Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Uncertificated shares in a family-owned public limited company: How to ensure a smooth transfer

Trans­fer­ring unre­gis­tered shares cor­rect­ly in a fami­ly-owned public limi­t­ed com­pa­ny: Why the prin­ci­ple of spe­ci­fi­ci­ty is so important. 
Uncertificated shares in a family-owned public limited company: How to ensure a smooth transfer

Uncertificated shares in a family-owned public limited company: How to ensure a smooth transfer

Public limi­t­ed com­pa­nies are no lon­ger the pre­ser­ve of lis­ted cor­po­ra­ti­ons. Fami­ly busi­nesses, in par­ti­cu­lar, are deli­bera­te­ly opting for the public limi­t­ed com­pa­ny struc­tu­re. One prac­ti­cal issue crops up time and again: the trans­fer of shares that do not exist in phy­si­cal form. Whilst this may sound abs­tract at first, it pres­ents spe­ci­fic legal pitfalls.

What are unregistered shares?

Tra­di­tio­nal­ly, a share cer­ti­fi­ca­te embo­dies the right of mem­ber­ship in the form of a phy­si­cal docu­ment. Sin­ce 1966, howe­ver, public limi­t­ed com­pa­nies have been able to sti­pu­la­te in their artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on that no such cer­ti­fi­ca­tes shall be issued. In prac­ti­ce, this is the norm for unlis­ted com­pa­nies. The cost savings are obvious: no prin­ting cos­ts, no safe­kee­ping, and no time-con­sum­ing pro­cess of decla­ring shares void in the event of loss.

Howe­ver, wit­hout a cer­ti­fi­ca­te, the share can­not be trans­fer­red sim­ply by han­ding it over. Ins­tead, an assign­ment of the mem­ber­ship right in accordance with Sec­tions 398 and 413 of the Civil Code is mandatory.

The principle of specificity as a key obstacle

The assign­ment is not sub­ject to any for­mal requi­re­ments; in theo­ry, it can the­r­e­fo­re even be made ver­bal­ly. The key pro­blem lies else­whe­re: pro­per­ty law requi­res it to be cle­ar­ly iden­ti­fia­ble which shares are to be trans­fer­red. This so-cal­led ‘prin­ci­ple of spe­ci­fi­ci­ty’ sounds simp­le, but in prac­ti­ce it regu­lar­ly leads to errors.

If the shares are not suf­fi­ci­ent­ly indi­vi­dua­li­sed, the trans­fer is inva­lid. In the worst-case sce­na­rio, the pre­vious share­hol­der remains the legal owner, even though ano­ther per­son has alre­a­dy taken over the shares in eco­no­mic terms.

When is which description sufficient?

Various fea­tures are available for customisation:

  • Share num­bersoffer the grea­test legal cer­tain­ty, but unli­ke in the case of a GmbH, they are not requi­red by law in the case of AGs.
  • Ori­gin of the shares, i.e. whe­ther they stem from the company’s incor­po­ra­ti­on or from a capi­tal increase, can be used to distin­gu­ish bet­ween them.
  • Class of shares(for exam­p­le, pre­fe­rence shares), par value or encum­bran­ces such as a usu­fruct are fur­ther characteristics.

If all of a shareholder’s shares are com­ple­te­ly iden­ti­cal and can­not be distin­gu­is­hed on the basis of any of the cha­rac­te­ristics men­tio­ned, the pre­vai­ling view is that it is suf­fi­ci­ent to sta­te the com­pa­ny, the trans­fer­or and the num­ber of shares. This is in line with the prac­ti­ce for secu­ri­ties held in glo­bal cer­ti­fi­ca­tes or in a cen­tra­li­sed book-ent­ry sys­tem, whe­re the num­ber of shares is also dee­med sufficient.

Special features of registered and restricted shares

In the case of regis­tered shares, ent­ry in the regis­ter of share­hol­ders is not a pre­re­qui­si­te for the trans­fer to take effect, but it is neces­sa­ry in order to be able to assert rights against the com­pa­ny. Anyo­ne acqui­ring shares should the­r­e­fo­re ensu­re that they are ente­red in the regis­ter wit­hout delay.

The requi­re­ments are even stric­ter in the case of so-cal­led regis­tered shares sub­ject to trans­fer rest­ric­tions. In such cases, the Artic­les of Asso­cia­ti­on pro­vi­de for the com­pa­ny to reser­ve the right to give its con­sent. Wit­hout this con­sent, the trans­fer is inva­lid or, at the very least, remains pro­vi­sio­nal­ly inva­lid until the com­pa­ny gives its consent.

What does this mean for family-run companies?

Par­ti­cu­lar­ly in the case of busi­ness suc­ces­si­on or gifts within the fami­ly, errors in the draf­ting of con­tracts are often only dis­co­ver­ed years later, for exam­p­le in the event of a death or a dis­pu­te bet­ween share­hol­ders. Anyo­ne trans­fer­ring shares in a fami­ly-owned public limi­t­ed com­pa­ny should draw up the trans­fer agree­ment in wri­ting and descri­be the shares as pre­cis­e­ly as pos­si­ble. If in doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice befo­re sig­ning the agreement.

Source: Hau­fe: Law

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this