Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Dismissal of employees with severe disabilities: A „Noted“ stamp does not replace the SBV’s statement

The Fede­ral Labour Court (BAG) makes it clear: a “noted” stamp from the repre­sen­ta­ti­ves for peo­p­le with seve­re disa­bi­li­ties does not con­sti­tu­te a state­ment of opi­ni­on. A noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on issued too ear­ly is invalid. 
Dismissal of employees with severe disabilities: A "Noted" stamp does not replace the SBV’s statement

Dismissal of employees with severe disabilities: A „Noted“ stamp does not replace the SBV’s statement

Anyo­ne wis­hing to dis­miss an employee with a seve­re disa­bi­li­ty must first invol­ve the repre­sen­ta­ti­ve body for employees with seve­re disa­bi­li­ties (SBV). This also appli­es during the pro­ba­tio­na­ry peri­od. The Fede­ral Labour Court has now cla­ri­fied what must be taken into account in this regard: A mere receipt stamp mark­ed „ack­now­led­ged“ is not suf­fi­ci­ent to shor­ten the wai­ting peri­od (BAG, jud­ge­ment of 29 Janu­ary 2026, ref. 2 AZR 128/25).

The case: Dismissal during the probationary period

A man reco­g­nis­ed as having a seve­re disa­bi­li­ty had been working for a local aut­ho­ri­ty sin­ce Octo­ber 2023, car­ry­ing out both office-based and field work, inclu­ding traf­fic checks. The employ­ment con­tract pro­vi­ded for a six-month pro­ba­tio­na­ry peri­od. After he had arri­ved late on three occa­si­ons, a staff app­rai­sal was held. Fol­lo­wing this, his line mana­ger recom­men­ded intern­al­ly that the pro­ba­tio­na­ry peri­od should not be continued.

The city con­sul­ted the staff coun­cil and infor­med the SBV of the plan­ned ter­mi­na­ti­on on 7 Decem­ber 2023. The let­ter was later stam­ped by the SBV on 11 Decem­ber with the note „Ack­now­led­ged“. The city issued the noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on as ear­ly as 13 Decem­ber, and it was ser­ved on the man on 14 Decem­ber. He brought legal pro­cee­dings within the pre­scri­bed time limit, chal­len­ging, among­st other things, the impro­per invol­vement of the SBV.

The path through the courts

The Employ­ment Tri­bu­nal ruled in favour of the clai­mant. The Regio­nal Labour Court took a dif­fe­rent view and dis­missed the cla­im. The appeal to the Fede­ral Labour Court was ulti­m­ate­ly suc­cessful. The court rein­sta­ted the judgment of the court of first instance.

Why the notice of termination was invalid

Under Sec­tion 178(2) of SGB IX, a noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on is inva­lid if the works coun­cil has not been duly con­sul­ted. Howe­ver, the Act does not spe­ci­fy a time limit for sub­mit­ting comm­ents. Case law has long fil­led this gap by app­ly­ing Sec­tion 102(2) of the Works Con­sti­tu­ti­on Act. In the case of ordi­na­ry dis­mis­sals, the SBV the­r­e­fo­re has one week in which to sub­mit its comments.

In this case, the let­ter was post­mark­ed 11 Decem­ber, so the dead­line ran until the end of 18 Decem­ber at the ear­liest. Even if one assu­mes that the SBV recei­ved the let­ter as ear­ly as 7 Decem­ber, the week would not have expi­red until mid­night on 14 Decem­ber. Howe­ver, the noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on was alre­a­dy deli­ver­ed to the man on that day, and was the­r­e­fo­re ser­ved too early.

What the note „Acknowledged“ means – and what it does not mean

The city argued that the SBV had made its final state­ment by affi­xing the stamp. The court did not agree with this. The stamp was neither an expli­cit con­sent nor a wai­ver of the right to com­ment. For the pro­cee­dings to be dee­med con­cluded pre­ma­tu­re­ly, the­re must be clear indi­ca­ti­ons that the SBV no lon­ger wis­hes to com­ment. The­re were no such indi­ca­ti­ons. The employ­er should have enqui­red whe­ther the SBV wis­hed to make a fur­ther state­ment. It had fai­led to do so.

What this means in practice

  • The SBV’s invol­vement appli­es to all cases of dis­mis­sal of peo­p­le with seve­re disa­bi­li­ties, inclu­ding during the pro­ba­tio­na­ry peri­od and the wai­ting peri­od under the Pro­tec­tion Against Dis­mis­sal Act.
  • The one-week peri­od beg­ins when the SBV recei­ves the noti­ce. If noti­ce is given ear­lier, the ter­mi­na­ti­on may be invalid.
  • A receipt stamp or a note such as „Ack­now­led­ged“ does not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly con­sti­tu­te a final response.
  • If the­re is any uncer­tain­ty, it may be neces­sa­ry to con­sult the SBV befo­re giving notice.
  • Employees should rai­se the issue of incor­rect share­hol­ding at an ear­ly stage. In this case, this had alre­a­dy been done in the state­ment of claim.

Whe­ther a noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on is for­mal­ly valid in a par­ti­cu­lar case depends on the exact cir­cum­s­tances. Employ­ers and employees should the­r­e­fo­re seek legal advice.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this