Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Coronavirus bridging support: Providing a valid justification for an appeal

Coronavirus bridging support: Providing a valid justification for an appeal

The final sett­le­ments for the coro­na­vi­rus bridging aid are still kee­ping num­e­rous busi­nesses and their advi­sers busy. Anyo­ne who has recei­ved a noti­ce of reduc­tion or reco­very often thinks in two stages: first, lodge an appeal; then, if neces­sa­ry, take the mat­ter to court. Howe­ver, this approach can pro­ve costly.

An appeal is the last chance to present new evidence

In many fede­ral sta­tes, the­re is no for­mal appeal pro­ce­du­re at all for bridging aid. Bava­ria, North Rhi­ne-West­pha­lia and Hes­se are examp­les of this: in tho­se sta­tes, lodging an out-of-court appeal does not sus­pend the fina­li­ty of the decis­i­on. The direct rou­te is to the admi­nis­tra­ti­ve court.

Even in sta­tes with an appeal pro­ce­du­re, such as Ham­burg, Lower Sax­o­ny or Baden-Würt­tem­berg, an important rest­ric­tion appli­es: the Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court gene­ral­ly exami­nes the facts of the case as estab­lished by the aut­ho­ri­ty. New fac­tu­al sub­mis­si­ons are rare­ly accept­ed at a later stage. The Karls­ru­he Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court cle­ar­ly illus­tra­ted this in July 2026 (jud­ge­ment of 7 July 2026, ref. 8 K 12012/25). In that case, ancil­la­ry ren­tal cos­ts of 383 euros had been inad­ver­t­ent­ly ente­red under the wrong cost item. As the error was only noti­ced during the oral hea­ring, the cla­im was rejec­ted, even though the basic eli­gi­bi­li­ty for fun­ding was never in dispute.

The most common mistake: a brief explanation lacking in substance

In prac­ti­ce, tax advi­sers – acting as so-cal­led ‘third-par­ty review­ers’ – often initi­al­ly lodge an appeal mere­ly to meet the dead­line, i.e. wit­hout pro­vi­ding grounds. This is per­mis­si­ble. The situa­ti­on beco­mes pro­ble­ma­tic if litt­le else fol­lows. Grounds for appeal that mere­ly sta­te that the funds were used for their inten­ded pur­po­se and ask the aut­ho­ri­ty to plea­se exami­ne the docu­ments pro­vi­ded usual­ly do not result in a genui­ne sub­stan­ti­ve review. The out­co­me is a noti­ce of appeal decis­i­on that sim­ply con­firms the ori­gi­nal decision.

A com­mon mis­con­cep­ti­on in this regard is the refe­rence to what is known as ‘ex offi­cio inves­ti­ga­ti­on’. Under the Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Pro­ce­du­re Act, the aut­ho­ri­ty is inde­ed requi­red to estab­lish the facts of the case on its own initia­ti­ve and to take favoura­ble cir­cum­s­tances into account. Howe­ver, the duty to inves­ti­ga­te ex offi­cio ends whe­re the applicant’s duty to coope­ra­te beg­ins. Tur­no­ver figu­res, the fixed-cost struc­tu­re and the reasons for a decli­ne in tur­no­ver fall exclu­si­ve­ly within the remit of the com­pa­ny. The gran­ting aut­ho­ri­ties deal with high-volu­me appli­ca­ti­ons and will not, on their own initia­ti­ve, seek out alter­na­ti­ve cost items.

What makes a good statement of grounds for an appeal

A sub­stan­ti­ve jus­ti­fi­ca­ti­on beg­ins with a com­pre­hen­si­ve account of the facts: the busi­ness model, the months cover­ed by the grant, and the finan­cial per­for­mance during the grant peri­od. All essen­ti­al infor­ma­ti­on must be included in the text. Sup­port­ing docu­ments are important, but they are no sub­sti­tu­te for your own pre­sen­ta­ti­on of the case.

Auxi­lia­ry and sub­sti­tu­te claims are par­ti­cu­lar­ly important. If the appro­ving aut­ho­ri­ty dis­al­lows ren­tal expen­ses on the grounds that it assu­mes a group of com­pa­nies exists, the appeal should expli­cit­ly, and as an alter­na­ti­ve cla­im, also assert the landlord’s buil­ding expen­ses, sup­port­ed by pro­per­ty tax assess­ment noti­ces, loan agree­ments and uti­li­ty bills. If this alter­na­ti­ve cla­im is miss­ing, the court will not be able to take it into account at a later stage.

  • Pre­sent the facts ful­ly and in a struc­tu­red manner
  • Plea­se attach all sup­port­ing docu­ments as evi­dence; they are not a sub­sti­tu­te for your presentation
  • Sta­te requests for assis­tance rela­ting to indi­vi­du­al cost items explicitly
  • Iden­ti­fy legal grounds for chall­enge, such as the prin­ci­ple of pro­tec­tion of legi­ti­ma­te expec­ta­ti­ons or the bin­ding effect of the FAQs
  • Include spe­ci­fic claims at the end of the noti­ce of appeal

Liability risks for tax advisers

Tax advi­sers who have acted as inde­pen­dent third-par­ty audi­tors and are now also hand­ling the appeal bear a con­sidera­ble degree of per­so­nal respon­si­bi­li­ty in this regard. Anyo­ne who keeps the grounds for an appeal so brief that alter­na­ti­ve posi­ti­ons are not men­tio­ned will lose them for good. The cli­ent often only rea­li­ses this when the Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court rejects the sub­mis­si­on on the grounds that it was lodged too late and rai­ses the ques­ti­on of recourse.

Even advice to refrain from lodging an appeal altog­e­ther, on the grounds that the reco­very of the funds is a fore­go­ne con­clu­si­on, may have impli­ca­ti­ons for lia­bi­li­ty. In many cir­cum­s­tances, this assess­ment is incor­rect. Anyo­ne who is unsu­re should seek advice in good time from a soli­ci­tor expe­ri­en­ced in admi­nis­tra­ti­ve law.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this