entirely from scratch, but also to residential accommodation which, due to severe damage, simply no longer existed and has been permanently restored through extensive building works. The decisive factor is that the building works result in residential accommodation that was not previously available.
What are the requirements?
In drawing this distinction, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) bases its approach on the principles of the Housing Promotion Act. According to this, the financial outlay for the restoration must amount to at least one third of the costs that would be incurred for a comparable new-build flat, excluding the cost of the land. Mere modernisation of housing that remains habitable, on the other hand, does not fall under this exception, but at most under the separate modernisation exception provided for in the Act.
What about wilful damage?
One possible objection is: Could a landlord deliberately damage a building in order to later invoke the new-build exception? The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) considers this to be a very rare exceptional case, as the renovation costs involved are usually so high that such a course of action makes no economic sense. In cases of genuine abuse of rights, the principle of good faith remains in place as a corrective measure.
In this specific case, the Federal Court of Justice was unable to reach a final decision because there were no precise findings regarding the actual renovation costs. The Regional Court must therefore rehear the case.
What does this mean for landlords and tenants?
The ruling is significant for landlords who purchase and refurbish properties in serious need of renovation. Those who can provide evidence of the costs incurred may not be subject to the rent cap. Tenants should be aware that merely claiming that extensive refurbishment has taken place is not sufficient. The actual costs must be substantiated with concrete evidence. Any landlord or tenant who needs clarity regarding their own situation should seek legal advice.
Source: Haufe: Property
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.