Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Fixed-term employment contracts: What currently applies and what is set to change soon

Fixed-term employment contracts: What currently applies and what is set to change soon

Fixed-term employ­ment con­tracts are the excep­ti­on rather than the rule under Ger­man employ­ment law. The Part-Time and Fixed-Term Employ­ment Act (TzBfG) sets out the con­di­ti­ons under which an employ­ment rela­ti­onship may be of fixed dura­ti­on. The Fede­ral Govern­ment is curr­ent­ly plan­ning a signi­fi­cant rela­xa­ti­on of the­se regulations.

What the government is planning

Under the cur­rent reform pro­po­sals, fixed-term con­tracts wit­hout objec­ti­ve grounds will in future be per­mit­ted to last up to 48 months and may be exten­ded up to six times. At pre­sent, the maxi­mum dura­ti­on is 24 months, with three exten­si­ons per­mit­ted. The rela­xed rules are set to app­ly to new hires until the end of 2030. The­re are also plans to abo­lish the requi­re­ment for fixed-term con­tracts to be in wri­ting with effect from 1 Janu­ary 2027. It should then also be pos­si­ble to be re-employ­ed by the same employ­er. Important: The­se are, as yet, poli­ti­cal announce­ments, not laws that have been pas­sed. It has not yet been deci­ded when and in what form the chan­ges will come into force.

An overview of the current legal situation

Anyo­ne wis­hing to draw up a fixed-term employ­ment con­tract today must adhe­re strict­ly to the appli­ca­ble rules. An inva­lid fixed term auto­ma­ti­cal­ly results in a per­ma­nent employ­ment rela­ti­onship. This can have signi­fi­cant con­se­quen­ces for employers.

Fixed-term contract on objective grounds

The stan­dard prac­ti­ce is to offer a fixed-term con­tract on objec­ti­ve grounds. Per­mis­si­ble grounds include, for exam­p­le, the pro­ba­tio­na­ry peri­od for new staff, cove­ring for col­le­agues on sick lea­ve, or a tem­po­ra­ry increase in workload. The sta­tu­to­ry list in Sec­tion 14(1) of the TzBfGThis list is not exhaus­ti­ve, but it does pro­vi­de a good guide.

Fixed-term contract without objective grounds

A fixed-term con­tract is pos­si­ble even wit­hout objec­ti­ve grounds, but only under strict con­di­ti­ons. The con­tract may run for a maxi­mum of two years and may be exten­ded no more than three times within that peri­od. For new­ly estab­lished com­pa­nies, more gene­rous terms of up to four years app­ly during the first four years fol­lo­wing incor­po­ra­ti­on. For employees aged 52 or over who were pre­vious­ly unem­ploy­ed or par­ti­ci­pa­ting in a sup­port sche­me for at least four months, fixed-term con­tracts of up to five years are pos­si­ble even wit­hout objec­ti­ve grounds.

The ban on prior employment

In prin­ci­ple, a fixed-term con­tract wit­hout objec­ti­ve grounds is only per­mit­ted for genui­ne new appoint­ments. If the employee has pre­vious­ly work­ed for the same employ­er, a fur­ther fixed-term con­tract wit­hout objec­ti­ve grounds is gene­ral­ly not per­mit­ted. In 2018, the Fede­ral Con­sti­tu­tio­nal Court cla­ri­fied that this pro­hi­bi­ti­on must be inter­pre­ted strict­ly (BVerfG, decis­i­on of 6 June 2018).

Sin­ce then, the Fede­ral Labour Court (BAG) has only allo­wed excep­ti­ons if the pre­vious employ­ment took place a very long time ago, was of very short dura­ti­on, or was of a com­ple­te­ly dif­fe­rent natu­rewas. A pre­vious employ­ment rela­ti­onship dating back eight years was not dee­med by the Fede­ral Labour Court (BAG) to con­sti­tu­te an excep­ti­on. Only whe­re the inter­val was 22 years did the court reco­g­ni­se an exception.

Sin­ce 1 Janu­ary 2026, a spe­cial rule has appli­ed to old-age pen­sio­ners: under cer­tain con­di­ti­ons, they may also be employ­ed on a fixed-term basis wit­hout cau­se by a for­mer employ­er, pro­vi­ded that the total dura­ti­on does not exceed eight years and the­re are no more than twel­ve fixed-term contracts.

The written form is still mandatory at present

At pre­sent, an agree­ment on a fixed-term con­tract must be set out in wri­ting, befo­re the employee starts work. A qua­li­fied elec­tro­nic signa­tu­re is per­mit­ted. Anyo­ne who fails to com­ple­te this step risks the fixed-term con­tract being inva­lid. Employ­ers should not unde­re­sti­ma­te this for­mal requirement.

In view of the plan­ned legis­la­ti­ve chan­ges and the some­ti­mes unclear case law, it is advi­sa­ble to seek advice on employ­ment law when draf­ting fixed-term employ­ment con­tracts on a case-by-case basis.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this