Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Letting to family members: Why the all-inclusive rent determines the tax benefit

BFH ruling: Anyo­ne let­ting pro­per­ty to rela­ti­ves at a redu­ced rate must check the 66 per cent limit on the basis of the rent inclu­si­ve of uti­li­ties, not the rent exclu­si­ve of utilities. 
Letting to family members: Why the all-inclusive rent determines the tax benefit

Letting to family members: Why the all-inclusive rent determines the tax benefit

Anyo­ne who lets a flat to a fami­ly mem­ber at a redu­ced rate often still wis­hes to bene­fit from tax reli­ef. The Inco­me Tax Act express­ly allows this, but makes the full deduc­tion for inco­me-rela­ted expen­ses sub­ject to one important con­di­ti­on: the agreed rent must be at least 66 per cent of the local mar­ket rent. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has pro­vi­ded a bin­ding cla­ri­fi­ca­ti­on as to what con­sti­tu­tes a bench­mark in this context.

Basic rent is not a sufficient benchmark

In prac­ti­ce, many land­lords have long used the basic rent as a bench­mark. Tax aut­ho­ri­ties, too, initi­al­ly reli­ed on this figu­re when asses­sing whe­ther the agreed rent excee­ded the 66 per cent thres­hold. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has cle­ar­ly rejec­ted this view in a land­mark ruling.

In the case in ques­ti­on (Fede­ral Fis­cal Court, jud­ge­ment of 10 May 2016, IX R 44/15), a mar­ried cou­ple let a flat to the claimant’s mother. The tax office based its assess­ment sole­ly on the basic rent and found that this amoun­ted to only around 62 per cent of the local mar­ket rate for basic rent. It con­se­quent­ly redu­ced the clai­med inco­me-rela­ted expen­ses on a pro rata basis. The land­lords con­tes­ted this, arguing that, when the ser­vice char­ges actual­ly paid were taken into account, the 66 per cent thres­hold was met. The Düs­sel­dorf Finan­ce Court dis­missed the cla­im. Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) ruled in favour of the landlords.

The local standard rent, inclusive of heating costs, is the statutory benchmark

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) cla­ri­fied that it is not the basic rent that is decisi­ve, but the local stan­dard rent inclu­si­ve of char­ges. This com­pri­ses the local stan­dard basic rent as set out in the rent index and the ancil­la­ry cos­ts that are appor­tionable under the Ope­ra­ting Cos­ts Ordi­nan­ce. Rely­ing sole­ly on the basic rent con­tra­ve­nes the law. The legal basis for this is Sec­tion 21(2) of the Inco­me Tax Act.

For land­lords, this means that tho­se who pass on the full cost of ser­vice char­ges to the ten­ant signi­fi­cant­ly impro­ve their nego­tia­ting posi­ti­on. The ser­vice char­ges actual­ly paid increase the agreed rent inclu­si­ve of ser­vice char­ges and, con­se­quent­ly, the rent-to-mar­ket ratio – that is, the ratio of the actu­al rent to the local com­pa­ra­ti­ve rent.

This is how the remuneration rate is calculated

  • Step 1:Deter­mi­ne the local stan­dard rent (exclu­ding ser­vice char­ges) using the rent index. Whe­re the rent index indi­ca­tes a ran­ge, the lowest figu­re may be used, which works in the landlord’s favour.
  • Step 2:Add up the appor­tionable ope­ra­ting cos­ts in accordance with the Ope­ra­ting Cos­ts Regu­la­ti­on. The result is the local stan­dard rent inclu­si­ve of heating.
  • Step 3:Compa­re the actu­al agreed total rent (basic rent plus the agreed share of ser­vice char­ges) with the local mar­ket rate for total rent.
  • Result:If the pro­por­ti­on is at least 66 per cent, the inco­me-rela­ted expen­ses are ful­ly deductible.

What happens if the figure falls below the 66 per cent threshold?

If the agreed rent is below the thres­hold, tax law divi­des the let­ting into a part for which rent is paid and a part for which no rent is paid. Inco­me-rela­ted expen­ses, such as inte­rest, depre­cia­ti­on or reno­va­ti­on cos­ts, are then only taken into account on a pro rata basis. Tax los­ses ari­sing from let­ting and lea­sing are signi­fi­cant­ly rest­ric­ted in this case.

What this means for landlords

Anyo­ne let­ting a flat to par­ents, child­ren or other clo­se rela­ti­ves at a redu­ced rate should careful­ly cal­cu­la­te the rent based on the local stan­dard rent inclu­ding hea­ting and other char­ges. A basic rent which, on its own, is just below the 66 per cent thres­hold can be brought back abo­ve this thres­hold by pas­sing on the full amount of ser­vice char­ges. In indi­vi­du­al cases, it is advi­sa­ble to seek tax advice to ensu­re that the basis for cal­cu­la­ti­on and the spe­ci­fic local rent index are cor­rect­ly taken into account.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this