Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Insolvency whilst receiving bridging support: No entitlement to payment or back payment

Munich Hig­her Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court: Insol­vent com­pa­nies are not entit­led to bridging aid – not even in the final settlement. 
Insolvency whilst receiving bridging support: No entitlement to payment or back payment

Insolvency whilst receiving bridging support: No entitlement to payment or back payment

Any com­pa­ny that has appli­ed for bridging aid and sub­se­quent­ly beco­mes insol­vent loses its entit­le­ment to pay­ment. This also appli­es if the final sett­le­ment shows that a fur­ther pay­ment is due. The Bava­ri­an Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court in Munich has cle­ar­ly estab­lished this posi­ti­on in a recent ruling (VGH Munich, ruling of 1 July 2026, ref. 21 ZB 25.432).

What had happened?

A restau­rant orga­nis­ed as a public limi­t­ed com­pa­ny had appli­ed for Bridging Aid III amoun­ting to around 329,000 euros in Sep­tem­ber 2021. The appro­ving aut­ho­ri­ty rejec­ted the appli­ca­ti­on in Octo­ber 2022, whereu­pon the com­pa­ny brought legal pro­cee­dings. Whilst the legal pro­cee­dings were ongo­ing, insol­ven­cy pro­cee­dings were ope­ned in respect of the company’s assets in ear­ly Janu­ary 2025. The court was initi­al­ly una­wa­re of this and dis­missed the cla­im in Febru­ary 2025. It was only during the sub­se­quent lea­ve to appeal pro­cee­dings that the court of appeal beca­me awa­re of the insolvency.

No entitlement in the event of insolvency

The Munich Hig­her Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court upheld the rejec­tion. Under the fun­ding gui­de­lines for Bridging Aid III, the appro­ving aut­ho­ri­ty may not dis­bur­se funds if it is awa­re that the appli­cant has cea­sed tra­ding or filed for insol­ven­cy. The court fol­lo­wed admi­nis­tra­ti­ve prac­ti­ce, accor­ding to which the pro­hi­bi­ti­on on dis­bur­se­ment neces­s­a­ri­ly also encom­pas­ses the gran­ting of the aid its­elf. Anyo­ne who is not per­mit­ted to dis­bur­se funds is also not per­mit­ted to grant them. Other­wi­se, the pur­po­se of the fun­ding would be defea­ted from the outset.

The pur­po­se of the bridging aid is to safe­guard the eco­no­mic via­bi­li­ty of ongo­ing busi­nesses. An insol­vent busi­ness can no lon­ger ful­fil this pur­po­se. The court did not regard this as a breach of the prin­ci­ple of equa­li­ty, as insol­vent and non-insol­vent busi­nesses are fun­da­men­tal­ly dif­fe­rent in terms of their eco­no­mic situation.

Any additional payments arising from the final statement are also excluded

Ano­ther point is of par­ti­cu­lar prac­ti­cal rele­van­ce. The exclu­si­on appli­es not only to ongo­ing appli­ca­ti­on pro­ce­du­res, but also to sup­ple­men­ta­ry pay­ments made as part of the final sett­le­ment. Even if a com­pa­ny was, in prin­ci­ple, eli­gi­ble for fun­ding and the sett­le­ment reve­als a cla­im to a sup­ple­men­ta­ry pay­ment, this cla­im lap­ses upon the com­mence­ment of insol­ven­cy pro­cee­dings. For insol­ven­cy prac­ti­tio­ners, this means that a final sett­le­ment show­ing a posi­ti­ve balan­ce is not a secu­red cla­im against the estate.

Obligation to report insolvency

The court has also express­ly ruled that the fil­ing for insol­ven­cy and the com­mence­ment of pro­cee­dings con­sti­tu­te what are known as ‘facts rele­vant to the grant’. The com­pa­ny is the­r­e­fo­re obli­ged to noti­fy the gran­ting aut­ho­ri­ty of both wit­hout delay. This obli­ga­ti­on ari­ses from the Sub­si­dies Act and has cri­mi­nal law impli­ca­ti­ons. Anyo­ne who con­ce­als facts rele­vant to sub­si­dies risks pro­se­cu­ti­on for sub­s­idy fraud under Sec­tion 264 of the Cri­mi­nal Code. This cri­mi­nal pro­vi­si­on appli­es even in cases of reck­less con­duct, i.e. even whe­re the­re is no deli­be­ra­te deception.

What does this mean for those affected?

Busi­nesses for which a bridging aid pro­ce­du­re or a final sett­le­ment is still ongo­ing should check whe­ther insol­ven­cy has been filed for or pro­cee­dings ope­ned in the mean­ti­me. In this case, noti­fy­ing the gran­ting aut­ho­ri­ty is a mat­ter of urgent prio­ri­ty. At the same time, a rea­li­stic assess­ment should be made as to whe­ther ongo­ing legal pro­cee­dings still make eco­no­mic sen­se. The Munich Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court makes it clear that, whilst such pro­cee­dings remain admis­si­ble, they have litt­le pro­s­pect of suc­cess on the merits.

The decis­i­on is not yet final. Howe­ver, it is con­sis­tent with a clear and well-docu­men­ted admi­nis­tra­ti­ve prac­ti­ce. Anyo­ne fin­ding them­sel­ves in such a situa­ti­on should seek legal and tax advice.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this