Parents of children of full age who are in education generally receive child benefit until the child reaches the age of 25. But when, for tax purposes, is a distance-learning course actually considered vocational training? A recent ruling by the Münster Finance Court provides a clear answer to this question, which has practical implications for many families.
The case study: Photo design via distance learning
In May 2025, a young woman began an 18-month distance-learning course to become a certified photo designer with the provider ILS. The course was accredited by the State Central Office for Distance Learning and comprised a total of 542 teaching hours. The course provider stated that the average study load was 7 hours per week. In addition to creative content, the course also covered legal principles and practical professional topics.
The woman had not completed any vocational training and hoped to work as a photographer or photo designer in the future. She also held a part-time job working around nine hours a week. By the time of the dispute, she had already completed eight out of 19 set assignments, mostly achieving good to very good results.
Family Benefits Office rejected the child benefit claim
The Family Benefits Office refused to pay the child benefit. Their reasoning was that seven hours a week was too few to be considered serious vocational training. Furthermore, the authority fundamentally doubted whether the course was of a training nature at all. The knowledge imparted could just as easily be used for leisure activities or as a hobby. Furthermore, the Jobcentre had neither recognised nor funded the course as a vocational preparation measure.
Court considers vocational training to have been completed
In its judgement of 6 May 2026 (Case No. 9 K 2730/25 Kg), the Münster Finance Court ruled in favour of the claimant. The court clarified: Vocational training within the meaning of the Income Tax Act (Section 32(4), first sentence, No. 2a of the EStG) is not dependent on a specific minimum duration. The sole decisive factor is whether the child is preparing seriously and consistently for a specific career goal.
According to the court, the often-cited limit of 10 hours per week, which the Family Benefits Office used as a benchmark, applies only to specific categories such as language courses or au pair placements. In such cases, a distinction must be made between these activities and mere leisure pursuits or personal development. This limit cannot be applied to a state-approved, structured distance-learning course with job-specific content.
The claimant demonstrated that she was taking the course seriously by successfully submitting the set assignments. It was therefore clearly not a case of mere nominal enrolment without any actual participation in the course. The absence of a funding decision from the Jobcentre was irrelevant to the tax assessment.
What does this mean for families?
The ruling shows that distance-learning courses are not, across the board, treated less favourably than face-to-face courses when it comes to child benefit. Parents whose child is undertaking a recognised distance-learning course should not simply accept a rejection by the family benefits office. The decisive factor is whether the course is aimed at acquiring knowledge that can be put to professional use and whether the child can demonstrate that they are undertaking it in earnest.
In individual cases, it is advisable to seek tax advice, particularly if the family benefits office demands the repayment of child benefit retrospectively or refuses to recognise the child.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.