Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Work-from-home directive rejected: employer must provide objective grounds

Work-from-home directive rejected: employer must provide objective grounds

An employ­er can­not sim­ply with­draw the opti­on for employees to work from home wit­hout a valid reason and order them to return to the office on a per­ma­nent basis. The Düs­sel­dorf Labour Court has cla­ri­fied this in a recent jud­ge­ment (case num­ber not yet offi­ci­al­ly published, decis­i­on 2025/2026).

The case: IT employee loses his days working from home

An IT spe­cia­list had been working for the com­pa­ny sin­ce 2014 and had been working from home on Mon­days and Fri­days for many years. This amoun­ted to two out of five working days per week. In the sum­mer of 2025, the­re were dif­fi­cul­ties in the depart­ment: his line mana­ger fell ill whilst he hims­elf was on holi­day. Col­le­agues then approa­ched the seni­or mana­ger, who iden­ti­fied alle­ged short­co­mings in pro­ject plan­ning and com­mu­ni­ca­ti­on. An important IT pro­ject had been delayed.

The manager’s respon­se was an email ins­truc­ting the employee to come into the office every day from then on. Later, he was at least allo­wed to con­ti­nue working from home on Fri­days. The employee did not accept this and took legal action.

No legally enforceable right to work from home

The court first exami­ned whe­ther the employee had any legal entit­le­ment at all to the days he had spent working from home to date. The con­clu­si­on was clear: no. Neither the employ­ment con­tract nor any estab­lished com­pa­ny prac­ti­ce nor any bin­ding gene­ral under­ta­king by the employ­er gave rise to such an entitlement.

The wor­ding of the company’s inter­nal poli­cy on working from home was decisi­ve in this regard. It expli­cit­ly sta­ted that working remo­te­ly was a Pri­vi­le­geand would requi­re the supervisor’s pri­or writ­ten con­sent. The court did not regard this as a bin­ding pro­mi­se of bene­fit, but rather as a vol­un­t­a­ry con­ces­si­on sub­ject to appr­oval. Nor was the fact that the employee had work­ed from home for years suf­fi­ci­ent to estab­lish a per­ma­nent entitlement.

The instruction was nevertheless invalid

Alt­hough the employee was not the­r­e­fo­re entit­led to work from home, the employer’s ins­truc­tion to work exclu­si­ve­ly from the office was unsuc­cessful. This is whe­re the so-cal­led Manage­ment aut­ho­ri­tythe employer’s role comes into play: Under Sec­tion 106 of the Trade Regu­la­ti­on Act, an employ­er is, in prin­ci­ple, entit­led to deter­mi­ne the place of work. Howe­ver, this ins­truc­tion must at its dis­cre­ti­onbe appro­pria­te, i.e. objec­tively jus­ti­fied and proportionate.

This is pre­cis­e­ly whe­re the employ­er fell short. It was unable to demons­tra­te why com­pul­so­ry atten­dance at the office would, in con­cre­te terms, impro­ve pro­ject out­co­mes, com­mu­ni­ca­ti­on or team­work. The court the­r­e­fo­re did not regard the ins­truc­tion as an objec­ti­ve mea­su­re to impro­ve work pro­ces­ses, but rather as a form of punish­ment for the employee.

What does this mean for employees and employers?

The jud­ge­ment high­lights an important limitation:

  • Employees can­not deri­ve a per­ma­nent entit­le­ment sole­ly from the fact that working from home has beco­me estab­lished prac­ti­ce if the company’s poli­cy is sub­ject to approval.
  • Whilst employ­ers are per­mit­ted to rest­rict or with­draw the right to work from home, they may only do so for a reasonable and objec­ti­ve reason. A blan­ket ins­truc­tion to return to the office wit­hout a spe­ci­fic jus­ti­fi­ca­ti­on is not sufficient.
  • Wor­ding in inter­nal gui­de­lines that descri­bes working from home as a pri­vi­le­ge and requi­res the line manager’s appr­oval pro­tects employ­ers from unin­ten­ded legal claims.

Any employee who recei­ves such an ins­truc­tion, or any employ­er wis­hing to draw up working-from-home arran­ge­ments, should careful­ly review the pre­cise terms of the inter­nal agree­ments. In indi­vi­du­al cases, it is advi­sa­ble to seek advice on employ­ment law.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this