A telecommunications provider laid fibre-optic cables in a block of flats without authorisation, installed distribution boxes, drilled holes in the building structure and connected flats up to the fourth floor. All of this was done without the owner’s knowledge. The company’s justification was that a tenant had taken out a fibre-optic contract, and that was sufficient. The Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe has clearly rejected this argument.
What the court ruled
In its judgement of 24 June 2026 (Case No. 6 W 15/26), the Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe ruled entirely in favour of the owner. The consent of an individual tenant does not replace the owner’s consent. The court ordered the complete removal of all installed fixtures and prohibited the contractor from carrying out any further building works on any of the owner’s properties without her express consent. Any breaches are liable to result in an administrative fine of up to 250,000 euros.
When, in fact, is there an obligation to grant temporary residence?
Section 145(1) of the Telecommunications Act (TKG) provides, under certain conditions, for an obligation on the part of the owner to allow access. However, this only applies if no equivalent network infrastructure is available within the building. In the present case, the building already had a high-performance network with download speeds of up to ten gigabits per second. The requested connection, with a speed of 300 megabits per second, could therefore be accommodated without any difficulty. In the court’s view, there was therefore no obligation to tolerate the installation.
European Gigabit legislation does nothing to change this
The provider also invoked the European Gigabit Infrastructure Regulation (GIV). Article 11(4) of the GIV does grant network operators the right to extend their network into the user’s home. However, the Higher Regional Court made it clear that this right always requires the owner’s consent. EU law therefore does not override property rights.
Exercising one’s own authority despite an alternative offer
One further factor carried particular weight: the owner had already concluded a contract with another company for the roll-out of fibre-optic cables to all the properties and had offered the claimant provider the opportunity to share use of the completed network. The provider refused and began construction on its own initiative. The court deemed this course of action to be an unlawful act of self-help.
What does this mean for landlords and flat owners?
This ruling sends an important message to all owners of blocks of flats and housing associations. Any landlord who discovers that a telecoms provider is carrying out building works in the building without prior consultation can invoke this ruling. An interim injunction is an effective means of taking swift action in such cases.
- A tenant’s consent is not sufficient for the installation of fibre-optic cables in the building.
- An obligation to grant access under the Telecommunications Act (TKG) applies only if no equivalent infrastructure is available.
- Carrying out unauthorised extension work despite an alternative offer being available is unlawful.
- Complete removal and cessation of the activity may be enforced through the courts.
In individual cases, it is advisable to seek legal advice, particularly if building work has already been carried out without consent or if a service provider insists on an alleged right of access.
Source: Haufe: Property
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.