Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Property tax: Costs for market value valuations may be reimbursed

Property tax: Costs for market value valuations may be reimbursed

Anyo­ne who takes legal action against a pro­per­ty tax assess­ment noti­ce and is requi­red to sub­mit a mar­ket value valua­ti­on report may, under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, cla­im reim­bur­se­ment of the cos­ts incur­red from the tax office. The Baden-Würt­tem­berg Finan­ce Court ruled on this in a recent decis­i­on, ther­eby resol­ving a prac­ti­cal issue for pro­per­ty owners.

What was the case about?

A lan­dow­ner had brought legal pro­cee­dings against the pro­per­ty tax valua­ti­on noti­ce dated 1 Janu­ary 2022. The tax office had set the pro­per­ty tax value at around 602,000 euros. The clai­mant con­side­red this figu­re to be signi­fi­cant­ly too high and com­mis­sio­ned a mar­ket value report from the rele­vant valua­ti­on com­mit­tee. The report deter­mi­ned the actu­al value of the land to be just 355,000 euros.

Both the tax office and the court had express­ly reques­ted the clai­mant in wri­ting during the pro­cee­dings to sub­mit such an expert report. The tax office even­tual­ly relen­ted and amen­ded the noti­ce in line with the value deter­mi­ned in the expert report. The cos­ts of the pro­cee­dings were orde­red to be bor­ne by the tax office.

Dispute over the costs of expert reports

The clai­mant sub­se­quent­ly appli­ed for reim­bur­se­ment of all his expen­ses, inclu­ding the cost of the expert report, amoun­ting to appro­xi­m­ate­ly 1,514 euros. The tax office dis­agreed: it poin­ted out that the tax­pay­er was legal­ly obli­ged to pro­vi­de evi­dence of the lower value and could not the­r­e­fo­re pass on the cos­ts of pro­vi­ding such evi­dence to the authorities.

The Tax Court took a dif­fe­rent view. Under Sec­tion 139(1) of the Tax Court Rules (FGO), expen­ses are reco­vera­ble only if they were neces­sa­ry for the pro­per pur­su­it of legal pro­cee­dings. The cri­ter­ion here is the per­spec­ti­ve of a reasonable par­ty at the time the expen­dit­u­re was incurred.

Court rules that costs are recoverable

The Tax Court found that the cos­ts of the expert reports were inde­ed neces­sa­ry in this case. Three fac­tors were decisive:

  • The tax office had alre­a­dy reques­ted the clai­mant in wri­ting, both during the admi­nis­tra­ti­ve pro­cee­dings and again during the court pro­cee­dings, to sub­mit an expert report.
  • The court its­elf had issued a noti­ce to that effect.
  • The tax office sub­se­quent­ly included the value deter­mi­ned in the valua­ti­on report as the pro­per­ty tax value in the noti­ce of amend­ment, ther­eby accep­ting the con­tent of the valua­ti­on report.

In the­se cir­cum­s­tances, com­mis­sio­ning the expert report was not a vol­un­t­a­ry mea­su­re, but a de fac­to unavo­ida­ble respon­se to the requi­re­ments of the aut­ho­ri­ties and the court. The cos­ts of around 1,514 euros are the­r­e­fo­re recoverable.

What does this mean for property owners?

The new pro­per­ty tax reform has led to signi­fi­cant reva­lua­tions of land in many places. Many pro­per­ty owners con­sider the asses­sed pro­per­ty tax values to be too high. To suc­cessful­ly chall­enge the­se, tax offices and courts often requi­re a valua­ti­on report as evi­dence. The ruling from Baden-Würt­tem­berg makes it clear that anyo­ne who obta­ins such a report upon expli­cit request and is suc­cessful in their chall­enge does not have to bear the cos­ts themselves.

The court also points out that legis­la­ti­ve action is requi­red. The­re are as yet no stan­dar­di­sed and pro­por­tio­na­te fees for such expert reports, which results in tax­pay­ers facing vary­ing levels of finan­cial burden.

In indi­vi­du­al cases, it is advi­sa­ble to seek advice from a tax advi­ser or soli­ci­tor in order to assess the pro­s­pects of suc­cess of an appeal or legal action against a pro­per­ty tax assess­ment notice.

Baden-Würt­tem­berg Regio­nal Court, Order of 5 May 2026, Case No. 8 KO 351/26

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this