Those who receive funds from a city or local authority to carry out cultural activities sometimes treat these payments as tax-free grants. The Schleswig-Holstein Finance Court has now clarified that, under certain conditions, this is incorrect. In its judgement of 23 April 2026 (case number 4 K 112/25), the judges ruled that if the grant is directly linked to a specific obligation to provide a service, it is subject to VAT.
The case: Private operator takes over municipal conference and events centre
A town had outsourced the running of its conference and events centre to a private company. The operator entered into a lease and operating agreement with the town. This agreement expressly stipulated that the company was required to continue the town’s existing high-quality cultural activities at a standard at least equivalent to that previously provided. In return for this obligation, the operator received annual ‘cultural cost subsidies’ from the town.
In its VAT return, the company treated these payments as genuine grants, i.e. as payments made solely for the purpose of general support and therefore not subject to VAT. The tax office took a different view and demanded payment of VAT. The court ruled in favour of the tax office.
A genuine grant or taxable remuneration?
The difference between the two is crucial. A genuine grant is where money is provided without any consideration in return, for example to generally support a business without a specific contract. It is not a genuine grant if, in return, the recipient provides a specific service which the donor would otherwise have to provide themselves or in which they have a recognisable interest of their own.
That was precisely the case here. The court found that there was a direct link between the payments made by the city and the services provided by the operator. The city did not wish to run the cultural organisation itself, but contracted the work out to a private partner whilst reserving the right to monitor the fulfilment of obligations. In the event of a breach, it could even have taken action itself and charged the costs to the operator.
Temporal correlation as a further indication
The court also considered it significant that the payments were directly linked, in terms of timing, to the staging of the events. This clearly argued against the payments being merely general funding and in favour of them constituting consideration within the meaning of VAT law. It was irrelevant in this context whether the operator used the subsidy at its own financial risk or whether the payments actually covered the costs incurred.
Appeal not allowed
The judgement is final. The Finance Court refused to grant leave to appeal on the grounds that there were no grounds for appeal within the meaning of Section 115(2) of the Finance Court Rules.
What does this mean in practice?
Organisations that receive payments from the public sector in return for carrying out specific tasks should carefully examine the VAT treatment of these funds. The key question is always whether the payment constitutes remuneration for a specific service rendered or whether it represents genuine, non-conditional funding. The line between the two is blurred, as this case demonstrates. Where in doubt, it is advisable to seek expert tax advice before classifying payments in the VAT return.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.