Anyone who has entered an incorrect tax code in their accounting or ERP system and, as a result, has claimed too little input tax cannot simply have a VAT assessment that has already become final corrected. This was ruled by the Lower Saxony Finance Court in its judgement of 19 March 2026 (Case No. 5 K 137/25).
What had happened?
Following a tax audit and the subsequent finalisation of its VAT assessment, a company realised that an incorrect tax code had been entered in its ERP system. This error meant that too little input VAT was deducted when the VAT return was prepared. The company sought to have the assessment amended retrospectively, invoking Section 173a of the German Fiscal Code (AO).
This provision allows for the correction of a final tax assessment if the taxpayer made a clerical or calculation error whilst completing their tax return and, as a result, provided the tax office with incorrect information.
The Tax Court dismissed the claim
Both the tax office and the court rejected the application of Section 173a of the German Fiscal Code (AO). The Tax Court clarified what is meant by a calculation error within the meaning of this provision: this refers to incorrect mathematical operations such as addition, subtraction, multiplication or division. Clerical errors within the meaning of the provision, on the other hand, are spelling mistakes or incorrect carrying over of figures.
In the present case, the computer programme had carried out the calculation itself correctly. The error lay one step earlier: the data on which the calculation was based was incorrect because the tax code entered was wrong. In the court’s view, this is not a calculation or clerical error, but a substantive error in the system configuration. Nor do other corrective measures provided for in the Tax Code apply in this instance.
Why is this important for businesses?
The ruling highlights a growing problem in digitalised accounting practice. The more processes are automated, the greater the risk that errors will arise not in the calculation process itself, but in the parameters that were pre-programmed into the system. Such configuration errors can go unnoticed for months or years and lead to significant tax disadvantages.
The commentator on the judgement points out that the legislature should extend the scope of application of Section 173a of the German Fiscal Code (AO) to include such errors occurring prior to the actual calculation process. The court itself has granted leave to appeal to the Federal Fiscal Court because the issue is of fundamental importance. It therefore remains to be seen whether the Federal Finance Court will interpret the concept of a calculation error more broadly.
What does that mean in practice?
Companies should regularly check their ERP and accounting systems to ensure that tax codes are correctly configured, particularly following system changes or updates. If such an error is only discovered after a tax assessment has become final, the options for correction are very limited. Anyone finding themselves in a similar situation should seek tax advice to explore all remaining avenues for correction.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.