For property management companies, the so-called ‘extended property deduction’ under Section 9(1), second sentence, of the Trade Tax Act (GewStG) represents a significant tax advantage. It allows income from the management of a company’s own property to be entirely exempt from trade tax. The Munich Finance Court has now clarified in a recent judgement the circumstances under which this benefit is forfeited.
The case: A limited liability company (GmbH) sells all its properties and is wound up
A limited liability company (GmbH) specialised in the management, acquisition and development of its own property. In December 2016, it sold its entire property portfolio by way of a notarised contract. The transfer of rights and obligations took place in February 2017. Shortly afterwards, the shareholders resolved to wind up the GmbH. The company was therefore in the process of liquidation from January 2017.
For the 2017 tax year, the GmbH applied for the extended property allowance, as it had done in previous years. The tax office rejected this application following an external audit. The appeal lodged against this decision was unsuccessful, whereupon the GmbH brought legal proceedings.
The ruling: Liquidation interrupts the right to use the property
The Munich Finance Court ruled in favour of the tax office and refused to grant the extended deduction for the year 2017. The reasoning behind this decision is significant in several respects.
- The obligation to pay trade tax on a fixed-asset basis ends late:A company’s tax liability does not cease simply with the resolution to wind up. It continues until the company has ceased all activities. This is typically only the case once the assets have been distributed to the shareholders.
- No specific liquidation assessment period:Under trade tax law, there is no provision for an extended or separate tax period for the liquidation phase. The standard annual taxation regime continues to apply.
- Liquidation is not a secondary activity:The court emphasised that the winding-up of a company does not constitute a mere ancillary activity to its previous property management. In 2017, the GmbH was no longer managing any property but was in the process of winding up. Consequently, the exclusive link to property required for the extended deduction was lacking.
Nor did the fact that there was no time lag between the sale of the property and the commencement of liquidation, and that the GmbH had drawn up a short financial year, alter this assessment in any way.
Appeal allowed: Final decision still pending
The Finance Court has expressly authorised an appeal to the Federal Finance Court (BFH). It considers the issue to be of fundamental importance, as the precise circumstances of a sale of the last property during the financial year, followed immediately by liquidation, have not yet been decided by the highest court. A final ruling by the BFH is therefore still pending.
What does this mean for the companies concerned?
For limited liability companies (GmbHs) or other corporations that dispose of their property portfolio and are subsequently wound up, this ruling serves as a clear warning. The extended property allowance may no longer apply in the year of liquidation, even if the company has consistently benefited from this advantage in previous years. Anyone planning such a scenario should have the tax implications assessed at an early stage.
Munich Regional Court, judgment of 12 May 2026, Case No. 6 K 1713/23
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.