Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Property viewings by the landlord: When is access permitted?

Property viewings by the landlord: When is access permitted?

The land­lord rings the door­bell and wants to view his flat. But it’s not quite that simp­le. Ten­ants have the right to con­trol access to the pre­mi­ses they are ren­ting, and this pro­tects them from unan­noun­ced or unju­s­ti­fied visits. The cir­cum­s­tances in which land­lords may nevert­hel­ess demand access, and what needs to be taken into account in such cases, are pri­ma­ri­ly gover­ned by case law.

No entry without a valid reason

The legal basis for a landlord’s right of inspec­tion is set out in Sec­tion 809 of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB). Accor­ding to this pro­vi­si­on, the land­lord may demand access if he has a spe­ci­fic cla­im rela­ting to the let pro­per­ty or wis­hes to ascer­tain whe­ther he is entit­led to such a cla­im. Fur­ther­mo­re, Artic­le 13 of the Basic Law pro­tects the invio­la­bi­li­ty of the home, which sets strict limits on con­trac­tu­al access clauses.

If the land­lord enters the flat wit­hout the ten­ants’ con­sent – for exam­p­le, whilst they are away, using a spa­re key – they are guil­ty of tre­s­pass under Sec­tion 123 of the Ger­man Cri­mi­nal Code (StGB). This offence is punis­ha­ble by a fine or up to one year’s imprisonment.

When a right of inspection applies

Valid reasons for vie­w­ing a flat include, among­st others:

  • Plan­ned sale of the flat, with vie­wings by pro­s­pec­ti­ve buyers
  • Upco­ming moder­ni­sa­ti­on or main­ten­an­ce work
  • Noti­fi­ca­ti­on of defects by the ten­ant and assess­ment of the damage
  • Reasonable sus­pi­ci­on of use in breach of contract
  • Rea­ding mea­su­re­ments from mea­su­ring equipment
  • Inspec­tion of cos­me­tic repairs fol­lo­wing a tenant’s departure
  • Cal­cu­la­ti­on for a rent increase

In a jud­ge­ment dated 26 April 2023 (BGH, VIII ZR 420/21), the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce con­firm­ed that the ten­ant has a secon­da­ry con­trac­tu­al obli­ga­ti­on to grant access whe­re the­re is a spe­ci­fic, objec­ti­ve reason for doing so. In doing so, a fair balan­ce must be struck bet­ween the con­flic­ting inte­rests of both parties.

Notification and deadlines

Land­lords must give reasonable noti­ce of a vie­w­ing. The­re is no sta­tu­to­ry mini­mum noti­ce peri­od. In prac­ti­ce, for appoint­ments that can be plan­ned in advan­ce, appro­xi­m­ate­ly two weeks’ noti­ce is con­side­red reasonable. The vie­w­ing should take place on a working day at a reasonable time of day; week­days up to 7 pm are gene­ral­ly accept­ed. Satur­days count as working days. Whe­re pos­si­ble, seve­ral vie­wings should be sche­du­led tog­e­ther to mini­mi­se the incon­ve­ni­ence to the tenant.

In the event of immi­nent dan­ger, such as a burst water pipe, the obli­ga­ti­on to give noti­ce does not apply.

No right to carry out routine inspections without cause

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) has express­ly ruled out a right to peri­odic inspec­tion wit­hout a spe­ci­fic reason. Alt­hough the Munich Local Court did per­mit an inspec­tion after more than five years in one spe­ci­fic case (Munich Local Court, jud­ge­ment of 8 Janu­ary 2016, 461 C 19626/15), this issue has not yet been con­clu­si­ve­ly deci­ded by the hig­hest court.

What tenants can do

Ten­ants are entit­led to refu­se a vie­w­ing if the land­lord turns up wit­hout noti­ce and wit­hout a valid reason, if the vie­w­ing is sche­du­led at an unre­asonable time, or if vie­wings take place with unre­asonable fre­quen­cy, such as seve­ral times a week. Whe­re the­re is a valid reason, howe­ver, ten­ants must coope­ra­te in arran­ging a vie­w­ing and must not per­ma­nent­ly refu­se access.

Dis­pu­tes over the right to view a pro­per­ty affect both land­lords and ten­ants. Anyo­ne who is unsu­re how to pro­ceed in spe­ci­fic situa­tions should seek legal advice.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this