Anyone carrying out a complete refurbishment of an older building must expect the tax office to treat the year of the refurbishment as the new year of construction for the purposes of property tax assessment. This was clarified by the Saxon Finance Court in a recent judgement dated 27 April 2026 (Ref. 2 K 1283/25).
What had happened?
The owner of a block of flats had purchased the building back in 1997. At the time, a large part of the purchase price was attributable to outstanding renovation work; according to the tax office, the building was in an uninhabitable condition. Extensive refurbishment work followed in 1998 and 1999: conversion of the attic, addition of a storey, construction of a balcony and alterations to the floor plan.
In the main property tax assessment as at 1 January 2022, the tax office used 1991 as the notional year of construction – that is, the year in which the comprehensive refurbishment was completed. This resulted in a remaining useful life of 49 years. The owner objected, arguing that the original year of construction was 1896 and that, taking into account the actual extent of the refurbishment in accordance with the Property Valuation Ordinance (ImmoWertV), the remaining useful life was only 23 years.
What was the court’s ruling?
The Tax Court dismissed the claim. It upheld the tax office’s calculation, highlighting two key points in the process.
A major refurbishment results in a new notional year of construction
In principle, the actual year of construction of a building is used for valuation purposes. However, the Valuation Act provides for an exception: if alterations have been made after the building was ready for occupation which have significantly extended the building’s overall economic useful life, the year in which these alterations took place is taken as the notional year of construction. A major refurbishment, in which the building is restored to a condition that is virtually equivalent to a new build, meets this criterion. The relevant administrative guidelines (Section 253.1 AEBewGrSt) expressly provide for this.
In the present case, the information contained in the owner’s own declaration, the breakdown of the purchase price in the contract and previous communications to the tax office all pointed to such a major refurbishment.
The ImmoWertV does not apply here
The owner wished to apply the ImmoWertV in order to calculate a shorter remaining useful life on the basis of a lower level of modernisation. The court rejected this. Under valuation law for property tax purposes, the ImmoWertV may, at most, be taken into account when determining land values. With regard to the capitalised net yield for residential rental properties, the Valuation Act does not refer to the ImmoWertV or the Building Code.
The burden of proof lies with the taxpayer
Anyone wishing to claim a lower property tax valuation must provide evidence of this themselves. The claimant did not submit an expert report that would have substantiated a lower market value. The court expressly referred to the relevant case law of the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH, judgement of 17 November 2021, ref. II R 26/20): the tax court is not obliged to obtain an expert report on its own initiative.
What does this mean for property owners?
Anyone who has carried out a complete refurbishment of a building should document in detail, for the purposes of property tax valuation, exactly which measures were actually carried out and whether any essential structural elements were retained. The more comprehensive the refurbishment, the closer the notional year of construction will be to the year of refurbishment, which may extend the remaining useful life and increase the property tax value. Anyone seeking a lower valuation bears the burden of proof and should commission a qualified valuation report. In case of doubt, it is advisable to seek tax advice before lodging an objection or bringing legal proceedings.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.