Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Failure to comply with the terms of a Covid-19 support scheme could jeopardise all other grants

Frank­furt Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court: Anyo­ne who acts unre­lia­bly in rela­ti­on to a Covid-19 sup­port sche­me risks having pay­ments reclai­med from all other schemes. 
Failure to comply with the terms of a Covid-19 support scheme could jeopardise all other grants

Failure to comply with the terms of a Covid-19 support scheme could jeopardise all other grants

Anyo­ne who has pro­vi­ded incor­rect or incom­ple­te infor­ma­ti­on in rela­ti­on to a coro­na­vi­rus sup­port sche­me risks more than just having that par­ti­cu­lar pay­ment reclai­med. A jud­ge­ment by the Frank­furt am Main Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court dated 20 May 2026 shows that a fin­ding of unre­lia­bi­li­ty in one sche­me can also jus­ti­fy the reco­very of pay­ments from other sup­port packa­ges. The case refe­rence is 5 K 2065/25.F.

What had happened?

The clai­mant, the owner of a café, had recei­ved a total of around 101,000 euros in Bridging Aid III and the Novem­ber Aid. In June 2021, he sub­mit­ted invoices from a sup­pli­er as pro­of of hygie­ne-rela­ted cos­ts. The­se invoices were can­cel­led short­ly after­wards. The clai­mant was obli­ged to inform the gran­ting aut­ho­ri­ty of such chan­ges wit­hout delay. He fai­led to do so. It was only when the aut­ho­ri­ty made an expli­cit enquiry two years later that he admit­ted to the can­cel­la­ti­on. He explai­ned that he had sub­se­quent­ly pro­cu­red the goods from ano­ther sup­pli­er, albeit out­side the fun­ding period.

The aut­ho­ri­ty revo­ked the Bridging Aid III on the grounds of abu­se of dis­cre­tio­na­ry powers. A noti­ce of rejec­tion was issued in respect of the Novem­ber aid, in which the repay­ment was jus­ti­fied on the grounds that the clai­mant was not a relia­ble reci­pi­ent under the fun­ding regu­la­ti­ons. This was based pre­cis­e­ly on the events ari­sing from the pro­cee­dings con­cer­ning Bridging Aid III.

The court’s key finding

The Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court upheld this approach. It tre­ats the applicant’s per­so­nal relia­bi­li­ty as a sepa­ra­te eli­gi­bi­li­ty cri­ter­ion. Anyo­ne who loses their relia­bi­li­ty sta­tus in one pro­gram­me may also be clas­si­fied as unre­lia­ble in other pro­gram­mes if the tem­po­ral and fac­tu­al pro­xi­mi­ty of the pro­cee­dings jus­ti­fies this. Alt­hough the indi­vi­du­al COVID-19 sup­port pro­gram­mes are legal­ly sepa­ra­te, they are in fact lin­ked by the cri­ter­ion of reliability.

No exoneration following the discontinuation of criminal proceedings

The Hanau Local Court had dis­con­tin­ued the preli­mi­na­ry inves­ti­ga­ti­on into sub­s­idy fraud under Sec­tion 153(2) of the Code of Cri­mi­nal Pro­ce­du­re, that is, on the grounds that the offence was minor. The Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court did not regard this dis­con­ti­nua­tion as exo­ne­ra­ting. The aut­ho­ri­ty is not bound by cri­mi­nal law prin­ci­ples, such as the pre­sump­ti­on of inno­cence, in the area of bene­fits admi­nis­tra­ti­on. A dis­con­ti­nua­tion on the grounds of insi­gni­fi­can­ce is not an acquit­tal and does not pre­vent the gran­ting aut­ho­ri­ty from taking action under sub­s­idy law.

What does that mean in practice?

This decis­i­on is of con­sidera­ble signi­fi­can­ce for anyo­ne who is still under­go­ing the final sett­le­ment pro­cess or who has recei­ved enqui­ries from the aut­ho­ri­ties. Mis­con­duct in a sin­gle sup­port sche­me – such as a fail­ure to com­ply with a report­ing obli­ga­ti­on – can jeo­par­di­se fun­ding under all schemes.

  • Any enqui­ries from the gran­ting aut­ho­ri­ty should be ans­we­red ful­ly and truthfully.
  • Any chan­ges to the ori­gi­nal details – such as can­cel­led invoices or a chan­ge of sup­pli­er – must be repor­ted immediately.
  • Anyo­ne who only admits to chan­ges when asked to do so risks being accu­sed of unre­lia­bi­li­ty, with con­se­quen­ces for all grants received.

Howe­ver, the court sug­gests that this lack of relia­bi­li­ty does not have a per­ma­nent effect. Fol­lo­wing a so-cal­led ‘pro­ba­tio­na­ry peri­od’, it may be pos­si­ble to par­ti­ci­pa­te in govern­ment sup­port pro­gram­mes once again.

It is not yet known whe­ther the jud­ge­ment will beco­me final. In the case of ongo­ing reco­very pro­cee­dings based on a breach of fun­ding regu­la­ti­ons, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice at an ear­ly stage. The sums invol­ved can be sub­stan­ti­al across seve­ral programmes.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this