Anyone who gifts or bequeaths shares in a company hopes to benefit from the inheritance tax relief available for business assets. However, not everything that forms part of a company qualifies for this relief. So-called ‘administrative assets’ are excluded from this exemption. The Düsseldorf Finance Court has now clarified in a noteworthy ruling that land used for agricultural purposes and owned by a company is not to be classified as administrative assets.
What are administrative assets?
Section 13b(4)(1) of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act (ErbStG) provides that certain assets are deemed to be administrative assets and therefore do not qualify for the tax relief available for business assets. A typical example is land let or leased to third parties. However, the Act contains counter-exceptions, i.e. cases in which, despite being made available to third parties, the assets do not constitute administrative assets. One such counter-exception concerns land made available for agricultural or forestry use.
The case: Farmland in the USA, a gift in Germany
In this specific case, shares in a commercially oriented GmbH & Co. KG were transferred by way of a gift. This company held a stake in a US corporation (Inc.) which leased arable land, together with farm buildings and farm equipment, to local farmers. The farmers managed the land independently and paid either a fixed fee or a share of the harvest proceeds. Certain costs, such as those for irrigation systems, were borne by the corporation itself.
The tax office classified the arable land as administrative assets and significantly increased the taxable value of the gift. Reason: In the case of the leasing of an entire farm, only a specific exception applies; the exception for agricultural use, however, does not apply.
The court has ruled against the tax office
The Düsseldorf Finance Court upheld the claim. In its judgement of 2 June 2026 (case number 4 K 384/24 F), the court clarified that the exception for land used for agricultural and forestry purposes also applies where the land forms part of the business assets of a company limited by shares. The wording of the law itself contains no restriction as to the type of assets or legal form concerned.
Furthermore, the judges emphasised that the various exceptions to the law co-exist and are not mutually exclusive. Whether a farm is leased in its entirety is simply irrelevant for the agricultural exception, as the two provisions pursue different policy objectives. By introducing the agricultural exemption, the legislature expressly intended to promote agricultural activities, regardless of whether these are carried out by an individual or by a company.
What does this mean for businesses and heirs?
The ruling is particularly relevant for companies whose assets include agricultural land that is leased to third parties for farming purposes. In such circumstances, the tax relief on gifts or inheritances may be retained if the conditions of the agricultural exemption are met. According to this ruling, it is irrelevant whether the land is let as part of a comprehensive farm lease or belongs to a company.
As the distinction between business assets eligible for tax relief and taxable administrative assets is complex and may have significant tax implications, it is advisable to seek thorough tax advice on a case-by-case basis.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.