Anyone who has provided incorrect or incomplete information in relation to a coronavirus support scheme risks more than just having that particular payment reclaimed. A judgement by the Frankfurt am Main Administrative Court dated 20 May 2026 shows that a finding of unreliability in one scheme can also justify the recovery of payments from other support packages. The case reference is 5 K 2065/25.F.
What had happened?
The claimant, the owner of a café, had received a total of around 101,000 euros in Bridging Aid III and the November Aid. In June 2021, he submitted invoices from a supplier as proof of hygiene-related costs. These invoices were cancelled shortly afterwards. The claimant was obliged to inform the granting authority of such changes without delay. He failed to do so. It was only when the authority made an explicit enquiry two years later that he admitted to the cancellation. He explained that he had subsequently procured the goods from another supplier, albeit outside the funding period.
The authority revoked the Bridging Aid III on the grounds of abuse of discretionary powers. A notice of rejection was issued in respect of the November aid, in which the repayment was justified on the grounds that the claimant was not a reliable recipient under the funding regulations. This was based precisely on the events arising from the proceedings concerning Bridging Aid III.
The court’s key finding
The Administrative Court upheld this approach. It treats the applicant’s personal reliability as a separate eligibility criterion. Anyone who loses their reliability status in one programme may also be classified as unreliable in other programmes if the temporal and factual proximity of the proceedings justifies this. Although the individual COVID-19 support programmes are legally separate, they are in fact linked by the criterion of reliability.
No exoneration following the discontinuation of criminal proceedings
The Hanau Local Court had discontinued the preliminary investigation into subsidy fraud under Section 153(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, that is, on the grounds that the offence was minor. The Administrative Court did not regard this discontinuation as exonerating. The authority is not bound by criminal law principles, such as the presumption of innocence, in the area of benefits administration. A discontinuation on the grounds of insignificance is not an acquittal and does not prevent the granting authority from taking action under subsidy law.
What does that mean in practice?
This decision is of considerable significance for anyone who is still undergoing the final settlement process or who has received enquiries from the authorities. Misconduct in a single support scheme – such as a failure to comply with a reporting obligation – can jeopardise funding under all schemes.
- Any enquiries from the granting authority should be answered fully and truthfully.
- Any changes to the original details – such as cancelled invoices or a change of supplier – must be reported immediately.
- Anyone who only admits to changes when asked to do so risks being accused of unreliability, with consequences for all grants received.
However, the court suggests that this lack of reliability does not have a permanent effect. Following a so-called ‘probationary period’, it may be possible to participate in government support programmes once again.
It is not yet known whether the judgement will become final. In the case of ongoing recovery proceedings based on a breach of funding regulations, it is advisable to seek legal advice at an early stage. The sums involved can be substantial across several programmes.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.