Anyone giving notice must not only have valid grounds for doing so; the formal requirements must also be met. This is demonstrated by a recent ruling by the Berlin Labour Court, which declared two notices of termination issued by the same employer to be invalid because different procedural rules had been breached in each case.
The background: a conflict of interest involving a portfolio manager
The Pension Fund of the Berlin Dental Association (VZB) has been the subject of a public prosecutor’s investigation for some time. Members of various committees and staff are alleged to have carried out risky investment transactions for their own benefit. In this context, the VZB also dismissed a head of department who had been employed as a portfolio manager since 2017 and whose responsibilities included preparing investment decisions for the Administrative Committee.
The employer had noticed that the head of department had, through her own company, acquired shares in a trust company that was closely integrated into the VZB’s investment structure. The VZB regarded this as a breach of the duty of loyalty under the employment contract and a conflict of interest. Consequently, it initially issued a notice of termination with immediate effect, or alternatively with notice, in September 2025, followed by a further notice of termination in November 2025.
The decision: Both notices of termination were formally flawed
The Berlin Labour Court declared all the dismissals to be invalid, though not on the grounds that there were no substantive reasons for them, but because of procedural errors.
- Termination without notice:In the case of extraordinary termination for good cause, the employer must act within two weeks of becoming aware of the relevant circumstances. The VZB had failed to comply with this so-called two-week period, as set out in Section 626(2) of the German Civil Code (BGB). The notice of termination was served too late.
- Termination with notice:In this case, the VZB’s application failed because the staff council had not been involved correctly. Although the employer had sent the consultation letter, it had not waited for the staff council’s prescribed two-week period for submitting comments to expire. The notice of termination was served before this period had even expired.
- Further termination:In the case of the third dismissal, the court had already found that the head of department had not breached any duty.
Continued employment cannot be enforced, however
Although the court considers the dismissals to be invalid, the VZB is not obliged to continue employing the staff member on a provisional basis. The court rejected the relevant application by the head of department. Given the seriousness of the alleged breaches of duty, it would simply be unreasonable to expect the employer to continue employing her until the end of the legal proceedings.
The judgement is not yet final. Both parties may lodge an appeal with the Berlin-Brandenburg Regional Labour Court.
What does this mean for employers?
This case makes it clear that even valid grounds for dismissal can come to nothing if deadlines are not met or staff representatives are not properly involved. For companies without a staff council, the same applies to the works council consultation under Section 102 of the Works Constitution Act. Anyone planning to dismiss an employee should carefully review the procedure before the notice of dismissal is handed over. If in doubt, it is advisable to seek legal advice at an early stage.
Berlin Labour Court, judgement of 26 June 2026, Case No. 22 Ca 13829/25
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.