Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Distance learning course with 7 hours per week: Child benefit despite minimal study commitment?

Müns­ter Regio­nal Court: A distance-lear­ning cour­se com­pri­sing just 7 hours per week may be regard­ed as voca­tio­nal trai­ning. What this means for child benefit. 
Distance learning course with 7 hours per week: Child benefit despite minimal study commitment?

Distance learning course with 7 hours per week: Child benefit despite minimal study commitment?

Par­ents of child­ren of full age who are in edu­ca­ti­on gene­ral­ly recei­ve child bene­fit until the child rea­ches the age of 25. But when, for tax pur­po­ses, is a distance-lear­ning cour­se actual­ly con­side­red voca­tio­nal trai­ning? A recent ruling by the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court pro­vi­des a clear ans­wer to this ques­ti­on, which has prac­ti­cal impli­ca­ti­ons for many families.

The case study: Photo design via distance learning

In May 2025, a young woman began an 18-month distance-lear­ning cour­se to beco­me a cer­ti­fied pho­to desi­gner with the pro­vi­der ILS. The cour­se was accre­di­ted by the Sta­te Cen­tral Office for Distance Lear­ning and com­pri­sed a total of 542 tea­ching hours. The cour­se pro­vi­der sta­ted that the avera­ge stu­dy load was 7 hours per week. In addi­ti­on to crea­ti­ve con­tent, the cour­se also cover­ed legal prin­ci­ples and prac­ti­cal pro­fes­sio­nal topics.

The woman had not com­ple­ted any voca­tio­nal trai­ning and hoped to work as a pho­to­grapher or pho­to desi­gner in the future. She also held a part-time job working around nine hours a week. By the time of the dis­pu­te, she had alre­a­dy com­ple­ted eight out of 19 set assign­ments, most­ly achie­ving good to very good results.

Family Benefits Office rejected the child benefit claim

The Fami­ly Bene­fits Office refu­sed to pay the child bene­fit. Their reaso­ning was that seven hours a week was too few to be con­side­red serious voca­tio­nal trai­ning. Fur­ther­mo­re, the aut­ho­ri­ty fun­da­men­tal­ly doub­ted whe­ther the cour­se was of a trai­ning natu­re at all. The know­ledge impar­ted could just as easi­ly be used for lei­su­re acti­vi­ties or as a hob­by. Fur­ther­mo­re, the Job­cent­re had neither reco­g­nis­ed nor fun­ded the cour­se as a voca­tio­nal pre­pa­ra­ti­on measure.

Court considers vocational training to have been completed

In its jud­ge­ment of 6 May 2026 (Case No. 9 K 2730/25 Kg), the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court ruled in favour of the clai­mant. The court cla­ri­fied: Voca­tio­nal trai­ning within the mea­ning of the Inco­me Tax Act (Sec­tion 32(4), first sen­tence, No. 2a of the EStG) is not depen­dent on a spe­ci­fic mini­mum dura­ti­on. The sole decisi­ve fac­tor is whe­ther the child is pre­pa­ring serious­ly and con­sis­t­ent­ly for a spe­ci­fic care­er goal.

Accor­ding to the court, the often-cited limit of 10 hours per week, which the Fami­ly Bene­fits Office used as a bench­mark, appli­es only to spe­ci­fic cate­go­ries such as lan­guage cour­ses or au pair pla­ce­ments. In such cases, a distinc­tion must be made bet­ween the­se acti­vi­ties and mere lei­su­re pur­suits or per­so­nal deve­lo­p­ment. This limit can­not be appli­ed to a sta­te-appro­ved, struc­tu­red distance-lear­ning cour­se with job-spe­ci­fic content.

The clai­mant demons­tra­ted that she was taking the cour­se serious­ly by suc­cessful­ly sub­mit­ting the set assign­ments. It was the­r­e­fo­re cle­ar­ly not a case of mere nomi­nal enrol­ment wit­hout any actu­al par­ti­ci­pa­ti­on in the cour­se. The absence of a fun­ding decis­i­on from the Job­cent­re was irrele­vant to the tax assessment.

What does this mean for families?

The ruling shows that distance-lear­ning cour­ses are not, across the board, trea­ted less favour­a­b­ly than face-to-face cour­ses when it comes to child bene­fit. Par­ents who­se child is under­ta­king a reco­g­nis­ed distance-lear­ning cour­se should not sim­ply accept a rejec­tion by the fami­ly bene­fits office. The decisi­ve fac­tor is whe­ther the cour­se is aimed at acqui­ring know­ledge that can be put to pro­fes­sio­nal use and whe­ther the child can demons­tra­te that they are under­ta­king it in earnest.

In indi­vi­du­al cases, it is advi­sa­ble to seek tax advice, par­ti­cu­lar­ly if the fami­ly bene­fits office demands the repay­ment of child bene­fit retro­s­pec­tively or refu­ses to reco­g­ni­se the child.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this