Anyone wishing to dismiss an employee with a severe disability must first involve the representative body for employees with severe disabilities (SBV). This also applies during the probationary period. The Federal Labour Court has now clarified what must be taken into account in this regard: A mere receipt stamp marked „acknowledged“ is not sufficient to shorten the waiting period (BAG, judgement of 29 January 2026, ref. 2 AZR 128/25).
The case: Dismissal during the probationary period
A man recognised as having a severe disability had been working for a local authority since October 2023, carrying out both office-based and field work, including traffic checks. The employment contract provided for a six-month probationary period. After he had arrived late on three occasions, a staff appraisal was held. Following this, his line manager recommended internally that the probationary period should not be continued.
The city consulted the staff council and informed the SBV of the planned termination on 7 December 2023. The letter was later stamped by the SBV on 11 December with the note „Acknowledged“. The city issued the notice of termination as early as 13 December, and it was served on the man on 14 December. He brought legal proceedings within the prescribed time limit, challenging, amongst other things, the improper involvement of the SBV.
The path through the courts
The Employment Tribunal ruled in favour of the claimant. The Regional Labour Court took a different view and dismissed the claim. The appeal to the Federal Labour Court was ultimately successful. The court reinstated the judgment of the court of first instance.
Why the notice of termination was invalid
Under Section 178(2) of SGB IX, a notice of termination is invalid if the works council has not been duly consulted. However, the Act does not specify a time limit for submitting comments. Case law has long filled this gap by applying Section 102(2) of the Works Constitution Act. In the case of ordinary dismissals, the SBV therefore has one week in which to submit its comments.
In this case, the letter was postmarked 11 December, so the deadline ran until the end of 18 December at the earliest. Even if one assumes that the SBV received the letter as early as 7 December, the week would not have expired until midnight on 14 December. However, the notice of termination was already delivered to the man on that day, and was therefore served too early.
What the note „Acknowledged“ means – and what it does not mean
The city argued that the SBV had made its final statement by affixing the stamp. The court did not agree with this. The stamp was neither an explicit consent nor a waiver of the right to comment. For the proceedings to be deemed concluded prematurely, there must be clear indications that the SBV no longer wishes to comment. There were no such indications. The employer should have enquired whether the SBV wished to make a further statement. It had failed to do so.
What this means in practice
- The SBV’s involvement applies to all cases of dismissal of people with severe disabilities, including during the probationary period and the waiting period under the Protection Against Dismissal Act.
- The one-week period begins when the SBV receives the notice. If notice is given earlier, the termination may be invalid.
- A receipt stamp or a note such as „Acknowledged“ does not automatically constitute a final response.
- If there is any uncertainty, it may be necessary to consult the SBV before giving notice.
- Employees should raise the issue of incorrect shareholding at an early stage. In this case, this had already been done in the statement of claim.
Whether a notice of termination is formally valid in a particular case depends on the exact circumstances. Employers and employees should therefore seek legal advice.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.