Anyone who acquires shares in a partnership as part of the settlement of an estate and thereby triggers transactions subject to land transfer tax cannot automatically rely on the tax exemption for inheritance cases. This was clarified by the Münster Finance Court in a recent judgement of 21 May 2026 (Ref. 8 K 1592/24 GrE).
An overview of the facts
A father was the general partner of a limited partnership and the sole shareholder of a limited liability company (GmbH), which was also a general partner in the limited partnership without holding any equity interest. Following the father’s death, the shareholding in the partnership was transferred to his three children by way of what is known as ‘singular succession’. This means that each child became a partner directly by virtue of succession, without the share initially forming part of the joint estate.
In the subsequent agreement on the distribution of the estate, two of the siblings transferred their shares in the company to the third brother, the claimant. He also acquired the business share in the GmbH. The tax office subsequently determined that, as a result of these transactions, the claimant had acquired at least 90 per cent of the shares in the company and levied land transfer tax in accordance with Section 1(3)(1) of the Land Transfer Tax Act. In the case of such a consolidation of shares, this provision deems there to have been an acquisition, for the purposes of land transfer tax, of the land forming part of the company’s assets.
Point of contention: Exemption through the settlement of an estate?
The claimant argued that the transfer of the shares by his siblings formed part of the distribution of the estate and was therefore exempt from land transfer tax under section 3(3), first sentence, of the Land Transfer Tax Act (GrEStG). This exemption applies where co-heirs acquire land forming part of the estate in the course of the distribution of the estate.
However, the Münster Finance Court dismissed the claim. The decisive factor in this case was the question of when an asset forms part of the estate for the purposes of land transfer tax. According to the relevant case law of the Federal Fiscal Court, this is only the case if the asset is held by the heirs in joint ownership, i.e. jointly as a community of heirs. However, this was precisely not the case here: the shares in the company had already passed directly to the individual children upon the testator’s death by way of individual succession, without falling into the joint ownership of the community of heirs.
What does that mean in practice?
The judgement shows that the exemption from land transfer tax in the settlement of estates does not automatically apply when company shares are involved. In particular, in the case of partnerships where shares pass directly to individual heirs under the partnership agreement, the exemption provision may prove ineffective. The transfer of shares between siblings is, in principle, not eligible for any relief under property acquisition tax law.
- Land transfer tax may also arise without a traditional property purchase, when company shares are consolidated.
- The tax exemption for the distribution of an estate is subject to the condition that the assets in question form part of the estate as joint property.
- When planning succession in family businesses, the implications of share transfers for land transfer tax should be assessed at an early stage.
Anyone inheriting or transferring a family business, whether in the form of a partnership or a company, should analyse the tax implications carefully in advance. The way in which the articles of association and the inheritance agreement are drafted can have a significant impact on whether, and to what extent, land transfer tax is payable. Seeking tax advice at an early stage is strongly recommended in such circumstances.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.