Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

BFH: No separate assessment in the case of partial ownership of a GmbH share

BFH: The­re is no sepa­ra­te, stan­dar­di­sed method for deter­mi­ning the tax bases for sub-hol­dings in GmbH shares. 
BFH: No separate assessment in the case of partial ownership of a GmbH share

BFH: No separate assessment in the case of partial ownership of a GmbH share

Anyo­ne who holds a sta­ke in a GmbH as a silent sub-share­hol­der is fami­li­ar with a prac­ti­cal pro­blem: how is the inco­me trea­ted for tax pur­po­ses, and which tax office is respon­si­ble? In its jud­ge­ment of 19 May 2026 (Ref. VIII R 33/24), the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court cla­ri­fied that no sepa­ra­te and uni­form assess­ment of the tax bases may be car­ri­ed out for a so-cal­led sub-par­ti­ci­pa­ti­on company.

What is a sub-participation?

A ‘sub-share­hol­ding’ ari­ses when a per­son holds a share in a GmbH (the so-cal­led ‘prin­ci­pal share­hol­der’) and ano­ther per­son has an eco­no­mic inte­rest in that share wit­hout being ente­red in the Com­mer­cial Regis­ter them­sel­ves. A distinc­tion is made bet­ween the typi­cal under-repre­sen­ta­ti­on, in which the sub-par­ti­ci­pant mere­ly shares in the pro­fits, and the aty­pi­cal under-par­ti­ci­pa­ti­on, in which he also holds a sta­ke in the hid­den reser­ves and is the­r­e­fo­re a co-owner in eco­no­mic terms.

What was the case about?

The clai­mant and ano­ther par­ty joint­ly plan­ned the dis­tri­bu­ti­on of a soft­ware pro­gram­me. To this end, the other par­ty acqui­red a share in a GmbH. A sub-par­ti­ci­pa­ti­on agree­ment was con­cluded with the claimant’s son. The son is said to have acted as a trus­tee on behalf of his father. The GmbH dis­tri­bu­ted pro­fits and with­held capi­tal gains tax. The clai­mant recei­ved part of the dis­tri­bu­ti­ons via the sub-share­hol­ding arran­ge­ment, but wis­hed to have the capi­tal gains tax with­held by the GmbH cre­di­ted against his own inco­me tax.

To achie­ve this, he sub­mit­ted decla­ra­ti­ons of assess­ment on behalf of a sub­si­dia­ry. The tax office refu­sed to issue the cor­re­spon­ding assess­ment noti­ces. An appeal, legal pro­cee­dings and, final­ly, an appeal to the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) were all unsuccessful.

The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) con­firm­ed that no sepa­ra­te and uni­form assess­ment is car­ri­ed out in respect of a sub-par­ti­ci­pa­ting com­pa­ny pur­su­ant to Sec­tion 180(1), first sen­tence, No. 2(a) of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code. This pro­ce­du­re requi­res that seve­ral per­sons joint inco­mefrom the same source of income.

  • Typi­cal under-par­ti­ci­pa­ti­on:The prin­ci­pal share­hol­der deri­ves invest­ment inco­me from their sta­ke in the GmbH (Sec­tion 20(1)(1) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)), whilst the typi­cal mino­ri­ty share­hol­der, by con­trast, deri­ves invest­ment inco­me from a silent part­ner­ship (Sec­tion 20(1)(4) of the Ger­man Inco­me Tax Act (EStG)). The­se are the­r­e­fo­re dif­fe­rent sources of inco­me with no com­mon denominator.
  • Aty­pi­cal under-repre­sen­ta­ti­on:In this case, alt­hough the sub-share­hol­der is an eco­no­mic co-owner of the GmbH share­hol­ding and hims­elf deri­ves inco­me within the mea­ning of Sec­tion 20(1)(1) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG), the­re is nevert­hel­ess no legal basis for a mul­ti-stage assess­ment procedure.

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) also rejec­ted the idea of app­ly­ing the sta­tu­to­ry pro­vi­si­ons in this way on the basis of gene­ral con­side­ra­ti­ons of prac­ti­cal­i­ty. Wit­hout an expli­cit legal basis, such a pro­ce­du­ral step may not be intro­du­ced, even if it might appear prac­ti­cal in indi­vi­du­al cases.

What does that mean in practice?

Anyo­ne with a sta­ke in a sub-par­ti­ci­pa­ti­on must decla­re their inco­me direct­ly in their own inco­me tax return. It is not pos­si­ble to report this inco­me cen­tral­ly at the level of the sub-par­ti­ci­pa­ti­on com­pa­ny. This also appli­es to the cre­diting of with­hol­ding tax on capi­tal gains, which can lead to con­sidera­ble dif­fi­cul­ties in such arrangements.

For share­hol­ders, inves­tors or fami­ly mem­bers who hold silent part­ner­ships in GmbH shares, the ruling sends a clear mes­sa­ge: tax plan­ning should be careful­ly review­ed in advan­ce. Indi­vi­du­al tax advice is recom­men­ded in all cases.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this