Disputes over noise are among the most common conflicts in tenancy law. However, not every disturbance automatically entitles a tenant to a rent reduction or even to terminate the tenancy. The decisive factor is always whether the disturbance exceeds what is customary for the locality and becomes unreasonable for the person affected. Only then do legal claims arise. A number of court rulings illustrate where the boundaries lie in practice.
Termination of employment due to noise: identify the source of the noise precisely
In a recent judgement, the Flensburg Regional Court has clarified that landlords may not terminate tenancies arbitrarily in the event of disputes between several tenants. In this case, a new tenant was causing persistent noise, prompting a long-standing neighbour to retaliate. The landlord terminated both tenancies without notice. The court quashed the termination of the long-standing tenant’s tenancy: where several parties are involved in a dispute, landlords must first identify the actual cause of the disturbance and hear all parties concerned before taking action. A unilateral termination without this investigation is invalid (Flensburg Regional Court, judgement of 17 April 2026, 1 S 64/25).
Commercial music tuition may justify termination of employment
Anyone who uses their rented flat for commercial activities that are visible from the outside may be in breach of their tenancy agreement. In one case, the Federal Court of Justice ruled that guitar lessons in a residential flat had led to unreasonable disputes with neighbours and that termination for cause was valid. Unless otherwise agreed, the landlord is not obliged to tolerate such use (Federal Court of Justice, judgement of 10 April 2013, VIII ZR 213/12).
Roosters, dogs and music at home: where does tolerance end?
There is not always a right to an injunction. Whether neighbours are required to tolerate noise depends very much on the individual case:
- The Cologne Regional Court prohibited a landowner from keeping roosters in an urban residential area on the grounds that their unpredictable crowing made it impossible to sleep peacefully or enjoy the garden in a relaxed manner (Cologne Regional Court, judgement of 21 May 2025, 13 S 202/23).
- The Koblenz Regional Court reached a different conclusion: 25 hens and one cockerel in a rural area are regarded as customary local use. In such cases, there is an obligation to tolerate this (Koblenz Regional Court, judgement of 19 November 2019, 6 S 21/19).
- By contrast, roosters crowing at night between 10 pm and 6 am is, as a matter of principle, unacceptable, even in rural areas. The right to a good night’s sleep is enshrined in law in the Federal States’ regulations on the protection against environmental pollution (Mosbach Regional Court, judgement of 31 May 2023, 5 S 47/22).
- According to the Higher Regional Court of Hamm, dogs’ barking must not last for more than 30 minutes in total each day, and individual episodes of barking must not last for more than ten minutes at a time (Higher Regional Court of Hamm, judgement of 11 April 1988, 22 U 265/87).
- Music played at home is permitted provided it causes only a minor disturbance. A claim for an injunction only arises in the event of significant disruption (Federal Court of Justice, judgement of 26 October 2018, V ZR 143/17).
Rent reduction due to noise: What are the rules?
Significant noise nuisance caused by neighbours may constitute a defect in the tenancy and entitle the tenant to a rent reduction. Important: The reduction applies by operation of law as soon as a specific defect exists. The tenant need only be able to demonstrate this. In one case, the Federal Court of Justice even quashed an eviction order after a tenant had sought a rent reduction due to knocking noises, stomping and furniture being moved in the flat above, and the landlord subsequently terminated the tenancy without notice (BGH, decision of 21 February 2017, VIII ZR 1/16).
The legal situation is different where construction noise originates from a neighbouring property: As a rule, this does not constitute a breach of the tenancy agreement if the landlord is unable to prevent the noise themselves or to claim compensation (Federal Court of Justice, judgement of 29 April 2020, VIII ZR 31/18).
Children’s noise enjoys special protection
Under the Federal Immission Control Act, noise from childcare centres, playgrounds or football pitches is not generally regarded as a harmful environmental impact and must be tolerated in residential areas. However, there are limits here too: the nature, duration, timing and intensity of the noise, as well as the child’s age, may be relevant in individual cases.
Anyone who is unsure whether there is a defect in the property or what steps are permissible in the event of a notice of termination should seek legal advice before reducing the rent or taking legal action.
Source: Haufe: Property
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.