Many employers use so-called remuneration optimisation schemes to help their employees take home more of their gross pay. The idea behind this is simple: instead of taxable cash wages, the employer provides certain benefits that are either tax-free or subject only to a flat-rate tax. This saves money for both parties. However, for the tax authorities to recognise these arrangements, certain clear conditions must be met.
The additionality criterion as a key hurdle
The crux of the problem lies in what is known as the ‘additionality’ criterion. Many tax exemptions and flat-rate rules only apply if the employer provides a benefit in addition to the wages already dueprovides. A simple conversion of an already agreed salary is not sufficient.
Since 2020, the concept of ‘additionality’ has been defined in law in Section 8(4) of the Income Tax Act (EStG). According to this provision, a benefit is only considered additional if it is not offset against the employee’s entitlement to wages, the wages have not been reduced in favour of the benefit, it is not granted in lieu of an already agreed pay rise, and the wages do not increase should the benefit cease. These four conditions must all be met cumulatively.
Which services are affected
The additionality criterion applies, amongst other things, to the following elements of remuneration:
- Tax-free travel vouchers under Section 3(15) of the Income Tax Act (EStG)
- Nursery subsidies for children not yet of school age under Section 3(33) of the Income Tax Act (EStG)
- Healthcare subsidies under Section 3(34) of the Income Tax Act (EStG)
- Tax-free provision of a bicycle under Section 3(37) of the Income Tax Act (EStG)
- Flat-rate tax-treated travel allowances for commuting to work pursuant to Section 40(2), second sentence, of the Income Tax Act (EStG)
- Transfer of ownership of computers and IT equipment pursuant to section 40(2)(5) of the Income Tax Act (EStG)
- The monthly €50 allowance for benefits in kind under section 8(2), sentence 11, of the Income Tax Act (EStG)
- The employer’s contribution to occupational pension schemes under Section 100 of the Income Tax Act (EStG)
Amendment agreements are problematic
Anyone who amends their employment contract to replace their previous cash salary with tax-free benefits in kind can quickly run into difficulties. This is because, under an amendment to the contract, the salary already owed under employment law is merely converted. The ‘additionality’ criterion is therefore not met. The Federal Fiscal Court had previously taken a different view before the legislative amendment, but the stricter statutory provision has been in force since 2020. For outstanding cases dating up to and including 2019, the Federal Ministry of Finance continues to apply the earlier, more employee-friendly case law (BMF letter of 5 January 2022, Ref. IV C 5 – S 2334/19/10017 :004).
Relief on voluntary special payments
One important exception concerns voluntary payments made by the employer. In a recent judgement dated 21 January 2026 (Ref. VI R 25/24), the Federal Fiscal Court clarified that voluntary special payments do not form part of the wages already due. It is therefore permissible for an employer to set off one voluntary payment against another or to assign it a different purpose. This provides scope for structuring arrangements, which employers should be aware of.
What this means for employers and employees
Remuneration optimisation can be a useful tool for retaining staff and increasing salaries without incurring higher wage costs. However, the tax law requirements are complex and prone to errors. Anyone proceeding without careful scrutiny risks the tax authorities refusing tax exemption or flat-rate taxation during a tax audit. Tax advice is recommended in all cases.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.