Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Pension allowance following an internal pension split: Federal Fiscal Court upholds tax office’s position

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) cla­ri­fies: In the case of inter­nal pen­si­on rights equa­li­sa­ti­on, the date on which one’s own pen­si­on pay­ments com­mence is used to deter­mi­ne the tax allowance. 
Pension allowance following an internal pension split: Federal Fiscal Court upholds tax office’s position

Pension allowance following an internal pension split: Federal Fiscal Court upholds tax office’s position

Anyo­ne who, as part of divorce pro­cee­dings, recei­ves pen­si­on entit­le­ments deri­ved from their for­mer spouse’s civil ser­vice pen­si­on must pay clo­se atten­ti­on to the tax impli­ca­ti­ons. In its jud­ge­ment of 24 June 2026, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court ruled on a prac­ti­cal issue con­cer­ning tax allo­wan­ces, ther­eby express­ly con­fir­ming the tax aut­ho­ri­ties’ posi­ti­on (BFH, VI R 19/24).

What is the pension allowance?

Civil ser­vants’ pen­si­ons and simi­lar pen­si­on pay­ments under civil ser­vice law are sub­ject to inco­me tax. To com­pen­sa­te for this, the­re is the so-cal­led pen­si­on allo­wan­ce under Sec­tion 19(2) of the Inco­me Tax Act. This amount, plus a fixed sup­ple­ment, remains tax-free. The key fea­ture is that the amount depends on the year in which the pen­si­on pay­ments began. The ear­lier the pen­si­on pay­ments begin, the hig­her the allo­wan­ce, as the sche­me ope­ra­tes on a pha­sed reduc­tion model over the years.

The case behind the judgement

A woman was divorced from her hus­band, a civil ser­vant, in 2001. Fol­lo­wing a fami­ly court order in 2016, the husband’s ongo­ing civil ser­vice pen­si­on was retro­s­pec­tively divi­ded bet­ween them. This means that, from that point onwards, the woman acqui­red her own retroac­ti­ve entit­le­ment against the pen­si­on pro­vi­der; actu­al pay­ments did not com­mence until 2018, inclu­ding back pay­ments for the peri­od from Febru­ary 2016.

The man had been recei­ving his pen­si­on sin­ce 2007. The ques­ti­on now was: Which year counts towards the cal­cu­la­ti­on of the pen­si­on allo­wan­ce for the divorced woman? The year 2007, when her ex-husband’s pen­si­on began? Or the year 2016, when her own entit­le­ment arose?

The Hessian Finance Court and the Federal Finance Court reached different conclusions

The Hes­se Finan­ce Court had ruled in favour of the clai­mant and based its decis­i­on on the year 2007. It argued that, as a result of the inter­nal divi­si­on, the woman was fol­lo­wing in her ex-husband’s tax foot­s­teps, in a simi­lar way to sur­vi­vors fol­lo­wing the death of a pen­si­on recipient.

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) took a dif­fe­rent view. It quas­hed the jud­ge­ment of the Hes­si­an Fis­cal Court and empha­sis­ed that the inter­nal divi­si­on gives rise to a ful­ly inde­pen­dent cla­im on the part of the per­son entit­led to a pen­si­on against the pen­si­on pro­vi­der. She is not the uni­ver­sal suc­ces­sor to her ex-hus­band. The­r­e­fo­re, it is the date on which her own pen­si­on pay­ments com­mence that is decisi­ve, not that of her for­mer spouse.

In this spe­ci­fic case, the year 2016 is rele­vant, as the fami­ly court order took effect retroac­tively from 1 Febru­ary 2016. The fact that the pay­ment was not made until 2018 does not alter this.

What does that mean in practice?

Anyo­ne who beco­mes entit­led to a civil ser­vice pen­si­on as a result of a pen­si­on rights equa­li­sa­ti­on should be awa­re that the date on which their pen­si­on pay­ments com­mence is decisi­ve in deter­mi­ning the level of tax allo­wan­ces. The later this date is, the lower the pen­si­on allo­wan­ce. This can have a signi­fi­cant impact on the tax bur­den in retirement.

Tho­se affec­ted, par­ti­cu­lar­ly in com­plex divorce cases invol­ving pen­si­on entit­le­ments under civil ser­vice law, should have their tax situa­ti­on asses­sed on a case-by-case basis. In such cases, it is worth see­king tax advice in order to accu­ra­te­ly assess the impli­ca­ti­ons for their annu­al tax liability.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this