Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Photovoltaic systems and losses: Subsequent tax exemption does not apply to previous forecasts

Photovoltaic systems and losses: Subsequent tax exemption does not apply to previous forecasts

Anyo­ne who ope­ra­tes a pho­to­vol­taic sys­tem and wis­hes to cla­im tax los­ses against the tax office regu­lar­ly faces a signi­fi­cant hurd­le: they must pro­ve that they intend to make a pro­fit from the sys­tem over its enti­re useful life. This so-cal­led ‘total pro­fit fore­cast’ is decisi­ve in deter­mi­ning whe­ther the tax office will reco­g­ni­se the los­ses for tax pur­po­ses. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has now cla­ri­fied, in a recent­ly published ruling, how this pro­of is to be pro­vi­ded and which events must not be taken into account.

The case: Investment made in 2015, tax exemption from 2022

A plant ope­ra­tor had com­mis­sio­ned his pho­to­vol­taic sys­tem in Decem­ber 2015 and had declared tax los­ses in the fol­lo­wing years. The tax office did not reco­g­ni­se the­se los­ses becau­se it doub­ted that the­re was a genui­ne inten­ti­on to make a pro­fit. The Baden-Würt­tem­berg Finan­ce Court upheld this assess­ment: the fore­cast total pro­fit was negative.

The ope­ra­tor sought to over­turn the jud­ge­ment on two grounds. First­ly, he com­plai­ned that the court’s decis­i­on had taken him by sur­pri­se, as the judge-rap­por­teur had, during the oral hea­ring, indi­ca­ted that the resi­du­al value of the sys­tem would be taken into account. Second­ly, he refer­red to the tax exemp­ti­on for small pho­to­vol­taic sys­tems, which has been in force sin­ce 2022 under Sec­tion 3(72) of the Inco­me Tax Act. He argued that this exemp­ti­on should have been taken into account in his favour when cal­cu­la­ting the forecast.

The Federal Fiscal Court rejects both arguments

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court rejec­ted both argu­ments (decis­i­on of 17 May 2024, case num­ber X B 119/23, published on 30 July 2026).

With regard to the pro­ce­du­ral objec­tion, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) made it clear that the­re had been no breach of the right to be heard. The rap­por­teur had mere­ly indi­ca­ted that, in prin­ci­ple, a resi­du­al value should be included in the cal­cu­la­ti­on. The fact that this resi­du­al value, at the spe­ci­fic amount in ques­ti­on, was insuf­fi­ci­ent to turn the fore­cast into a posi­ti­ve one was not a con­tra­dic­to­ry U‑turn, but purely a mat­ter of figu­res. Fur­ther­mo­re, the ope­ra­tor was repre­sen­ted by a spe­cia­list soli­ci­tor. Whe­re a par­ty is repre­sen­ted by a soli­ci­tor, all legal­ly tenable argu­ments must be con­side­red inde­pendent­ly, wit­hout the court being requi­red to address every sin­gle point explicitly.

With regard to the tax exemp­ti­on, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) empha­sis­ed a fun­da­men­tal prin­ci­ple: the fore­cast of total pro­fit depends sole­ly on the date on which the invest­ment decis­i­on was made. In Decem­ber 2015, the tax exemp­ti­on intro­du­ced seven years later was sim­ply unfo­re­seeable. Anyo­ne who purcha­sed an asset in 2015 could not and did not have to anti­ci­pa­te this legis­la­ti­ve decis­i­on. Sub­se­quent legis­la­ti­ve chan­ges which, view­ed objec­tively, were unfo­re­seeable, are the­r­e­fo­re not taken into account in the forecast.

What does this mean for operators of photovoltaic systems?

This decis­i­on is important for anyo­ne who ope­ra­tes an older pho­to­vol­taic sys­tem and is clai­ming – or has alre­a­dy clai­med – tax losses:

  • The pro­fit fore­cast is asses­sed on the basis of the cir­cum­s­tances pre­vai­ling at the time of acquisition.
  • Favoura­ble legis­la­ti­ve chan­ges that come into effect only after the invest­ment has been made are of no help when asses­sing older facilities.
  • Anyo­ne who is repre­sen­ted by a soli­ci­tor or tax advi­ser must put for­ward all rele­vant argu­ments themselves.

Anyo­ne who is unsu­re whe­ther their invest­ment meets the requi­re­ments for the total pro­fit fore­cast, or whe­ther an ongo­ing case with the tax aut­ho­ri­ties has a good chan­ce of suc­cess, should seek tax advice. A case-by-case assess­ment remains crucial.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this