Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Noise in block of flats: When tenants may reduce their rent and landlords may give notice

Noi­se in a block of flats can lead to a rent reduc­tion or ter­mi­na­ti­on of the ten­an­cy. Recent court rulings cla­ri­fy when spe­ci­fic rights apply. 
Noise in block of flats: When tenants may reduce their rent and landlords may give notice

Noise in block of flats: When tenants may reduce their rent and landlords may give notice

Dis­pu­tes over noi­se are among the most com­mon con­flicts in ten­an­cy law. Howe­ver, not every dis­tur­ban­ce auto­ma­ti­cal­ly entit­les a ten­ant to a rent reduc­tion or even to ter­mi­na­te the ten­an­cy. The decisi­ve fac­tor is always whe­ther the dis­tur­ban­ce exceeds what is cus­to­ma­ry for the loca­li­ty and beco­mes unre­asonable for the per­son affec­ted. Only then do legal claims ari­se. A num­ber of court rulings illus­tra­te whe­re the boun­da­ries lie in practice.

Termination of employment due to noise: identify the source of the noise precisely

In a recent jud­ge­ment, the Flens­burg Regio­nal Court has cla­ri­fied that land­lords may not ter­mi­na­te ten­an­ci­es arbi­tra­ri­ly in the event of dis­pu­tes bet­ween seve­ral ten­ants. In this case, a new ten­ant was caus­ing per­sis­tent noi­se, promp­ting a long-stan­ding neigh­bour to reta­lia­te. The land­lord ter­mi­na­ted both ten­an­ci­es wit­hout noti­ce. The court quas­hed the ter­mi­na­ti­on of the long-stan­ding tenant’s ten­an­cy: whe­re seve­ral par­ties are invol­ved in a dis­pu­te, land­lords must first iden­ti­fy the actu­al cau­se of the dis­tur­ban­ce and hear all par­ties con­cer­ned befo­re taking action. A uni­la­te­ral ter­mi­na­ti­on wit­hout this inves­ti­ga­ti­on is inva­lid (Flens­burg Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 17 April 2026, 1 S 64/25).

Commercial music tuition may justify termination of employment

Anyo­ne who uses their ren­ted flat for com­mer­cial acti­vi­ties that are visi­ble from the out­side may be in breach of their ten­an­cy agree­ment. In one case, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce ruled that gui­tar les­sons in a resi­den­ti­al flat had led to unre­asonable dis­pu­tes with neigh­bours and that ter­mi­na­ti­on for cau­se was valid. Unless other­wi­se agreed, the land­lord is not obli­ged to tole­ra­te such use (Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce, jud­ge­ment of 10 April 2013, VIII ZR 213/12).

Roosters, dogs and music at home: where does tolerance end?

The­re is not always a right to an injunc­tion. Whe­ther neigh­bours are requi­red to tole­ra­te noi­se depends very much on the indi­vi­du­al case:

  • The Colo­gne Regio­nal Court pro­hi­bi­ted a lan­dow­ner from kee­ping roos­ters in an urban resi­den­ti­al area on the grounds that their unpre­dic­ta­ble cro­wing made it impos­si­ble to sleep peaceful­ly or enjoy the gar­den in a rela­xed man­ner (Colo­gne Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 21 May 2025, 13 S 202/23).
  • The Koblenz Regio­nal Court rea­ched a dif­fe­rent con­clu­si­on: 25 hens and one cocke­rel in a rural area are regard­ed as cus­to­ma­ry local use. In such cases, the­re is an obli­ga­ti­on to tole­ra­te this (Koblenz Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 19 Novem­ber 2019, 6 S 21/19).
  • By con­trast, roos­ters cro­wing at night bet­ween 10 pm and 6 am is, as a mat­ter of prin­ci­ple, unac­cep­ta­ble, even in rural are­as. The right to a good night’s sleep is enshri­ned in law in the Fede­ral Sta­tes’ regu­la­ti­ons on the pro­tec­tion against envi­ron­men­tal pol­lu­ti­on (Mos­bach Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 31 May 2023, 5 S 47/22).
  • Accor­ding to the Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Hamm, dogs’ bar­king must not last for more than 30 minu­tes in total each day, and indi­vi­du­al epi­so­des of bar­king must not last for more than ten minu­tes at a time (Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Hamm, jud­ge­ment of 11 April 1988, 22 U 265/87).
  • Music play­ed at home is per­mit­ted pro­vi­ded it cau­ses only a minor dis­tur­ban­ce. A cla­im for an injunc­tion only ari­ses in the event of signi­fi­cant dis­rup­ti­on (Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce, jud­ge­ment of 26 Octo­ber 2018, V ZR 143/17).

Rent reduction due to noise: What are the rules?

Signi­fi­cant noi­se nui­sance cau­sed by neigh­bours may con­sti­tu­te a defect in the ten­an­cy and entit­le the ten­ant to a rent reduc­tion. Important: The reduc­tion appli­es by ope­ra­ti­on of law as soon as a spe­ci­fic defect exists. The ten­ant need only be able to demons­tra­te this. In one case, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce even quas­hed an evic­tion order after a ten­ant had sought a rent reduc­tion due to kno­cking noi­ses, stom­ping and fur­ni­tu­re being moved in the flat abo­ve, and the land­lord sub­se­quent­ly ter­mi­na­ted the ten­an­cy wit­hout noti­ce (BGH, decis­i­on of 21 Febru­ary 2017, VIII ZR 1/16).

The legal situa­ti­on is dif­fe­rent whe­re con­s­truc­tion noi­se ori­gi­na­tes from a neigh­bou­ring pro­per­ty: As a rule, this does not con­sti­tu­te a breach of the ten­an­cy agree­ment if the land­lord is unable to pre­vent the noi­se them­sel­ves or to cla­im com­pen­sa­ti­on (Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce, jud­ge­ment of 29 April 2020, VIII ZR 31/18).

Children’s noise enjoys special protection

Under the Fede­ral Immis­si­on Con­trol Act, noi­se from child­ca­re cen­tres, play­grounds or foot­ball pit­ches is not gene­ral­ly regard­ed as a harmful envi­ron­men­tal impact and must be tole­ra­ted in resi­den­ti­al are­as. Howe­ver, the­re are limits here too: the natu­re, dura­ti­on, timing and inten­si­ty of the noi­se, as well as the child’s age, may be rele­vant in indi­vi­du­al cases.

Anyo­ne who is unsu­re whe­ther the­re is a defect in the pro­per­ty or what steps are per­mis­si­ble in the event of a noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on should seek legal advice befo­re redu­cing the rent or taking legal action.

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this