A buyer of a property who enters into an estate agent’s contract remains obliged to pay the commission, even if the other party validly rescinds their own estate agent’s contract. This was clarified by the Federal Court of Justice in a judgement of 16 July 2026 (BGH, I ZR 223/25).
What had happened?
In the spring of 2022, a estate agent was commissioned by a community of heirs to sell a detached house subject to a leasehold. The agreed commission amounted to 3.57 per cent of the purchase price. A prospective buyer made enquiries via a property portal, and the estate agent sent them a property brochure clearly stating that a buyer’s commission of the same amount would apply. Following a viewing, the prospective buyer signed an agreement in which they undertook to pay the commission should the purchase go ahead. They acknowledged the attached cancellation policy.
In September 2022, the community of heirs rescinded their estate agent’s contract. As the estate agent had not provided the sellers with information on their right of withdrawal when the contract was concluded, the rescission remained legally valid even months later. The estate agent received no commission from the sellers. When he subsequently requested payment from the buyer, the latter refused. He invoked the so-called ‘half-sharing principle’: if the seller pays nothing, then he too need pay nothing.
The principle of division by half and its limitations
The principle of equal division under Section 656c of the German Civil Code (BGB) stipulates that a dual agent acting on behalf of both the buyer and the seller at the same time may only charge a commission of equal amount from both parties. Furthermore, if the estate agent waives the commission for one party by means of an express agreement, the claim against the other party is automatically forfeited.
However, the Federal Court of Justice ruled that this automatic lapse does not apply if a party’s commission is waived as a result of a valid revocation, i.e. through the customer’s statutory right of withdrawal. This is fundamentally different from a deliberate waiver by the estate agent.
Why the revocation does not trigger a domino effect in this case
The purpose of Section 656c of the German Civil Code (BGB) is to prevent circumvention. The legislature sought to prevent a estate agent from deliberately agreeing with one party that their services would be provided free of charge, only to then collect the full commission from the other party. This presupposes deliberate action on the part of the estate agent.
A withdrawal, on the other hand, is not declared by the estate agent, but by the client, on whose own legal rights it is based. The estate agent did not cause this loss of legal rights; he merely negligently allowed it to happen by failing to provide the withdrawal instructions. The court made it clear that the legislature had precisely such scenarios in mind: an estate agent can sometimes only enforce their commission against one party, without this automatically exonerating the other party.
What does this mean for buyers and sellers?
Any buyer who has signed an estate agent’s contract containing a proper notice of withdrawal is bound by their obligation to pay commission. Withdrawal by the seller does not release them from this obligation. Conversely, the judgement shows that estate agents would be well advised to provide both parties to the contract with a correct notice of withdrawal. Errors in the notice may permanently jeopardise the commission claim on one side.
In this particular case, the buyer was required to pay the agreed commission. Anyone who finds themselves in a similar situation or wishes to enter into an estate agent’s contract should carefully check the exact terms and conditions and seek legal advice if anything is unclear.
Source: Haufe: Property
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.