Anyone who operates a photovoltaic system and wishes to claim tax losses against the tax office regularly faces a significant hurdle: they must prove that they intend to make a profit from the system over its entire useful life. This so-called ‘total profit forecast’ is decisive in determining whether the tax office will recognise the losses for tax purposes. The Federal Fiscal Court has now clarified, in a recently published ruling, how this proof is to be provided and which events must not be taken into account.
The case: Investment made in 2015, tax exemption from 2022
A plant operator had commissioned his photovoltaic system in December 2015 and had declared tax losses in the following years. The tax office did not recognise these losses because it doubted that there was a genuine intention to make a profit. The Baden-Württemberg Finance Court upheld this assessment: the forecast total profit was negative.
The operator sought to overturn the judgement on two grounds. Firstly, he complained that the court’s decision had taken him by surprise, as the judge-rapporteur had, during the oral hearing, indicated that the residual value of the system would be taken into account. Secondly, he referred to the tax exemption for small photovoltaic systems, which has been in force since 2022 under Section 3(72) of the Income Tax Act. He argued that this exemption should have been taken into account in his favour when calculating the forecast.
The Federal Fiscal Court rejects both arguments
The Federal Fiscal Court rejected both arguments (decision of 17 May 2024, case number X B 119/23, published on 30 July 2026).
With regard to the procedural objection, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) made it clear that there had been no breach of the right to be heard. The rapporteur had merely indicated that, in principle, a residual value should be included in the calculation. The fact that this residual value, at the specific amount in question, was insufficient to turn the forecast into a positive one was not a contradictory U‑turn, but purely a matter of figures. Furthermore, the operator was represented by a specialist solicitor. Where a party is represented by a solicitor, all legally tenable arguments must be considered independently, without the court being required to address every single point explicitly.
With regard to the tax exemption, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) emphasised a fundamental principle: the forecast of total profit depends solely on the date on which the investment decision was made. In December 2015, the tax exemption introduced seven years later was simply unforeseeable. Anyone who purchased an asset in 2015 could not and did not have to anticipate this legislative decision. Subsequent legislative changes which, viewed objectively, were unforeseeable, are therefore not taken into account in the forecast.
What does this mean for operators of photovoltaic systems?
This decision is important for anyone who operates an older photovoltaic system and is claiming – or has already claimed – tax losses:
- The profit forecast is assessed on the basis of the circumstances prevailing at the time of acquisition.
- Favourable legislative changes that come into effect only after the investment has been made are of no help when assessing older facilities.
- Anyone who is represented by a solicitor or tax adviser must put forward all relevant arguments themselves.
Anyone who is unsure whether their investment meets the requirements for the total profit forecast, or whether an ongoing case with the tax authorities has a good chance of success, should seek tax advice. A case-by-case assessment remains crucial.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.