Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Extended property allowance in the event of liquidation: Munich Finance Court denies trade tax relief

Extended property allowance in the event of liquidation: Munich Finance Court denies trade tax relief

For pro­per­ty manage­ment com­pa­nies, the so-cal­led ‘exten­ded pro­per­ty deduc­tion’ under Sec­tion 9(1), second sen­tence, of the Trade Tax Act (GewStG) repres­ents a signi­fi­cant tax advan­ta­ge. It allows inco­me from the manage­ment of a company’s own pro­per­ty to be enti­re­ly exempt from trade tax. The Munich Finan­ce Court has now cla­ri­fied in a recent jud­ge­ment the cir­cum­s­tances under which this bene­fit is forfeited.

The case: A limited liability company (GmbH) sells all its properties and is wound up

A limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) spe­cia­li­sed in the manage­ment, acqui­si­ti­on and deve­lo­p­ment of its own pro­per­ty. In Decem­ber 2016, it sold its enti­re pro­per­ty port­fo­lio by way of a nota­ri­sed con­tract. The trans­fer of rights and obli­ga­ti­ons took place in Febru­ary 2017. Short­ly after­wards, the share­hol­ders resol­ved to wind up the GmbH. The com­pa­ny was the­r­e­fo­re in the pro­cess of liqui­da­ti­on from Janu­ary 2017.

For the 2017 tax year, the GmbH appli­ed for the exten­ded pro­per­ty allo­wan­ce, as it had done in pre­vious years. The tax office rejec­ted this appli­ca­ti­on fol­lo­wing an exter­nal audit. The appeal lodged against this decis­i­on was unsuc­cessful, whereu­pon the GmbH brought legal proceedings.

The ruling: Liquidation interrupts the right to use the property

The Munich Finan­ce Court ruled in favour of the tax office and refu­sed to grant the exten­ded deduc­tion for the year 2017. The reaso­ning behind this decis­i­on is signi­fi­cant in seve­ral respects.

  • The obli­ga­ti­on to pay trade tax on a fixed-asset basis ends late:A company’s tax lia­bi­li­ty does not cea­se sim­ply with the reso­lu­ti­on to wind up. It con­ti­nues until the com­pa­ny has cea­sed all acti­vi­ties. This is typi­cal­ly only the case once the assets have been dis­tri­bu­ted to the shareholders.
  • No spe­ci­fic liqui­da­ti­on assess­ment peri­od:Under trade tax law, the­re is no pro­vi­si­on for an exten­ded or sepa­ra­te tax peri­od for the liqui­da­ti­on pha­se. The stan­dard annu­al taxa­ti­on regime con­ti­nues to apply.
  • Liqui­da­ti­on is not a secon­da­ry acti­vi­ty:The court empha­sis­ed that the win­ding-up of a com­pa­ny does not con­sti­tu­te a mere ancil­la­ry acti­vi­ty to its pre­vious pro­per­ty manage­ment. In 2017, the GmbH was no lon­ger mana­ging any pro­per­ty but was in the pro­cess of win­ding up. Con­se­quent­ly, the exclu­si­ve link to pro­per­ty requi­red for the exten­ded deduc­tion was lacking.

Nor did the fact that the­re was no time lag bet­ween the sale of the pro­per­ty and the com­mence­ment of liqui­da­ti­on, and that the GmbH had drawn up a short finan­cial year, alter this assess­ment in any way.

Appeal allowed: Final decision still pending

The Finan­ce Court has express­ly aut­ho­ri­sed an appeal to the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court (BFH). It con­siders the issue to be of fun­da­men­tal importance, as the pre­cise cir­cum­s­tances of a sale of the last pro­per­ty during the finan­cial year, fol­lo­wed imme­dia­te­ly by liqui­da­ti­on, have not yet been deci­ded by the hig­hest court. A final ruling by the BFH is the­r­e­fo­re still pending.

What does this mean for the companies concerned?

For limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­nies (GmbHs) or other cor­po­ra­ti­ons that dis­po­se of their pro­per­ty port­fo­lio and are sub­se­quent­ly wound up, this ruling ser­ves as a clear war­ning. The exten­ded pro­per­ty allo­wan­ce may no lon­ger app­ly in the year of liqui­da­ti­on, even if the com­pa­ny has con­sis­t­ent­ly bene­fi­ted from this advan­ta­ge in pre­vious years. Anyo­ne plan­ning such a sce­na­rio should have the tax impli­ca­ti­ons asses­sed at an ear­ly stage.

Munich Regio­nal Court, judgment of 12 May 2026, Case No. 6 K 1713/23

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this