Anyone who lets a flat to a family member at a reduced rate often still wishes to benefit from tax relief. The Income Tax Act expressly allows this, but makes the full deduction for income-related expenses subject to one important condition: the agreed rent must be at least 66 per cent of the local market rent. The Federal Fiscal Court has provided a binding clarification as to what constitutes a benchmark in this context.
Basic rent is not a sufficient benchmark
In practice, many landlords have long used the basic rent as a benchmark. Tax authorities, too, initially relied on this figure when assessing whether the agreed rent exceeded the 66 per cent threshold. The Federal Fiscal Court has clearly rejected this view in a landmark ruling.
In the case in question (Federal Fiscal Court, judgement of 10 May 2016, IX R 44/15), a married couple let a flat to the claimant’s mother. The tax office based its assessment solely on the basic rent and found that this amounted to only around 62 per cent of the local market rate for basic rent. It consequently reduced the claimed income-related expenses on a pro rata basis. The landlords contested this, arguing that, when the service charges actually paid were taken into account, the 66 per cent threshold was met. The Düsseldorf Finance Court dismissed the claim. However, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) ruled in favour of the landlords.
The local standard rent, inclusive of heating costs, is the statutory benchmark
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) clarified that it is not the basic rent that is decisive, but the local standard rent inclusive of charges. This comprises the local standard basic rent as set out in the rent index and the ancillary costs that are apportionable under the Operating Costs Ordinance. Relying solely on the basic rent contravenes the law. The legal basis for this is Section 21(2) of the Income Tax Act.
For landlords, this means that those who pass on the full cost of service charges to the tenant significantly improve their negotiating position. The service charges actually paid increase the agreed rent inclusive of service charges and, consequently, the rent-to-market ratio – that is, the ratio of the actual rent to the local comparative rent.
This is how the remuneration rate is calculated
- Step 1:Determine the local standard rent (excluding service charges) using the rent index. Where the rent index indicates a range, the lowest figure may be used, which works in the landlord’s favour.
- Step 2:Add up the apportionable operating costs in accordance with the Operating Costs Regulation. The result is the local standard rent inclusive of heating.
- Step 3:Compare the actual agreed total rent (basic rent plus the agreed share of service charges) with the local market rate for total rent.
- Result:If the proportion is at least 66 per cent, the income-related expenses are fully deductible.
What happens if the figure falls below the 66 per cent threshold?
If the agreed rent is below the threshold, tax law divides the letting into a part for which rent is paid and a part for which no rent is paid. Income-related expenses, such as interest, depreciation or renovation costs, are then only taken into account on a pro rata basis. Tax losses arising from letting and leasing are significantly restricted in this case.
What this means for landlords
Anyone letting a flat to parents, children or other close relatives at a reduced rate should carefully calculate the rent based on the local standard rent including heating and other charges. A basic rent which, on its own, is just below the 66 per cent threshold can be brought back above this threshold by passing on the full amount of service charges. In individual cases, it is advisable to seek tax advice to ensure that the basis for calculation and the specific local rent index are correctly taken into account.
Source: Haufe: Property
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.