Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Net pay optimisation: When are tax-free employer benefits actually recognised?

Tax-free employ­er bene­fits are only reco­g­nis­ed if the ‘addi­tio­na­li­ty’ cri­ter­ion is met. What this means and what matters. 
Net pay optimisation: When are tax-free employer benefits actually recognised?

Net pay optimisation: When are tax-free employer benefits actually recognised?

Many employ­ers use so-cal­led remu­ne­ra­ti­on opti­mi­sa­ti­on sche­mes to help their employees take home more of their gross pay. The idea behind this is simp­le: ins­tead of taxa­ble cash wages, the employ­er pro­vi­des cer­tain bene­fits that are eit­her tax-free or sub­ject only to a flat-rate tax. This saves money for both par­ties. Howe­ver, for the tax aut­ho­ri­ties to reco­g­ni­se the­se arran­ge­ments, cer­tain clear con­di­ti­ons must be met.

The additionality criterion as a key hurdle

The crux of the pro­blem lies in what is known as the ‘addi­tio­na­li­ty’ cri­ter­ion. Many tax exemp­ti­ons and flat-rate rules only app­ly if the employ­er pro­vi­des a bene­fit in addi­ti­on to the wages alre­a­dy duepro­vi­des. A simp­le con­ver­si­on of an alre­a­dy agreed sala­ry is not sufficient.

Sin­ce 2020, the con­cept of ‘addi­tio­na­li­ty’ has been defi­ned in law in Sec­tion 8(4) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG). Accor­ding to this pro­vi­si­on, a bene­fit is only con­side­red addi­tio­nal if it is not off­set against the employee’s entit­le­ment to wages, the wages have not been redu­ced in favour of the bene­fit, it is not gran­ted in lieu of an alre­a­dy agreed pay rise, and the wages do not increase should the bene­fit cea­se. The­se four con­di­ti­ons must all be met cumulatively.

Which services are affected

The addi­tio­na­li­ty cri­ter­ion appli­es, among­st other things, to the fol­lo­wing ele­ments of remuneration:

  • Tax-free tra­vel vou­ch­ers under Sec­tion 3(15) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)
  • Nur­sery sub­si­dies for child­ren not yet of school age under Sec­tion 3(33) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)
  • Health­ca­re sub­si­dies under Sec­tion 3(34) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)
  • Tax-free pro­vi­si­on of a bicy­cle under Sec­tion 3(37) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)
  • Flat-rate tax-trea­ted tra­vel allo­wan­ces for com­mu­ting to work pur­su­ant to Sec­tion 40(2), second sen­tence, of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)
  • Trans­fer of owner­ship of com­pu­ters and IT equip­ment pur­su­ant to sec­tion 40(2)(5) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)
  • The month­ly €50 allo­wan­ce for bene­fits in kind under sec­tion 8(2), sen­tence 11, of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)
  • The employer’s con­tri­bu­ti­on to occu­pa­tio­nal pen­si­on sche­mes under Sec­tion 100 of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)

Amendment agreements are problematic

Anyo­ne who amends their employ­ment con­tract to replace their pre­vious cash sala­ry with tax-free bene­fits in kind can quick­ly run into dif­fi­cul­ties. This is becau­se, under an amend­ment to the con­tract, the sala­ry alre­a­dy owed under employ­ment law is mere­ly con­ver­ted. The ‘addi­tio­na­li­ty’ cri­ter­ion is the­r­e­fo­re not met. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court had pre­vious­ly taken a dif­fe­rent view befo­re the legis­la­ti­ve amend­ment, but the stric­ter sta­tu­to­ry pro­vi­si­on has been in force sin­ce 2020. For out­stan­ding cases dating up to and inclu­ding 2019, the Fede­ral Minis­try of Finan­ce con­ti­nues to app­ly the ear­lier, more employee-fri­end­ly case law (BMF let­ter of 5 Janu­ary 2022, Ref. IV C 5 – S 2334/19/10017 :004).

Relief on voluntary special payments

One important excep­ti­on con­cerns vol­un­t­a­ry pay­ments made by the employ­er. In a recent jud­ge­ment dated 21 Janu­ary 2026 (Ref. VI R 25/24), the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court cla­ri­fied that vol­un­t­a­ry spe­cial pay­ments do not form part of the wages alre­a­dy due. It is the­r­e­fo­re per­mis­si­ble for an employ­er to set off one vol­un­t­a­ry pay­ment against ano­ther or to assign it a dif­fe­rent pur­po­se. This pro­vi­des scope for struc­tu­ring arran­ge­ments, which employ­ers should be awa­re of.

What this means for employers and employees

Remu­ne­ra­ti­on opti­mi­sa­ti­on can be a useful tool for retai­ning staff and incre­asing sala­ries wit­hout incur­ring hig­her wage cos­ts. Howe­ver, the tax law requi­re­ments are com­plex and pro­ne to errors. Anyo­ne pro­cee­ding wit­hout careful scru­ti­ny risks the tax aut­ho­ri­ties refu­sing tax exemp­ti­on or flat-rate taxa­ti­on during a tax audit. Tax advice is recom­men­ded in all cases.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this