Public limited companies are no longer the preserve of listed corporations. Family businesses, in particular, are deliberately opting for the public limited company structure. One practical issue crops up time and again: the transfer of shares that do not exist in physical form. Whilst this may sound abstract at first, it presents specific legal pitfalls.
What are unregistered shares?
Traditionally, a share certificate embodies the right of membership in the form of a physical document. Since 1966, however, public limited companies have been able to stipulate in their articles of association that no such certificates shall be issued. In practice, this is the norm for unlisted companies. The cost savings are obvious: no printing costs, no safekeeping, and no time-consuming process of declaring shares void in the event of loss.
However, without a certificate, the share cannot be transferred simply by handing it over. Instead, an assignment of the membership right in accordance with Sections 398 and 413 of the Civil Code is mandatory.
The principle of specificity as a key obstacle
The assignment is not subject to any formal requirements; in theory, it can therefore even be made verbally. The key problem lies elsewhere: property law requires it to be clearly identifiable which shares are to be transferred. This so-called ‘principle of specificity’ sounds simple, but in practice it regularly leads to errors.
If the shares are not sufficiently individualised, the transfer is invalid. In the worst-case scenario, the previous shareholder remains the legal owner, even though another person has already taken over the shares in economic terms.
When is which description sufficient?
Various features are available for customisation:
- Share numbersoffer the greatest legal certainty, but unlike in the case of a GmbH, they are not required by law in the case of AGs.
- Origin of the shares, i.e. whether they stem from the company’s incorporation or from a capital increase, can be used to distinguish between them.
- Class of shares(for example, preference shares), par value or encumbrances such as a usufruct are further characteristics.
If all of a shareholder’s shares are completely identical and cannot be distinguished on the basis of any of the characteristics mentioned, the prevailing view is that it is sufficient to state the company, the transferor and the number of shares. This is in line with the practice for securities held in global certificates or in a centralised book-entry system, where the number of shares is also deemed sufficient.
Special features of registered and restricted shares
In the case of registered shares, entry in the register of shareholders is not a prerequisite for the transfer to take effect, but it is necessary in order to be able to assert rights against the company. Anyone acquiring shares should therefore ensure that they are entered in the register without delay.
The requirements are even stricter in the case of so-called registered shares subject to transfer restrictions. In such cases, the Articles of Association provide for the company to reserve the right to give its consent. Without this consent, the transfer is invalid or, at the very least, remains provisionally invalid until the company gives its consent.
What does this mean for family-run companies?
Particularly in the case of business succession or gifts within the family, errors in the drafting of contracts are often only discovered years later, for example in the event of a death or a dispute between shareholders. Anyone transferring shares in a family-owned public limited company should draw up the transfer agreement in writing and describe the shares as precisely as possible. If in doubt, it is advisable to seek legal advice before signing the agreement.
Source: Haufe: Law
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.