Anyone who, as part of divorce proceedings, receives pension entitlements derived from their former spouse’s civil service pension must pay close attention to the tax implications. In its judgement of 24 June 2026, the Federal Fiscal Court ruled on a practical issue concerning tax allowances, thereby expressly confirming the tax authorities’ position (BFH, VI R 19/24).
What is the pension allowance?
Civil servants’ pensions and similar pension payments under civil service law are subject to income tax. To compensate for this, there is the so-called pension allowance under Section 19(2) of the Income Tax Act. This amount, plus a fixed supplement, remains tax-free. The key feature is that the amount depends on the year in which the pension payments began. The earlier the pension payments begin, the higher the allowance, as the scheme operates on a phased reduction model over the years.
The case behind the judgement
A woman was divorced from her husband, a civil servant, in 2001. Following a family court order in 2016, the husband’s ongoing civil service pension was retrospectively divided between them. This means that, from that point onwards, the woman acquired her own retroactive entitlement against the pension provider; actual payments did not commence until 2018, including back payments for the period from February 2016.
The man had been receiving his pension since 2007. The question now was: Which year counts towards the calculation of the pension allowance for the divorced woman? The year 2007, when her ex-husband’s pension began? Or the year 2016, when her own entitlement arose?
The Hessian Finance Court and the Federal Finance Court reached different conclusions
The Hesse Finance Court had ruled in favour of the claimant and based its decision on the year 2007. It argued that, as a result of the internal division, the woman was following in her ex-husband’s tax footsteps, in a similar way to survivors following the death of a pension recipient.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) took a different view. It quashed the judgement of the Hessian Fiscal Court and emphasised that the internal division gives rise to a fully independent claim on the part of the person entitled to a pension against the pension provider. She is not the universal successor to her ex-husband. Therefore, it is the date on which her own pension payments commence that is decisive, not that of her former spouse.
In this specific case, the year 2016 is relevant, as the family court order took effect retroactively from 1 February 2016. The fact that the payment was not made until 2018 does not alter this.
What does that mean in practice?
Anyone who becomes entitled to a civil service pension as a result of a pension rights equalisation should be aware that the date on which their pension payments commence is decisive in determining the level of tax allowances. The later this date is, the lower the pension allowance. This can have a significant impact on the tax burden in retirement.
Those affected, particularly in complex divorce cases involving pension entitlements under civil service law, should have their tax situation assessed on a case-by-case basis. In such cases, it is worth seeking tax advice in order to accurately assess the implications for their annual tax liability.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.