The final settlements for the coronavirus bridging aid are still keeping numerous businesses and their advisers busy. Anyone who has received a notice of reduction or recovery often thinks in two stages: first, lodge an appeal; then, if necessary, take the matter to court. However, this approach can prove costly.
An appeal is the last chance to present new evidence
In many federal states, there is no formal appeal procedure at all for bridging aid. Bavaria, North Rhine-Westphalia and Hesse are examples of this: in those states, lodging an out-of-court appeal does not suspend the finality of the decision. The direct route is to the administrative court.
Even in states with an appeal procedure, such as Hamburg, Lower Saxony or Baden-Württemberg, an important restriction applies: the Administrative Court generally examines the facts of the case as established by the authority. New factual submissions are rarely accepted at a later stage. The Karlsruhe Administrative Court clearly illustrated this in July 2026 (judgement of 7 July 2026, ref. 8 K 12012/25). In that case, ancillary rental costs of 383 euros had been inadvertently entered under the wrong cost item. As the error was only noticed during the oral hearing, the claim was rejected, even though the basic eligibility for funding was never in dispute.
The most common mistake: a brief explanation lacking in substance
In practice, tax advisers – acting as so-called ‘third-party reviewers’ – often initially lodge an appeal merely to meet the deadline, i.e. without providing grounds. This is permissible. The situation becomes problematic if little else follows. Grounds for appeal that merely state that the funds were used for their intended purpose and ask the authority to please examine the documents provided usually do not result in a genuine substantive review. The outcome is a notice of appeal decision that simply confirms the original decision.
A common misconception in this regard is the reference to what is known as ‘ex officio investigation’. Under the Administrative Procedure Act, the authority is indeed required to establish the facts of the case on its own initiative and to take favourable circumstances into account. However, the duty to investigate ex officio ends where the applicant’s duty to cooperate begins. Turnover figures, the fixed-cost structure and the reasons for a decline in turnover fall exclusively within the remit of the company. The granting authorities deal with high-volume applications and will not, on their own initiative, seek out alternative cost items.
What makes a good statement of grounds for an appeal
A substantive justification begins with a comprehensive account of the facts: the business model, the months covered by the grant, and the financial performance during the grant period. All essential information must be included in the text. Supporting documents are important, but they are no substitute for your own presentation of the case.
Auxiliary and substitute claims are particularly important. If the approving authority disallows rental expenses on the grounds that it assumes a group of companies exists, the appeal should explicitly, and as an alternative claim, also assert the landlord’s building expenses, supported by property tax assessment notices, loan agreements and utility bills. If this alternative claim is missing, the court will not be able to take it into account at a later stage.
- Present the facts fully and in a structured manner
- Please attach all supporting documents as evidence; they are not a substitute for your presentation
- State requests for assistance relating to individual cost items explicitly
- Identify legal grounds for challenge, such as the principle of protection of legitimate expectations or the binding effect of the FAQs
- Include specific claims at the end of the notice of appeal
Liability risks for tax advisers
Tax advisers who have acted as independent third-party auditors and are now also handling the appeal bear a considerable degree of personal responsibility in this regard. Anyone who keeps the grounds for an appeal so brief that alternative positions are not mentioned will lose them for good. The client often only realises this when the Administrative Court rejects the submission on the grounds that it was lodged too late and raises the question of recourse.
Even advice to refrain from lodging an appeal altogether, on the grounds that the recovery of the funds is a foregone conclusion, may have implications for liability. In many circumstances, this assessment is incorrect. Anyone who is unsure should seek advice in good time from a solicitor experienced in administrative law.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.