Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

AGG-Hopper loses its case in court: no compensation for an abusive job application

AGG-Hopper loses its case in court: no compensation for an abusive job application

A man who had appli­ed for a job and, after his appli­ca­ti­on was rejec­ted, clai­med 75,000 euros in com­pen­sa­ti­on on the grounds of dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on, has fai­led in his case befo­re the Düs­sel­dorf Labour Court. The court ruled that his cla­im con­sti­tu­ted an abu­se of the law and dis­missed it in its enti­re­ty. The jud­ge­ment of 7 May 2026 bears the case num­ber 2 Ca 6536/25.

What had happened?

The 50-year-old clai­mant, who has a 90 per cent degree of disa­bi­li­ty and descri­bed hims­elf as a doc­tor of law, appli­ed for a job via an online plat­form in August 2025. He enc­lo­sed a 17-page docu­ment with his appli­ca­ti­on, in which his sta­tus as a per­son with a seve­re disa­bi­li­ty was con­cea­led rather than open­ly dis­c­lo­sed. On the very same day, he recei­ved a rejec­tion via a recruit­ment agen­cy. His respon­se was swift: he imme­dia­te­ly cited num­e­rous obli­ga­ti­ons regar­ding pro­tec­tion and sup­port under Book IX of the Social Code and deman­ded a sub­stan­ti­al amount in compensation.

Why did the court dismiss the claim?

The Düs­sel­dorf Labour Court was con­vin­ced that the appli­cant had never real­ly been inte­res­ted in the adver­ti­sed post. Ins­tead, it found that he had deli­bera­te­ly used the appli­ca­ti­on in order to sub­se­quent­ly assert a cla­im for com­pen­sa­ti­on under the Gene­ral Equal Tre­at­ment Act (AGG). The AGG pro­tects employees from dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on on grounds such as disa­bi­li­ty, but does not con­fer a right to com­pen­sa­ti­on if the appli­ca­ti­on its­elf was not made in good faith.

Seve­ral fac­tors sup­port­ed this assessment:

  • Num­e­rous simi­lar cases had alre­a­dy been brought against the clai­mant by other poten­ti­al employers.
  • He respon­ded to the rejec­tion remar­kab­ly quick­ly with legal­ly com­plex letters.
  • He had taken screen­shots of the appli­ca­ti­on pro­cess, which sug­gests that he had plan­ned his approach.
  • He did not pre­sent his disa­bi­li­ty card open­ly, but con­cea­led the rele­vant infor­ma­ti­on within a leng­thy document.
  • The Hamm Labour Court had alre­a­dy ruled against the same appli­cant in a simi­lar case (jud­ge­ment of 23 Janu­ary 2026, ref. 2 Ca 628/25).

A significant step towards establishing circumstantial evidence

It is par­ti­cu­lar­ly note­wor­t­hy how the court dealt with the pre­vious case law of the Fede­ral Labour Court (BAG). The BAG has so far held that a mere breach by the employ­er of the obli­ga­ti­on to report vacan­ci­es to the Employ­ment Agen­cy is suf­fi­ci­ent in its­elf to con­sti­tu­te an indi­ca­ti­on of dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on. The employ­er would then have to pro­ve that no dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on had taken place.

The Düs­sel­dorf Labour Court rejec­ted this auto­ma­tic pre­sump­ti­on. The obli­ga­ti­on to regis­ter job vacan­ci­es with the employ­ment agen­cy ser­ves a labour mar­ket poli­cy objec­ti­ve and is inten­ded to bring about a struc­tu­ral impro­ve­ment in the employ­ment pro­s­pects of peo­p­le with seve­re disa­bi­li­ties. Howe­ver, it is not a tool for impo­sing sanc­tions in indi­vi­du­al recruit­ment pro­ces­ses. In view of modern recruit­ment methods via Lin­ke­dIn, Xing or per­so­nal net­works, the old case law no lon­ger reflects cur­rent practice.

What does this mean for employers?

The ruling shows that courts are scru­ti­ni­s­ing claims for com­pen­sa­ti­on under the AGG more clo­se­ly whe­re they are mani­fest­ly fri­vo­lous. Employ­ers should nevert­hel­ess docu­ment their recruit­ment pro­ce­du­res careful­ly and com­ply with the legal requi­re­ments when deal­ing with appli­cants with seve­re disa­bi­li­ties. Whe­re in doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to seek advice on employ­ment law, as the legal situa­ti­on can be com­plex in indi­vi­du­al cases.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this