Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Federal Court of Justice: Buyer must pay estate agent’s commission even if the seller withdraws from the contract

Federal Court of Justice: Buyer must pay estate agent’s commission even if the seller withdraws from the contract

A buy­er of a pro­per­ty who enters into an estate agent’s con­tract remains obli­ged to pay the com­mis­si­on, even if the other par­ty valid­ly resc­inds their own estate agent’s con­tract. This was cla­ri­fied by the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce in a jud­ge­ment of 16 July 2026 (BGH, I ZR 223/25).

What had happened?

In the spring of 2022, a estate agent was com­mis­sio­ned by a com­mu­ni­ty of heirs to sell a detached house sub­ject to a lea­se­hold. The agreed com­mis­si­on amoun­ted to 3.57 per cent of the purcha­se pri­ce. A pro­s­pec­ti­ve buy­er made enqui­ries via a pro­per­ty por­tal, and the estate agent sent them a pro­per­ty bro­chu­re cle­ar­ly sta­ting that a buyer’s com­mis­si­on of the same amount would app­ly. Fol­lo­wing a vie­w­ing, the pro­s­pec­ti­ve buy­er signed an agree­ment in which they under­took to pay the com­mis­si­on should the purcha­se go ahead. They ack­now­led­ged the atta­ched can­cel­la­ti­on policy.

In Sep­tem­ber 2022, the com­mu­ni­ty of heirs resc­in­ded their estate agent’s con­tract. As the estate agent had not pro­vi­ded the sel­lers with infor­ma­ti­on on their right of with­dra­wal when the con­tract was con­cluded, the rescis­si­on remain­ed legal­ly valid even months later. The estate agent recei­ved no com­mis­si­on from the sel­lers. When he sub­se­quent­ly reques­ted pay­ment from the buy­er, the lat­ter refu­sed. He invo­ked the so-cal­led ‘half-sha­ring prin­ci­ple’: if the sel­ler pays not­hing, then he too need pay nothing.

The principle of division by half and its limitations

The prin­ci­ple of equal divi­si­on under Sec­tion 656c of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB) sti­pu­la­tes that a dual agent acting on behalf of both the buy­er and the sel­ler at the same time may only char­ge a com­mis­si­on of equal amount from both par­ties. Fur­ther­mo­re, if the estate agent wai­ves the com­mis­si­on for one par­ty by means of an express agree­ment, the cla­im against the other par­ty is auto­ma­ti­cal­ly forfeited.

Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce ruled that this auto­ma­tic lap­se does not app­ly if a party’s com­mis­si­on is wai­ved as a result of a valid revo­ca­ti­on, i.e. through the customer’s sta­tu­to­ry right of with­dra­wal. This is fun­da­men­tal­ly dif­fe­rent from a deli­be­ra­te wai­ver by the estate agent.

Why the revocation does not trigger a domino effect in this case

The pur­po­se of Sec­tion 656c of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB) is to pre­vent cir­cum­ven­ti­on. The legis­la­tu­re sought to pre­vent a estate agent from deli­bera­te­ly agre­e­ing with one par­ty that their ser­vices would be pro­vi­ded free of char­ge, only to then coll­ect the full com­mis­si­on from the other par­ty. This pre­sup­po­ses deli­be­ra­te action on the part of the estate agent.

A with­dra­wal, on the other hand, is not declared by the estate agent, but by the cli­ent, on who­se own legal rights it is based. The estate agent did not cau­se this loss of legal rights; he mere­ly negli­gent­ly allo­wed it to hap­pen by fai­ling to pro­vi­de the with­dra­wal ins­truc­tions. The court made it clear that the legis­la­tu­re had pre­cis­e­ly such sce­na­ri­os in mind: an estate agent can some­ti­mes only enforce their com­mis­si­on against one par­ty, wit­hout this auto­ma­ti­cal­ly exo­ne­ra­ting the other party.

What does this mean for buyers and sellers?

Any buy­er who has signed an estate agent’s con­tract con­tai­ning a pro­per noti­ce of with­dra­wal is bound by their obli­ga­ti­on to pay com­mis­si­on. With­dra­wal by the sel­ler does not release them from this obli­ga­ti­on. Con­ver­se­ly, the jud­ge­ment shows that estate agents would be well advi­sed to pro­vi­de both par­ties to the con­tract with a cor­rect noti­ce of with­dra­wal. Errors in the noti­ce may per­ma­nent­ly jeo­par­di­se the com­mis­si­on cla­im on one side.

In this par­ti­cu­lar case, the buy­er was requi­red to pay the agreed com­mis­si­on. Anyo­ne who finds them­sel­ves in a simi­lar situa­ti­on or wis­hes to enter into an estate agent’s con­tract should careful­ly check the exact terms and con­di­ti­ons and seek legal advice if any­thing is unclear.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this