A shareholder in a GmbH & Co. KG who gifts their limited partnership interest does not automatically trigger an input tax deduction for the resulting tax consultancy costs. This was ruled by the Baden-Württemberg Finance Court in its judgement of 11 March 2026 (Ref. 14 K 1829/23). The judgement is not yet final, as an appeal is pending before the Federal Finance Court under file number V R 13/26.
What had happened?
In 2015, a limited partner in a GmbH & Co. KG transferred shares to two individuals by way of a gift. The tax office subsequently required the company to submit a so-called ‘declaration of assessment’ under the Valuation Act for the purposes of gift tax. To this end, the value of the company had to be determined. The GmbH & Co. KG commissioned a tax consultancy firm to carry out this valuation and draw up the declaration. The invoice amounted to approximately 12,000 euros net, from which the company claimed input tax of approximately 2,284 euros.
The tax office refused to allow the input tax deduction. The legal action brought against this decision was unsuccessful.
Why is there no input tax deduction?
Under the Value Added Tax Act, in order to claim an input tax deduction, there must, as a general rule, be a direct and immediate link between the services purchased and the company’s taxable output transactions. If this link is lacking, the right to deduct is forfeited.
The court made it clear that the gift of company shares is a private matter between the donor and the recipient. It has no effect whatsoever on the company’s turnover. One could simply disregard the gift without anything changing in respect of the supplies or other services provided by the GmbH & Co. KG. In the court’s view, the mere fact that the law obliges the company to submit the declaration of assessment does not constitute a business-related justification for the consultancy costs.
Distinction from other consultancy costs
The company had argued that the situation was comparable to payroll accounting costs, which regularly give rise to a right to deduct input VAT. The court rejected this comparison. Payroll costs are directly incorporated into the calculation of the business’s services and are therefore directly linked to output turnover. This is simply not the case with a gift of shares.
Nor was the court persuaded by the reference to the costs of determining profits, in respect of which the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) generally recognises the right to deduct input VAT for partnerships. Whilst operating profit is a direct consequence of business activity, the value of the shares, whilst indirectly dependent on this activity, remains primarily the result of a non-business decision to transfer the shares.
What does this mean in practice?
Shareholders in a GmbH & Co. KG who wish to transfer shares free of charge should be aware that, whilst the associated valuation and consultancy costs may reduce taxable profit, this judgement rules out any input VAT deduction for VAT purposes. As the proceedings before the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) are still ongoing, it remains to be seen whether the legal position on this point will change.
Anyone finding themselves in a similar situation should keep an eye on developments in the appeal proceedings and seek tax advice on the specific case.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.