A DHL employee publicly criticised his employer for transporting arms, naming the company Rheinmetall as a client. DHL dismissed him without notice, accusing him of divulging trade secrets. The Leipzig Labour Court took a different view and declared the dismissal invalid. The client relationship had been known for some time, and the employee had not made any false claims. The case illustrates how closely freedom of expression and employment relationships are linked in practice.
A fundamental right with limits
Article 5(1) of the Basic Law guarantees everyone the right to freedom of expression. This right applies not only in relation to the state, but also within the context of an employment relationship. The Federal Labour Court expressly confirmed this in a judgement of 24 November 2005 (Case No. 2 AZR 584/04). At the same time, freedom of expression is not a free pass for every kind of statement.
Fundamentally excluded from the scope of protection are untrue factual allegations, as well as insults, abusive criticism and so-called ‘formal insults’. Anyone who disparages or defames another person cannot invoke Article 5 of the Basic Law, regardless of whether this occurs internally towards a superior or externally on social media.
Internal criticism and public statements
Employees are entitled to raise concerns about malpractice within the workplace in an objective manner. Under certain circumstances, it is even permissible to disclose internal company matters if this brings to light significant issues that are of public interest. This is known as whistleblowing. Under the Whistleblower Protection Act, companies with 50 or more employees are obliged to set up internal reporting channels for this purpose.
Things become more complicated when it comes to public criticism. Anyone who, for example, speaks ill of their employer on social media or spreads rumours about the employer’s solvency risks consequences under employment law, which may even include dismissal. Even if a social media platform formally requires users to log in, such a statement is no longer regarded as internal to the company. The risk of rapid dissemination and loss of control is particularly high in such cases.
Political comments in the workplace
The Basic Law also protects the expression of political views in the workplace. Employees are permitted to express their beliefs through words, stickers or badges. An employer cannot declare the workplace a ‘politics-free zone’. However, there are exceptions: if an employee has regular contact with customers, a political statement may be attributed to the employer. The employer is not obliged to accept being used as a mouthpiece for such views.
Special rules for works councils and companies with a particular political orientation
Under Section 75(2), third sentence, of the Works Constitution Act, works council members are prohibited from engaging in party political activities. Statements on general political matters are not covered by this prohibition; however, specific references to political parties are. In so-called ‘ideologically oriented organisations’ – such as trade unions, political parties or religious institutions – stricter requirements apply to employees. Anyone working in such organisations must also conduct themselves outside working hours in a manner that does not consistently contradict the organisation’s ethos.
What does that mean in practice?
Whether a statement made in the context of an employment relationship is permissible or will result in consequences always depends on the specific circumstances of each individual case. Key factors include the content of the statement, the location where it was made, the employee’s position within the company and any potential impact on industrial peace. Anyone who has received a written warning or is facing the threat of dismissal should seek legal advice before taking any action.
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.