Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Formal defects in notice of termination: the two-week notice period and consultation with the staff council are decisive

Formal defects in notice of termination: the two-week notice period and consultation with the staff council are decisive

Anyo­ne giving noti­ce must not only have valid grounds for doing so; the for­mal requi­re­ments must also be met. This is demons­tra­ted by a recent ruling by the Ber­lin Labour Court, which declared two noti­ces of ter­mi­na­ti­on issued by the same employ­er to be inva­lid becau­se dif­fe­rent pro­ce­du­ral rules had been brea­ched in each case.

The background: a conflict of interest involving a portfolio manager

The Pen­si­on Fund of the Ber­lin Den­tal Asso­cia­ti­on (VZB) has been the sub­ject of a public prosecutor’s inves­ti­ga­ti­on for some time. Mem­bers of various com­mit­tees and staff are alle­ged to have car­ri­ed out ris­ky invest­ment tran­sac­tions for their own bene­fit. In this con­text, the VZB also dis­missed a head of depart­ment who had been employ­ed as a port­fo­lio mana­ger sin­ce 2017 and who­se respon­si­bi­li­ties included pre­pa­ring invest­ment decis­i­ons for the Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Committee.

The employ­er had noti­ced that the head of depart­ment had, through her own com­pa­ny, acqui­red shares in a trust com­pa­ny that was clo­se­ly inte­gra­ted into the VZB’s invest­ment struc­tu­re. The VZB regard­ed this as a breach of the duty of loyal­ty under the employ­ment con­tract and a con­flict of inte­rest. Con­se­quent­ly, it initi­al­ly issued a noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on with imme­dia­te effect, or alter­na­tively with noti­ce, in Sep­tem­ber 2025, fol­lo­wed by a fur­ther noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on in Novem­ber 2025.

The decision: Both notices of termination were formally flawed

The Ber­lin Labour Court declared all the dis­mis­sals to be inva­lid, though not on the grounds that the­re were no sub­stan­ti­ve reasons for them, but becau­se of pro­ce­du­ral errors.

  • Ter­mi­na­ti­on wit­hout noti­ce:In the case of extra­or­di­na­ry ter­mi­na­ti­on for good cau­se, the employ­er must act within two weeks of beco­ming awa­re of the rele­vant cir­cum­s­tances. The VZB had fai­led to com­ply with this so-cal­led two-week peri­od, as set out in Sec­tion 626(2) of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB). The noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on was ser­ved too late.
  • Ter­mi­na­ti­on with noti­ce:In this case, the VZB’s appli­ca­ti­on fai­led becau­se the staff coun­cil had not been invol­ved cor­rect­ly. Alt­hough the employ­er had sent the con­sul­ta­ti­on let­ter, it had not wai­ted for the staff council’s pre­scri­bed two-week peri­od for sub­mit­ting comm­ents to expi­re. The noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on was ser­ved befo­re this peri­od had even expired.
  • Fur­ther ter­mi­na­ti­on:In the case of the third dis­mis­sal, the court had alre­a­dy found that the head of depart­ment had not brea­ched any duty.

Continued employment cannot be enforced, however

Alt­hough the court con­siders the dis­mis­sals to be inva­lid, the VZB is not obli­ged to con­ti­nue employ­ing the staff mem­ber on a pro­vi­sio­nal basis. The court rejec­ted the rele­vant appli­ca­ti­on by the head of depart­ment. Given the serious­ness of the alle­ged brea­ches of duty, it would sim­ply be unre­asonable to expect the employ­er to con­ti­nue employ­ing her until the end of the legal proceedings.

The jud­ge­ment is not yet final. Both par­ties may lodge an appeal with the Ber­lin-Bran­den­burg Regio­nal Labour Court.

What does this mean for employers?

This case makes it clear that even valid grounds for dis­mis­sal can come to not­hing if dead­lines are not met or staff repre­sen­ta­ti­ves are not pro­per­ly invol­ved. For com­pa­nies wit­hout a staff coun­cil, the same appli­es to the works coun­cil con­sul­ta­ti­on under Sec­tion 102 of the Works Con­sti­tu­ti­on Act. Anyo­ne plan­ning to dis­miss an employee should careful­ly review the pro­ce­du­re befo­re the noti­ce of dis­mis­sal is han­ded over. If in doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice at an ear­ly stage.

Ber­lin Labour Court, jud­ge­ment of 26 June 2026, Case No. 22 Ca 13829/25

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this