A man who had applied for a job and, after his application was rejected, claimed 75,000 euros in compensation on the grounds of discrimination, has failed in his case before the Düsseldorf Labour Court. The court ruled that his claim constituted an abuse of the law and dismissed it in its entirety. The judgement of 7 May 2026 bears the case number 2 Ca 6536/25.
What had happened?
The 50-year-old claimant, who has a 90 per cent degree of disability and described himself as a doctor of law, applied for a job via an online platform in August 2025. He enclosed a 17-page document with his application, in which his status as a person with a severe disability was concealed rather than openly disclosed. On the very same day, he received a rejection via a recruitment agency. His response was swift: he immediately cited numerous obligations regarding protection and support under Book IX of the Social Code and demanded a substantial amount in compensation.
Why did the court dismiss the claim?
The Düsseldorf Labour Court was convinced that the applicant had never really been interested in the advertised post. Instead, it found that he had deliberately used the application in order to subsequently assert a claim for compensation under the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG). The AGG protects employees from discrimination on grounds such as disability, but does not confer a right to compensation if the application itself was not made in good faith.
Several factors supported this assessment:
- Numerous similar cases had already been brought against the claimant by other potential employers.
- He responded to the rejection remarkably quickly with legally complex letters.
- He had taken screenshots of the application process, which suggests that he had planned his approach.
- He did not present his disability card openly, but concealed the relevant information within a lengthy document.
- The Hamm Labour Court had already ruled against the same applicant in a similar case (judgement of 23 January 2026, ref. 2 Ca 628/25).
A significant step towards establishing circumstantial evidence
It is particularly noteworthy how the court dealt with the previous case law of the Federal Labour Court (BAG). The BAG has so far held that a mere breach by the employer of the obligation to report vacancies to the Employment Agency is sufficient in itself to constitute an indication of discrimination. The employer would then have to prove that no discrimination had taken place.
The Düsseldorf Labour Court rejected this automatic presumption. The obligation to register job vacancies with the employment agency serves a labour market policy objective and is intended to bring about a structural improvement in the employment prospects of people with severe disabilities. However, it is not a tool for imposing sanctions in individual recruitment processes. In view of modern recruitment methods via LinkedIn, Xing or personal networks, the old case law no longer reflects current practice.
What does this mean for employers?
The ruling shows that courts are scrutinising claims for compensation under the AGG more closely where they are manifestly frivolous. Employers should nevertheless document their recruitment procedures carefully and comply with the legal requirements when dealing with applicants with severe disabilities. Where in doubt, it is advisable to seek advice on employment law, as the legal situation can be complex in individual cases.
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.