Anyone who holds a stake in a GmbH as a silent sub-shareholder is familiar with a practical problem: how is the income treated for tax purposes, and which tax office is responsible? In its judgement of 19 May 2026 (Ref. VIII R 33/24), the Federal Fiscal Court clarified that no separate and uniform assessment of the tax bases may be carried out for a so-called sub-participation company.
What is a sub-participation?
A ‘sub-shareholding’ arises when a person holds a share in a GmbH (the so-called ‘principal shareholder’) and another person has an economic interest in that share without being entered in the Commercial Register themselves. A distinction is made between the typical under-representation, in which the sub-participant merely shares in the profits, and the atypical under-participation, in which he also holds a stake in the hidden reserves and is therefore a co-owner in economic terms.
What was the case about?
The claimant and another party jointly planned the distribution of a software programme. To this end, the other party acquired a share in a GmbH. A sub-participation agreement was concluded with the claimant’s son. The son is said to have acted as a trustee on behalf of his father. The GmbH distributed profits and withheld capital gains tax. The claimant received part of the distributions via the sub-shareholding arrangement, but wished to have the capital gains tax withheld by the GmbH credited against his own income tax.
To achieve this, he submitted declarations of assessment on behalf of a subsidiary. The tax office refused to issue the corresponding assessment notices. An appeal, legal proceedings and, finally, an appeal to the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) were all unsuccessful.
The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) confirmed that no separate and uniform assessment is carried out in respect of a sub-participating company pursuant to Section 180(1), first sentence, No. 2(a) of the German Fiscal Code. This procedure requires that several persons joint incomefrom the same source of income.
- Typical under-participation:The principal shareholder derives investment income from their stake in the GmbH (Section 20(1)(1) of the Income Tax Act (EStG)), whilst the typical minority shareholder, by contrast, derives investment income from a silent partnership (Section 20(1)(4) of the German Income Tax Act (EStG)). These are therefore different sources of income with no common denominator.
- Atypical under-representation:In this case, although the sub-shareholder is an economic co-owner of the GmbH shareholding and himself derives income within the meaning of Section 20(1)(1) of the Income Tax Act (EStG), there is nevertheless no legal basis for a multi-stage assessment procedure.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) also rejected the idea of applying the statutory provisions in this way on the basis of general considerations of practicality. Without an explicit legal basis, such a procedural step may not be introduced, even if it might appear practical in individual cases.
What does that mean in practice?
Anyone with a stake in a sub-participation must declare their income directly in their own income tax return. It is not possible to report this income centrally at the level of the sub-participation company. This also applies to the crediting of withholding tax on capital gains, which can lead to considerable difficulties in such arrangements.
For shareholders, investors or family members who hold silent partnerships in GmbH shares, the ruling sends a clear message: tax planning should be carefully reviewed in advance. Individual tax advice is recommended in all cases.
Source: BFH press releases
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.