Anyone who has renovated a listed building held by a civil-law partnership (GbR) with increased depreciation under Section 7i of the Income Tax Act (EStG) faces a tricky tax issue if a co-partner leaves the partnership: Is the remaining partner entitled to continue claiming the full amount of the so-called ‘listed building depreciation’ (Denkmal-AfA), or only half of it? The Saxony-Anhalt Finance Court has taken a clear stance on this matter in a recent judgement.
What had happened?
Two business partners jointly established a GbR in order to acquire, renovate and let a building in Saxony-Anhalt that is listed as a single monument. The renovation was carried out in accordance with conservation guidelines, and the district authority determined the eligible expenditure for the increased depreciation under Section 7i of the Income Tax Act (EStG). Four years after the acquisition, one of the two partners withdrew from the GbR. His 50 per cent share in the co-ownership was transferred to the remaining partner. No compensation was paid; the departing partner was merely released from his joint and several liability for the GbR’s liabilities.
The tax office classified this transaction as an acquisition and no longer allowed the heritage depreciation allowance for the acquired share. Instead, it treated the assumed liabilities as subsequent acquisition costs, to be depreciated over 45 years in accordance with the general rules. The remaining shareholder brought legal proceedings against this decision.
The court’s decision
The Saxony-Anhalt Finance Court largely ruled in favour of the claimant. The court found that, upon the departure of the penultimate partner from a two-member GbR, the partnership is dissolved by operation of law. All its assets are transferred to the last remaining partner by way of what is known as universal succession. This has applied expressly since 1 January 2024 under the new Section 712a(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB), but had already been recognised previously in the case law of the Federal Court of Justice (BGH, judgment of 5 July 2018, Ref. No. V ZB 10/18).
The key factor for the depreciation of listed buildings under Section 7i of the Income Tax Act (EStG) is that this depreciation requires the asset to have been acquired by way of universal succession. A transfer by way of universal succession does not constitute an acquisition in this tax law sense. Furthermore, as no compensation was paid, the court considers that there was no genuine consideration. Similar scenarios, such as the distribution of assets upon the dissolution of a GmbH or conversions to the sole shareholder, have previously been ruled by the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) not to constitute an acquisition.
The claimant was therefore entitled to continue claiming the increased allowances in full, including for the share previously attributable to the co-shareholder.
What does this mean for those affected?
The ruling is relevant to all owners of listed properties held within corporate structures. However, an appeal against the ruling has since been lodged with the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) (Ref. III R 19/25). A final ruling by Germany’s highest tax court is therefore still pending.
- Anyone who is refused the full heritage depreciation allowance by the tax authorities in a similar case should lodge an appeal against the tax assessment.
- The notice of objection should refer to the ongoing Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) proceedings (Ref. III R 19/25) and request that the proceedings be stayed.
- As a result, the decision remains open and may benefit from a favourable ruling by the Federal Fiscal Court.
As this is a complex issue relating to depreciation with significant financial implications, it is advisable to seek individual tax advice in all cases.
Saxony-Anhalt Finance Court, judgment of 5 December 2023, Case No. 5 K 871/18 (appeal pending before the Federal Finance Court, Case No. III R 19/25)
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.