Anyone who, as an unmarried partner, receives an insurance payout following the death of their partner may, under certain circumstances, face a substantial tax burden. In a recent ruling, the Munich Finance Court has decided that even a combined tax burden of around 60 per cent on such a survivor’s benefit is constitutionally permissible.
What was the case about?
The claimant was the partner of a deceased man. He was insured through his employer, and the claimant had been named as the beneficiary in the event of his death. Following his death, she received a survivor’s benefit amounting to just over 213,000 euros.
The tax office treated this payment as taxable on two counts: firstly, the payment was subject to income tax; secondly, the tax office assessed inheritance tax amounting to 58,020 euros. As the claimant was classified only in tax bracket III, she was entitled to an allowance of just 20,000 euros, and a tax rate of 30 per cent applied. She was unable to claim a higher allowance, such as that enjoyed by married couples.
In total, the combined tax liability comprising income tax and inheritance tax amounted to around 128,600 euros, which corresponds to approximately 60 per cent of the original purchase price. The claimant lodged an objection and subsequently brought legal proceedings on the grounds that this tax burden was excessive and contravened the fundamental right to property under Article 14 of the Basic Law.
What was the court’s ruling?
The Munich Finance Court dismissed the claim. In the court’s view, there is no excessive taxation, i.e. so-called confiscatory taxation. No rigid upper limit on taxation can be derived from the Basic Law, nor can a general ‘half-and-half’ principle be inferred, according to which the state may not tax more than half of a person’s income. This legal view is in line with the established case law of the Federal Constitutional Court and the Federal Finance Court.
In addition, the court pointed out that the double taxation arising from income tax and inheritance tax had been mitigated, at least in part: under Section 35b of the Income Tax Act, income tax was reduced by 24,047 euros to take account of the inheritance tax already paid.
The judgement was handed down on 6 March 2026 under case number 4 K 2179/25.
What does this mean for those affected?
This case highlights a significant tax difference between married couples and unmarried cohabiting partners. Married couples benefit from an inheritance tax allowance of 500,000 euros and a more favourable tax bracket. Unmarried cohabiting partners, on the other hand, are only entitled to the general allowance of 20,000 euros and are taxed in the least favourable tax bracket, tax bracket III.
Anyone wishing to provide financial security for their partner should take these tax implications into account when planning. In this specific case, getting married would have significantly reduced the tax burden. The best way to determine whether any tax planning options are appropriate for your own situation, and if so which ones, is to seek personalised tax or legal advice.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.