Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Property tax: Major refurbishment resets the year of construction – and this has consequences

A major refur­bish­ment can reset a building’s year of con­s­truc­tion for the pur­po­ses of coun­cil tax. What owners need to know now. 
Property tax: Major refurbishment resets the year of construction – and this has consequences

Property tax: Major refurbishment resets the year of construction – and this has consequences

Anyo­ne car­ry­ing out a com­ple­te refur­bish­ment of an older buil­ding must expect the tax office to tre­at the year of the refur­bish­ment as the new year of con­s­truc­tion for the pur­po­ses of pro­per­ty tax assess­ment. This was cla­ri­fied by the Saxon Finan­ce Court in a recent jud­ge­ment dated 27 April 2026 (Ref. 2 K 1283/25).

What had happened?

The owner of a block of flats had purcha­sed the buil­ding back in 1997. At the time, a lar­ge part of the purcha­se pri­ce was attri­bu­ta­ble to out­stan­ding reno­va­ti­on work; accor­ding to the tax office, the buil­ding was in an unin­ha­bi­ta­ble con­di­ti­on. Exten­si­ve refur­bish­ment work fol­lo­wed in 1998 and 1999: con­ver­si­on of the attic, addi­ti­on of a storey, con­s­truc­tion of a bal­c­o­ny and altera­ti­ons to the flo­or plan.

In the main pro­per­ty tax assess­ment as at 1 Janu­ary 2022, the tax office used 1991 as the notio­nal year of con­s­truc­tion – that is, the year in which the com­pre­hen­si­ve refur­bish­ment was com­ple­ted. This resul­ted in a remai­ning useful life of 49 years. The owner objec­ted, arguing that the ori­gi­nal year of con­s­truc­tion was 1896 and that, taking into account the actu­al ext­ent of the refur­bish­ment in accordance with the Pro­per­ty Valua­ti­on Ordi­nan­ce (Immo­WertV), the remai­ning useful life was only 23 years.

What was the court’s ruling?

The Tax Court dis­missed the cla­im. It upheld the tax office’s cal­cu­la­ti­on, high­light­ing two key points in the process.

A major refurbishment results in a new notional year of construction

In prin­ci­ple, the actu­al year of con­s­truc­tion of a buil­ding is used for valua­ti­on pur­po­ses. Howe­ver, the Valua­ti­on Act pro­vi­des for an excep­ti­on: if altera­ti­ons have been made after the buil­ding was rea­dy for occu­pa­ti­on which have signi­fi­cant­ly exten­ded the building’s over­all eco­no­mic useful life, the year in which the­se altera­ti­ons took place is taken as the notio­nal year of con­s­truc­tion. A major refur­bish­ment, in which the buil­ding is res­to­red to a con­di­ti­on that is vir­tual­ly equi­va­lent to a new build, meets this cri­ter­ion. The rele­vant admi­nis­tra­ti­ve gui­de­lines (Sec­tion 253.1 AEBew­GrSt) express­ly pro­vi­de for this.

In the pre­sent case, the infor­ma­ti­on con­tai­ned in the owner’s own decla­ra­ti­on, the break­down of the purcha­se pri­ce in the con­tract and pre­vious com­mu­ni­ca­ti­ons to the tax office all poin­ted to such a major refurbishment.

The ImmoWertV does not apply here

The owner wis­hed to app­ly the Immo­WertV in order to cal­cu­la­te a shorter remai­ning useful life on the basis of a lower level of moder­ni­sa­ti­on. The court rejec­ted this. Under valua­ti­on law for pro­per­ty tax pur­po­ses, the Immo­WertV may, at most, be taken into account when deter­mi­ning land values. With regard to the capi­ta­li­sed net yield for resi­den­ti­al ren­tal pro­per­ties, the Valua­ti­on Act does not refer to the Immo­WertV or the Buil­ding Code.

The burden of proof lies with the taxpayer

Anyo­ne wis­hing to cla­im a lower pro­per­ty tax valua­ti­on must pro­vi­de evi­dence of this them­sel­ves. The clai­mant did not sub­mit an expert report that would have sub­stan­tia­ted a lower mar­ket value. The court express­ly refer­red to the rele­vant case law of the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH, jud­ge­ment of 17 Novem­ber 2021, ref. II R 26/20): the tax court is not obli­ged to obtain an expert report on its own initiative.

What does this mean for property owners?

Anyo­ne who has car­ri­ed out a com­ple­te refur­bish­ment of a buil­ding should docu­ment in detail, for the pur­po­ses of pro­per­ty tax valua­ti­on, exact­ly which mea­su­res were actual­ly car­ri­ed out and whe­ther any essen­ti­al struc­tu­ral ele­ments were retai­ned. The more com­pre­hen­si­ve the refur­bish­ment, the clo­ser the notio­nal year of con­s­truc­tion will be to the year of refur­bish­ment, which may extend the remai­ning useful life and increase the pro­per­ty tax value. Anyo­ne see­king a lower valua­ti­on bears the bur­den of pro­of and should com­mis­si­on a qua­li­fied valua­ti­on report. In case of doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to seek tax advice befo­re lodging an objec­tion or brin­ging legal proceedings.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this