Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Depreciation for heritage-listed assets upon the dissolution of a GbR: The remaining partner may claim the full depreciation

Depre­cia­ti­on for heri­ta­ge-lis­ted assets upon the dis­so­lu­ti­on of a GbR: Anyo­ne who beco­mes the sole owner wit­hout recei­ving a sett­le­ment may con­ti­nue to cla­im the full amount of depreciation. 
Depreciation for heritage-listed assets upon the dissolution of a GbR: The remaining partner may claim the full depreciation

Depreciation for heritage-listed assets upon the dissolution of a GbR: The remaining partner may claim the full depreciation

Anyo­ne who has reno­va­ted a lis­ted buil­ding held by a civil-law part­ner­ship (GbR) with increased depre­cia­ti­on under Sec­tion 7i of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG) faces a tri­cky tax issue if a co-part­ner lea­ves the part­ner­ship: Is the remai­ning part­ner entit­led to con­ti­nue clai­ming the full amount of the so-cal­led ‘lis­ted buil­ding depre­cia­ti­on’ (Denk­mal-AfA), or only half of it? The Sax­o­ny-Anhalt Finan­ce Court has taken a clear stance on this mat­ter in a recent judgement.

What had happened?

Two busi­ness part­ners joint­ly estab­lished a GbR in order to acqui­re, reno­va­te and let a buil­ding in Sax­o­ny-Anhalt that is lis­ted as a sin­gle monu­ment. The reno­va­ti­on was car­ri­ed out in accordance with con­ser­va­ti­on gui­de­lines, and the dis­trict aut­ho­ri­ty deter­mi­ned the eli­gi­ble expen­dit­u­re for the increased depre­cia­ti­on under Sec­tion 7i of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG). Four years after the acqui­si­ti­on, one of the two part­ners with­drew from the GbR. His 50 per cent share in the co-owner­ship was trans­fer­red to the remai­ning part­ner. No com­pen­sa­ti­on was paid; the depar­ting part­ner was mere­ly released from his joint and seve­ral lia­bi­li­ty for the GbR’s liabilities.

The tax office clas­si­fied this tran­sac­tion as an acqui­si­ti­on and no lon­ger allo­wed the heri­ta­ge depre­cia­ti­on allo­wan­ce for the acqui­red share. Ins­tead, it trea­ted the assu­med lia­bi­li­ties as sub­se­quent acqui­si­ti­on cos­ts, to be depre­cia­ted over 45 years in accordance with the gene­ral rules. The remai­ning share­hol­der brought legal pro­cee­dings against this decision.

The court’s decision

The Sax­o­ny-Anhalt Finan­ce Court lar­ge­ly ruled in favour of the clai­mant. The court found that, upon the depar­tu­re of the penul­ti­ma­te part­ner from a two-mem­ber GbR, the part­ner­ship is dis­sol­ved by ope­ra­ti­on of law. All its assets are trans­fer­red to the last remai­ning part­ner by way of what is known as uni­ver­sal suc­ces­si­on. This has appli­ed express­ly sin­ce 1 Janu­ary 2024 under the new Sec­tion 712a(1) of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB), but had alre­a­dy been reco­g­nis­ed pre­vious­ly in the case law of the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH, judgment of 5 July 2018, Ref. No. V ZB 10/18).

The key fac­tor for the depre­cia­ti­on of lis­ted buil­dings under Sec­tion 7i of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG) is that this depre­cia­ti­on requi­res the asset to have been acqui­red by way of uni­ver­sal suc­ces­si­on. A trans­fer by way of uni­ver­sal suc­ces­si­on does not con­sti­tu­te an acqui­si­ti­on in this tax law sen­se. Fur­ther­mo­re, as no com­pen­sa­ti­on was paid, the court con­siders that the­re was no genui­ne con­side­ra­ti­on. Simi­lar sce­na­ri­os, such as the dis­tri­bu­ti­on of assets upon the dis­so­lu­ti­on of a GmbH or con­ver­si­ons to the sole share­hol­der, have pre­vious­ly been ruled by the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) not to con­sti­tu­te an acquisition.

The clai­mant was the­r­e­fo­re entit­led to con­ti­nue clai­ming the increased allo­wan­ces in full, inclu­ding for the share pre­vious­ly attri­bu­ta­ble to the co-shareholder.

What does this mean for those affected?

The ruling is rele­vant to all owners of lis­ted pro­per­ties held within cor­po­ra­te struc­tures. Howe­ver, an appeal against the ruling has sin­ce been lodged with the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) (Ref. III R 19/25). A final ruling by Germany’s hig­hest tax court is the­r­e­fo­re still pending.

  • Anyo­ne who is refu­sed the full heri­ta­ge depre­cia­ti­on allo­wan­ce by the tax aut­ho­ri­ties in a simi­lar case should lodge an appeal against the tax assessment.
  • The noti­ce of objec­tion should refer to the ongo­ing Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) pro­cee­dings (Ref. III R 19/25) and request that the pro­cee­dings be stayed.
  • As a result, the decis­i­on remains open and may bene­fit from a favoura­ble ruling by the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court.

As this is a com­plex issue rela­ting to depre­cia­ti­on with signi­fi­cant finan­cial impli­ca­ti­ons, it is advi­sa­ble to seek indi­vi­du­al tax advice in all cases.

Sax­o­ny-Anhalt Finan­ce Court, judgment of 5 Decem­ber 2023, Case No. 5 K 871/18 (appeal pen­ding befo­re the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court, Case No. III R 19/25)

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this