Anyone who submits their tax return late must expect to pay a late filing penalty. The fact that the outcome is a refund rather than an additional tax liability does not automatically exempt them from this. The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has clarified this in a recent ruling.
What had happened?
A businesswoman had not submitted an annual VAT return for 2018, even though she was obliged to do so. The tax office estimated the taxable amounts and set the VAT liability at 760 euros. At the same time, it imposed a late filing penalty of 325 euros. The claimant lodged an appeal and subsequently submitted her own return, in which she calculated a refund entitlement of 307 euros. The tax office did not initially accept this calculation.
It was only during the ongoing proceedings before the Tax Court that the woman submitted further supporting documents. The tax office subsequently amended the VAT assessment and granted the refund. However, it expressly upheld the late payment surcharge. The Berlin-Brandenburg Tax Court quashed the surcharge on the grounds that it constituted an error of discretion. In the court’s view, the tax authorities should have taken into account that the woman had not gained any financial advantage from the late submission.
The Federal Fiscal Court takes a different view
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) set aside the ruling of the Fiscal Court and dismissed the claim (judgement of 7 May 2026, ref. V R 35/24). In the court’s view, the tax office is not obliged, when exercising its discretion, to take into account, in favour of the taxpayer, the fact that he did not derive any benefit from the late filing. Nor is it mandatory to take the taxpayer’s financial circumstances into account when deciding whether to impose a surcharge at all.
The legislator has deliberately set minimum amounts: 25 euros for each month or part thereof that the payment is late. These amounts are intended to act as a deterrent even in cases where a refund is due. Anyone who fails to submit their tax return on time should face tangible consequences, regardless of whether this ultimately results in an additional payment or a refund.
Important procedural information
In this judgement, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) also clarified a procedural issue. If, during ongoing legal proceedings, the tax office issues a new notice that replaces the previous one, this new notice automatically becomes the subject of the proceedings already pending. This applies even if the legal basis of the notice changes in the process, as in this case with the shift from a binding decision to a discretionary decision.
What does this mean for taxpayers?
The ruling makes it clear that the timely submission of tax returns should be taken seriously. Anyone hoping that a late-filing penalty will be waived retrospectively because a refund is due cannot count on this happening. The tax office is entitled to impose the surcharge without having to invoke the specific circumstances of the individual case. Only in exceptional cases, where the minimum amount would lead to a disproportionate outcome in the specific instance, does the tax office retain a certain degree of discretion to refrain from imposing the surcharge altogether.
Taxpayers facing a late payment penalty should have the exact circumstances of their case reviewed. Whether the tax office has exercised its discretion incorrectly in a particular case can only be assessed on the basis of the specific case files.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.