Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Incorrect tax code in the ERP system: Not a calculation error within the meaning of the Tax Code

An incor­rect tax code in the ERP sys­tem does not con­sti­tu­te a cal­cu­la­ti­on error under Sec­tion 173a of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO) – the Lower Sax­o­ny Fis­cal Court does not per­mit the cor­rec­tion of the tax assess­ment notice. 
Incorrect tax code in the ERP system: Not a calculation error within the meaning of the Tax Code

Incorrect tax code in the ERP system: Not a calculation error within the meaning of the Tax Code

Anyo­ne who has ente­red an incor­rect tax code in their accoun­ting or ERP sys­tem and, as a result, has clai­med too litt­le input tax can­not sim­ply have a VAT assess­ment that has alre­a­dy beco­me final cor­rec­ted. This was ruled by the Lower Sax­o­ny Finan­ce Court in its jud­ge­ment of 19 March 2026 (Case No. 5 K 137/25).

What had happened?

Fol­lo­wing a tax audit and the sub­se­quent fina­li­sa­ti­on of its VAT assess­ment, a com­pa­ny rea­li­sed that an incor­rect tax code had been ente­red in its ERP sys­tem. This error meant that too litt­le input VAT was deduc­ted when the VAT return was pre­pared. The com­pa­ny sought to have the assess­ment amen­ded retro­s­pec­tively, invo­king Sec­tion 173a of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO).

This pro­vi­si­on allows for the cor­rec­tion of a final tax assess­ment if the tax­pay­er made a cle­ri­cal or cal­cu­la­ti­on error whilst com­ple­ting their tax return and, as a result, pro­vi­ded the tax office with incor­rect information.

The Tax Court dismissed the claim

Both the tax office and the court rejec­ted the appli­ca­ti­on of Sec­tion 173a of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO). The Tax Court cla­ri­fied what is meant by a cal­cu­la­ti­on error within the mea­ning of this pro­vi­si­on: this refers to incor­rect mathe­ma­ti­cal ope­ra­ti­ons such as addi­ti­on, sub­trac­tion, mul­ti­pli­ca­ti­on or divi­si­on. Cle­ri­cal errors within the mea­ning of the pro­vi­si­on, on the other hand, are spel­ling mista­kes or incor­rect car­ry­ing over of figures.

In the pre­sent case, the com­pu­ter pro­gram­me had car­ri­ed out the cal­cu­la­ti­on its­elf cor­rect­ly. The error lay one step ear­lier: the data on which the cal­cu­la­ti­on was based was incor­rect becau­se the tax code ente­red was wrong. In the court’s view, this is not a cal­cu­la­ti­on or cle­ri­cal error, but a sub­stan­ti­ve error in the sys­tem con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on. Nor do other cor­rec­ti­ve mea­su­res pro­vi­ded for in the Tax Code app­ly in this instance.

Why is this important for businesses?

The ruling high­lights a gro­wing pro­blem in digi­ta­li­sed accoun­ting prac­ti­ce. The more pro­ces­ses are auto­ma­ted, the grea­ter the risk that errors will ari­se not in the cal­cu­la­ti­on pro­cess its­elf, but in the para­me­ters that were pre-pro­grammed into the sys­tem. Such con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on errors can go unno­ti­ced for months or years and lead to signi­fi­cant tax disadvantages.

The com­men­ta­tor on the jud­ge­ment points out that the legis­la­tu­re should extend the scope of appli­ca­ti­on of Sec­tion 173a of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO) to include such errors occur­ring pri­or to the actu­al cal­cu­la­ti­on pro­cess. The court its­elf has gran­ted lea­ve to appeal to the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court becau­se the issue is of fun­da­men­tal importance. It the­r­e­fo­re remains to be seen whe­ther the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court will inter­pret the con­cept of a cal­cu­la­ti­on error more broadly.

What does that mean in practice?

Com­pa­nies should regu­lar­ly check their ERP and accoun­ting sys­tems to ensu­re that tax codes are cor­rect­ly con­fi­gu­red, par­ti­cu­lar­ly fol­lo­wing sys­tem chan­ges or updates. If such an error is only dis­co­ver­ed after a tax assess­ment has beco­me final, the opti­ons for cor­rec­tion are very limi­t­ed. Anyo­ne fin­ding them­sel­ves in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should seek tax advice to explo­re all remai­ning ave­nues for correction.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this