Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Coronavirus support: A claim for repayment to zero is inadmissible solely on the grounds of missing documentation

Coronavirus support: A claim for repayment to zero is inadmissible solely on the grounds of missing documentation

Many busi­nesses and self-employ­ed peo­p­le who recei­ved govern­ment finan­cial sup­port during the coro­na­vi­rus pan­de­mic are curr­ent­ly facing an unp­lea­sant pro­blem: years after the ori­gi­nal appr­oval, the aut­ho­ri­ties are reques­t­ing addi­tio­nal docu­men­ta­ti­on; when they recei­ve no respon­se, they are sim­ply redu­cing the total amount of sup­port to zero. In a recent ruling, the Hig­her Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court in Müns­ter has dee­med this cour­se of action to be likely to be unlawful.

What the court ruled

In this spe­ci­fic case, a clai­mant had been gran­ted ‘Neu­start­hil­fe Plus’ assis­tance of 4,750 euros in Novem­ber 2021. He sub­mit­ted the final state­ment of account on time via an inde­pen­dent audi­tor. Just under two years later, in the spring of 2025, the aut­ho­ri­ty sud­den­ly reques­ted a per­so­nal­ly signed appli­ca­ti­on form. The clai­mant sta­ted that he had never recei­ved the­se requests. In July 2025, the aut­ho­ri­ty issued a final decis­i­on and redu­ced the grant to zero.

The Hig­her Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court of Müns­ter gran­ted the clai­mant legal aid for the action brought against this decis­i­on and con­side­red his appeal likely to suc­ceed. The decis­i­on was han­ded down on 13 August 2026 (case num­ber 4 E 115/26).

The key legal argument

The Sena­te bases its decis­i­on on a fun­da­men­tal distinc­tion: whilst the ori­gi­nal grant noti­fi­ca­ti­on was sub­ject to a sub­se­quent final deter­mi­na­ti­on, this reser­va­ti­on rela­ted exclu­si­ve­ly to the actu­al tur­no­ver figu­res for the fun­ding peri­od, which were not yet known at the time of the grant award. By con­trast, the claimant’s eli­gi­bi­li­ty to app­ly and the basis for cal­cu­la­ti­on had alre­a­dy been estab­lished at the time of appr­oval and were the­r­e­fo­re legal­ly finalised.

This means that the aut­ho­ri­ty may not sim­ply reopen the case in its final decis­i­on and over­turn the enti­re grant on the basis of docu­ments reques­ted retro­s­pec­tively. Anyo­ne who recei­ves a grant ther­eby acqui­res a secu­re legal posi­ti­on, which may not be inter­fe­red with wit­hout good reason.

Fur­ther­mo­re, any ambi­gui­ties in the grant noti­ce are to the detri­ment of the aut­ho­ri­ty, not the appli­cant. If it is not cle­ar­ly sta­ted in the noti­ce that the fail­ure to sub­mit sup­ple­men­ta­ry docu­ments per­mits the grant to be set at zero, the aut­ho­ri­ty can­not rely on this either.

What consequences this has for ongoing proceedings

If the aut­ho­ri­ty wis­hes to with­draw fun­ding that has alre­a­dy been gran­ted, it must fol­low the for­mal pro­ce­du­re of revo­ca­ti­on or with­dra­wal. The­se pro­ce­du­res, set out in Sec­tions 48 and 49 of the Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Pro­ce­du­re Act, are con­sider­a­b­ly more com­plex and requi­re the aut­ho­ri­ty to exer­cise its dis­cre­ti­on. A simp­le rejec­tion in the final decis­i­on is not suf­fi­ci­ent for this purpose.

It is also worth not­ing that the Sena­te con­siders it signi­fi­cant if miss­ing docu­ments are sub­mit­ted at a later stage whilst legal pro­cee­dings are still ongo­ing. A case is the­r­e­fo­re not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly lost sim­ply becau­se no respon­se was given to requests from the authorities.

What this means for those affected

This ruling is not the only one of its kind. The same panel has taken the same line in three decis­i­ons within the space of a few weeks. Anyo­ne who has recent­ly recei­ved a final decis­i­on set­ting their coro­na­vi­rus sup­port at zero sole­ly becau­se of a fail­ure to sub­mit addi­tio­nal docu­men­ta­ti­on should check the fol­lo­wing points:

  • Is the decis­i­on not yet final? If so, the time limit for lodging an appeal or brin­ging legal pro­cee­dings is still run­ning and must be strict­ly observed.
  • What exact­ly does the ori­gi­nal grant noti­fi­ca­ti­on cover? To what ext­ent does the reser­va­ti­on regar­ding the final sett­le­ment apply?
  • Is the final decis­i­on based sole­ly on miss­ing docu­ments, wit­hout pro­vi­ding grounds for a with­dra­wal or revocation?
  • Can miss­ing docu­ments still be sub­mit­ted at a later date, inclu­ding, whe­re appli­ca­ble, during appeal or legal proceedings?

As this is a ruling in legal aid pro­cee­dings – that is, fol­lo­wing a sum­ma­ry, preli­mi­na­ry exami­na­ti­on – the final decis­i­on on the merits of the case is still pen­ding. Howe­ver, the court’s legal stance is clear. Affec­ted busi­ness owners and the self-employ­ed should seek legal advice in order to assess their pro­s­pects in indi­vi­du­al cases.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this