Many businesses and self-employed people who received government financial support during the coronavirus pandemic are currently facing an unpleasant problem: years after the original approval, the authorities are requesting additional documentation; when they receive no response, they are simply reducing the total amount of support to zero. In a recent ruling, the Higher Administrative Court in Münster has deemed this course of action to be likely to be unlawful.
What the court ruled
In this specific case, a claimant had been granted ‘Neustarthilfe Plus’ assistance of 4,750 euros in November 2021. He submitted the final statement of account on time via an independent auditor. Just under two years later, in the spring of 2025, the authority suddenly requested a personally signed application form. The claimant stated that he had never received these requests. In July 2025, the authority issued a final decision and reduced the grant to zero.
The Higher Administrative Court of Münster granted the claimant legal aid for the action brought against this decision and considered his appeal likely to succeed. The decision was handed down on 13 August 2026 (case number 4 E 115/26).
The key legal argument
The Senate bases its decision on a fundamental distinction: whilst the original grant notification was subject to a subsequent final determination, this reservation related exclusively to the actual turnover figures for the funding period, which were not yet known at the time of the grant award. By contrast, the claimant’s eligibility to apply and the basis for calculation had already been established at the time of approval and were therefore legally finalised.
This means that the authority may not simply reopen the case in its final decision and overturn the entire grant on the basis of documents requested retrospectively. Anyone who receives a grant thereby acquires a secure legal position, which may not be interfered with without good reason.
Furthermore, any ambiguities in the grant notice are to the detriment of the authority, not the applicant. If it is not clearly stated in the notice that the failure to submit supplementary documents permits the grant to be set at zero, the authority cannot rely on this either.
What consequences this has for ongoing proceedings
If the authority wishes to withdraw funding that has already been granted, it must follow the formal procedure of revocation or withdrawal. These procedures, set out in Sections 48 and 49 of the Administrative Procedure Act, are considerably more complex and require the authority to exercise its discretion. A simple rejection in the final decision is not sufficient for this purpose.
It is also worth noting that the Senate considers it significant if missing documents are submitted at a later stage whilst legal proceedings are still ongoing. A case is therefore not automatically lost simply because no response was given to requests from the authorities.
What this means for those affected
This ruling is not the only one of its kind. The same panel has taken the same line in three decisions within the space of a few weeks. Anyone who has recently received a final decision setting their coronavirus support at zero solely because of a failure to submit additional documentation should check the following points:
- Is the decision not yet final? If so, the time limit for lodging an appeal or bringing legal proceedings is still running and must be strictly observed.
- What exactly does the original grant notification cover? To what extent does the reservation regarding the final settlement apply?
- Is the final decision based solely on missing documents, without providing grounds for a withdrawal or revocation?
- Can missing documents still be submitted at a later date, including, where applicable, during appeal or legal proceedings?
As this is a ruling in legal aid proceedings – that is, following a summary, preliminary examination – the final decision on the merits of the case is still pending. However, the court’s legal stance is clear. Affected business owners and the self-employed should seek legal advice in order to assess their prospects in individual cases.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.