Employees who fall ill are entitled to continued payment of their wages by their employer for up to six weeks. What many people do not realise is that if they are absent again due to the same illness, they do not automatically receive a further six weeks’ pay. Under certain circumstances, the employer may take previous periods of illness into account and shorten the period during which wages are paid.
When is an employer permitted to take pre-existing conditions into account?
The law provides for two circumstances in which a deduction is permitted. Firstly: the employee was fit for work for less than six months prior to the new illness. Secondly: twelve months have not yet elapsed since the start of the first period of sick leave due to the same illness. If these conditions are not met, a new, full entitlement to six weeks’ continued pay arises.
The 6‑month time limit in practice
Whether the six-month period applies is calculated retrospectively, starting from the day before the start of the new period of incapacity for work. If there was no period of incapacity for work due to the same illness during this time, the entitlement starts afresh. An example: An employee falls ill again from 25 April 2026. Previously, they were unable to work due to the same illness from 4 September to 29 October 2025. The six-month period, calculated backwards, extends to 25 October 2025. As the previous period of incapacity for work ended within this timeframe, it is taken into account. If the employer has already paid six weeks’ continued remuneration, there is no further entitlement in respect of the new period of incapacity for work.
The 12-month period as a second option
If the assessment of the six-month period does not give rise to a new entitlement, the twelve-month period may nevertheless give rise to a new entitlement. The decisive factor here is the onset of the first illness. If the new period of incapacity for work begins after the end of this twelve-month period, a full six-week entitlement arises once again.
Only the same illness is eligible
Important: Only periods of sickness arising from the same underlying condition may be taken into account. This sounds simple, but in practice it is often difficult. Employers do not usually have access to diagnoses, as these are not shown on the electronic certificate of incapacity for work.
In such cases, employers can apply for an assessment via the data exchange procedure with the health insurance fund (DTA EEL). The health insurance fund then checks, on the basis of the available diagnoses, whether there is a connection. However, this is only possible if the employee is covered by statutory health insurance, the relevant illnesses are substantiated by the sick leave data retrieved, and the combined periods total at least 30 days.
The health insurance provider’s notification has no binding evidential value
There is one thing employers should bear in mind: the health insurance fund’s response is not a binding decision. In a judgement dated 18 January 2023 (case number 5 AZR 93/22), the Federal Labour Court clarified that the health insurance fund’s notification is not binding on either the employer or the labour courts. As the health insurance fund has its own financial interest in the outcome, it is not regarded as an impartial third party.
Special provisions for privately insured individuals
In the case of employees with private health insurance, the employer does not receive a sick note stating a diagnosis. As a general rule, it is assumed that there is a pre-existing condition that affects entitlement to benefits, unless the employee can prove otherwise. The burden of proof therefore lies with the employee if they wish to claim a new benefit.
Assessing pre-existing conditions is a complex process in which time limits, diagnoses and procedural steps are all interlinked. Any employer who is unsure, or any employee who wishes to have their entitlement assessed, should seek legal advice if in doubt.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.