Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Freedom of expression in employment law: what employees are and are not allowed to say

Freedom of expression in employment law: what employees are and are not allowed to say

A DHL employee publicly cri­ti­cis­ed his employ­er for trans­port­ing arms, naming the com­pa­ny Rhein­me­tall as a cli­ent. DHL dis­missed him wit­hout noti­ce, accu­sing him of divul­ging trade secrets. The Leip­zig Labour Court took a dif­fe­rent view and declared the dis­mis­sal inva­lid. The cli­ent rela­ti­onship had been known for some time, and the employee had not made any fal­se claims. The case illus­tra­tes how clo­se­ly free­dom of expres­si­on and employ­ment rela­ti­onships are lin­ked in practice.

A fundamental right with limits

Artic­le 5(1) of the Basic Law gua­ran­tees ever­yo­ne the right to free­dom of expres­si­on. This right appli­es not only in rela­ti­on to the sta­te, but also within the con­text of an employ­ment rela­ti­onship. The Fede­ral Labour Court express­ly con­firm­ed this in a jud­ge­ment of 24 Novem­ber 2005 (Case No. 2 AZR 584/04). At the same time, free­dom of expres­si­on is not a free pass for every kind of statement.

Fun­da­men­tal­ly excluded from the scope of pro­tec­tion are untrue fac­tu­al alle­ga­ti­ons, as well as insults, abu­si­ve cri­ti­cism and so-cal­led ‘for­mal insults’. Anyo­ne who dis­pa­ra­ges or defa­mes ano­ther per­son can­not invo­ke Artic­le 5 of the Basic Law, regard­less of whe­ther this occurs intern­al­ly towards a supe­ri­or or extern­al­ly on social media.

Internal criticism and public statements

Employees are entit­led to rai­se con­cerns about mal­prac­ti­ce within the work­place in an objec­ti­ve man­ner. Under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, it is even per­mis­si­ble to dis­c­lo­se inter­nal com­pa­ny mat­ters if this brings to light signi­fi­cant issues that are of public inte­rest. This is known as whist­le­b­lo­wing. Under the Whist­le­b­lower Pro­tec­tion Act, com­pa­nies with 50 or more employees are obli­ged to set up inter­nal report­ing chan­nels for this purpose.

Things beco­me more com­pli­ca­ted when it comes to public cri­ti­cism. Anyo­ne who, for exam­p­le, speaks ill of their employ­er on social media or spreads rumours about the employer’s sol­ven­cy risks con­se­quen­ces under employ­ment law, which may even include dis­mis­sal. Even if a social media plat­form for­mal­ly requi­res users to log in, such a state­ment is no lon­ger regard­ed as inter­nal to the com­pa­ny. The risk of rapid dis­se­mi­na­ti­on and loss of con­trol is par­ti­cu­lar­ly high in such cases.

Political comments in the workplace

The Basic Law also pro­tects the expres­si­on of poli­ti­cal views in the work­place. Employees are per­mit­ted to express their beliefs through words, sti­ckers or bad­ges. An employ­er can­not decla­re the work­place a ‘poli­tics-free zone’. Howe­ver, the­re are excep­ti­ons: if an employee has regu­lar cont­act with cus­to­mers, a poli­ti­cal state­ment may be attri­bu­ted to the employ­er. The employ­er is not obli­ged to accept being used as a mouth­pie­ce for such views.

Special rules for works councils and companies with a particular political orientation

Under Sec­tion 75(2), third sen­tence, of the Works Con­sti­tu­ti­on Act, works coun­cil mem­bers are pro­hi­bi­ted from enga­ging in par­ty poli­ti­cal acti­vi­ties. State­ments on gene­ral poli­ti­cal mat­ters are not cover­ed by this pro­hi­bi­ti­on; howe­ver, spe­ci­fic refe­ren­ces to poli­ti­cal par­ties are. In so-cal­led ‘ideo­lo­gi­cal­ly ori­en­ted orga­ni­sa­ti­ons’ – such as trade uni­ons, poli­ti­cal par­ties or reli­gious insti­tu­ti­ons – stric­ter requi­re­ments app­ly to employees. Anyo­ne working in such orga­ni­sa­ti­ons must also con­duct them­sel­ves out­side working hours in a man­ner that does not con­sis­t­ent­ly con­tra­dict the organisation’s ethos.

What does that mean in practice?

Whe­ther a state­ment made in the con­text of an employ­ment rela­ti­onship is per­mis­si­ble or will result in con­se­quen­ces always depends on the spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances of each indi­vi­du­al case. Key fac­tors include the con­tent of the state­ment, the loca­ti­on whe­re it was made, the employee’s posi­ti­on within the com­pa­ny and any poten­ti­al impact on indus­tri­al peace. Anyo­ne who has recei­ved a writ­ten war­ning or is facing the thre­at of dis­mis­sal should seek legal advice befo­re taking any action.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this