Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Late payment surcharge remains permissible even in the case of a tax refund

BFH: Anyo­ne who sub­mits their tax returns late must expect to pay a late-fil­ing surchar­ge, even if they are due a refund. 
Late payment surcharge remains permissible even in the case of a tax refund

Late payment surcharge remains permissible even in the case of a tax refund

Anyo­ne who sub­mits their tax return late must expect to pay a late fil­ing penal­ty. The fact that the out­co­me is a refund rather than an addi­tio­nal tax lia­bi­li­ty does not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly exempt them from this. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) has cla­ri­fied this in a recent ruling.

What had happened?

A busi­ness­wo­man had not sub­mit­ted an annu­al VAT return for 2018, even though she was obli­ged to do so. The tax office esti­ma­ted the taxa­ble amounts and set the VAT lia­bi­li­ty at 760 euros. At the same time, it impo­sed a late fil­ing penal­ty of 325 euros. The clai­mant lodged an appeal and sub­se­quent­ly sub­mit­ted her own return, in which she cal­cu­la­ted a refund entit­le­ment of 307 euros. The tax office did not initi­al­ly accept this calculation.

It was only during the ongo­ing pro­cee­dings befo­re the Tax Court that the woman sub­mit­ted fur­ther sup­port­ing docu­ments. The tax office sub­se­quent­ly amen­ded the VAT assess­ment and gran­ted the refund. Howe­ver, it express­ly upheld the late pay­ment surchar­ge. The Ber­lin-Bran­den­burg Tax Court quas­hed the surchar­ge on the grounds that it con­sti­tu­ted an error of dis­cre­ti­on. In the court’s view, the tax aut­ho­ri­ties should have taken into account that the woman had not gai­ned any finan­cial advan­ta­ge from the late submission.

The Federal Fiscal Court takes a different view

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) set asi­de the ruling of the Fis­cal Court and dis­missed the cla­im (jud­ge­ment of 7 May 2026, ref. V R 35/24). In the court’s view, the tax office is not obli­ged, when exer­cis­ing its dis­cre­ti­on, to take into account, in favour of the tax­pay­er, the fact that he did not deri­ve any bene­fit from the late fil­ing. Nor is it man­da­to­ry to take the taxpayer’s finan­cial cir­cum­s­tances into account when deci­ding whe­ther to impo­se a surchar­ge at all.

The legis­la­tor has deli­bera­te­ly set mini­mum amounts: 25 euros for each month or part the­reof that the pay­ment is late. The­se amounts are inten­ded to act as a deter­rent even in cases whe­re a refund is due. Anyo­ne who fails to sub­mit their tax return on time should face tan­gi­ble con­se­quen­ces, regard­less of whe­ther this ulti­m­ate­ly results in an addi­tio­nal pay­ment or a refund.

Important procedural information

In this jud­ge­ment, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) also cla­ri­fied a pro­ce­du­ral issue. If, during ongo­ing legal pro­cee­dings, the tax office issues a new noti­ce that replaces the pre­vious one, this new noti­ce auto­ma­ti­cal­ly beco­mes the sub­ject of the pro­cee­dings alre­a­dy pen­ding. This appli­es even if the legal basis of the noti­ce chan­ges in the pro­cess, as in this case with the shift from a bin­ding decis­i­on to a dis­cre­tio­na­ry decision.

What does this mean for taxpayers?

The ruling makes it clear that the time­ly sub­mis­si­on of tax returns should be taken serious­ly. Anyo­ne hoping that a late-fil­ing penal­ty will be wai­ved retro­s­pec­tively becau­se a refund is due can­not count on this hap­pe­ning. The tax office is entit­led to impo­se the surchar­ge wit­hout having to invo­ke the spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances of the indi­vi­du­al case. Only in excep­tio­nal cases, whe­re the mini­mum amount would lead to a dis­pro­por­tio­na­te out­co­me in the spe­ci­fic ins­tance, does the tax office retain a cer­tain degree of dis­cre­ti­on to refrain from impo­sing the surchar­ge altogether.

Tax­pay­ers facing a late pay­ment penal­ty should have the exact cir­cum­s­tances of their case review­ed. Whe­ther the tax office has exer­cis­ed its dis­cre­ti­on incor­rect­ly in a par­ti­cu­lar case can only be asses­sed on the basis of the spe­ci­fic case files.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this