An employer cannot simply withdraw the option for employees to work from home without a valid reason and order them to return to the office on a permanent basis. The Düsseldorf Labour Court has clarified this in a recent judgement (case number not yet officially published, decision 2025/2026).
The case: IT employee loses his days working from home
An IT specialist had been working for the company since 2014 and had been working from home on Mondays and Fridays for many years. This amounted to two out of five working days per week. In the summer of 2025, there were difficulties in the department: his line manager fell ill whilst he himself was on holiday. Colleagues then approached the senior manager, who identified alleged shortcomings in project planning and communication. An important IT project had been delayed.
The manager’s response was an email instructing the employee to come into the office every day from then on. Later, he was at least allowed to continue working from home on Fridays. The employee did not accept this and took legal action.
No legally enforceable right to work from home
The court first examined whether the employee had any legal entitlement at all to the days he had spent working from home to date. The conclusion was clear: no. Neither the employment contract nor any established company practice nor any binding general undertaking by the employer gave rise to such an entitlement.
The wording of the company’s internal policy on working from home was decisive in this regard. It explicitly stated that working remotely was a Privilegeand would require the supervisor’s prior written consent. The court did not regard this as a binding promise of benefit, but rather as a voluntary concession subject to approval. Nor was the fact that the employee had worked from home for years sufficient to establish a permanent entitlement.
The instruction was nevertheless invalid
Although the employee was not therefore entitled to work from home, the employer’s instruction to work exclusively from the office was unsuccessful. This is where the so-called Management authoritythe employer’s role comes into play: Under Section 106 of the Trade Regulation Act, an employer is, in principle, entitled to determine the place of work. However, this instruction must at its discretionbe appropriate, i.e. objectively justified and proportionate.
This is precisely where the employer fell short. It was unable to demonstrate why compulsory attendance at the office would, in concrete terms, improve project outcomes, communication or teamwork. The court therefore did not regard the instruction as an objective measure to improve work processes, but rather as a form of punishment for the employee.
What does this mean for employees and employers?
The judgement highlights an important limitation:
- Employees cannot derive a permanent entitlement solely from the fact that working from home has become established practice if the company’s policy is subject to approval.
- Whilst employers are permitted to restrict or withdraw the right to work from home, they may only do so for a reasonable and objective reason. A blanket instruction to return to the office without a specific justification is not sufficient.
- Wording in internal guidelines that describes working from home as a privilege and requires the line manager’s approval protects employers from unintended legal claims.
Any employee who receives such an instruction, or any employer wishing to draw up working-from-home arrangements, should carefully review the precise terms of the internal agreements. In individual cases, it is advisable to seek advice on employment law.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.