Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Double taxation of a survivor’s benefit: Munich Fiscal Court finds no breach of the Constitution

Double taxation of a survivor’s benefit: Munich Fiscal Court finds no breach of the Constitution

Anyo­ne who, as an unmar­ried part­ner, recei­ves an insu­rance pay­out fol­lo­wing the death of their part­ner may, under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, face a sub­stan­ti­al tax bur­den. In a recent ruling, the Munich Finan­ce Court has deci­ded that even a com­bi­ned tax bur­den of around 60 per cent on such a survivor’s bene­fit is con­sti­tu­tio­nal­ly permissible.

What was the case about?

The clai­mant was the part­ner of a decea­sed man. He was insu­red through his employ­er, and the clai­mant had been named as the bene­fi­ci­a­ry in the event of his death. Fol­lo­wing his death, she recei­ved a survivor’s bene­fit amoun­ting to just over 213,000 euros.

The tax office trea­ted this pay­ment as taxa­ble on two counts: first­ly, the pay­ment was sub­ject to inco­me tax; second­ly, the tax office asses­sed inhe­ri­tance tax amoun­ting to 58,020 euros. As the clai­mant was clas­si­fied only in tax bra­cket III, she was entit­led to an allo­wan­ce of just 20,000 euros, and a tax rate of 30 per cent appli­ed. She was unable to cla­im a hig­her allo­wan­ce, such as that enjoy­ed by mar­ried couples.

In total, the com­bi­ned tax lia­bi­li­ty com­pri­sing inco­me tax and inhe­ri­tance tax amoun­ted to around 128,600 euros, which cor­re­sponds to appro­xi­m­ate­ly 60 per cent of the ori­gi­nal purcha­se pri­ce. The clai­mant lodged an objec­tion and sub­se­quent­ly brought legal pro­cee­dings on the grounds that this tax bur­den was exces­si­ve and con­tra­ve­ned the fun­da­men­tal right to pro­per­ty under Artic­le 14 of the Basic Law.

What was the court’s ruling?

The Munich Finan­ce Court dis­missed the cla­im. In the court’s view, the­re is no exces­si­ve taxa­ti­on, i.e. so-cal­led con­fis­ca­to­ry taxa­ti­on. No rigid upper limit on taxa­ti­on can be deri­ved from the Basic Law, nor can a gene­ral ‘half-and-half’ prin­ci­ple be infer­red, accor­ding to which the sta­te may not tax more than half of a person’s inco­me. This legal view is in line with the estab­lished case law of the Fede­ral Con­sti­tu­tio­nal Court and the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court.

In addi­ti­on, the court poin­ted out that the dou­ble taxa­ti­on ari­sing from inco­me tax and inhe­ri­tance tax had been miti­ga­ted, at least in part: under Sec­tion 35b of the Inco­me Tax Act, inco­me tax was redu­ced by 24,047 euros to take account of the inhe­ri­tance tax alre­a­dy paid.

The jud­ge­ment was han­ded down on 6 March 2026 under case num­ber 4 K 2179/25.

What does this mean for those affected?

This case high­lights a signi­fi­cant tax dif­fe­rence bet­ween mar­ried cou­ples and unmar­ried coha­bi­ting part­ners. Mar­ried cou­ples bene­fit from an inhe­ri­tance tax allo­wan­ce of 500,000 euros and a more favoura­ble tax bra­cket. Unmar­ried coha­bi­ting part­ners, on the other hand, are only entit­led to the gene­ral allo­wan­ce of 20,000 euros and are taxed in the least favoura­ble tax bra­cket, tax bra­cket III.

Anyo­ne wis­hing to pro­vi­de finan­cial secu­ri­ty for their part­ner should take the­se tax impli­ca­ti­ons into account when plan­ning. In this spe­ci­fic case, get­ting mar­ried would have signi­fi­cant­ly redu­ced the tax bur­den. The best way to deter­mi­ne whe­ther any tax plan­ning opti­ons are appro­pria­te for your own situa­ti­on, and if so which ones, is to seek per­so­na­li­sed tax or legal advice.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this