Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

No inheritance tax allowance for the family home if it is not the genuine centre of one’s life

No inheritance tax allowance for the family home if it is not the genuine centre of one’s life

Anyo­ne who inhe­rits a house in which a parent used to live often hopes to qua­li­fy for the tax exemp­ti­on for what is known as the ‘fami­ly home’. Howe­ver, in a recent ruling, the Munich Finan­ce Court has made it clear that this exemp­ti­on is sub­ject to strict con­di­ti­ons. Neither a regis­tered pri­ma­ry resi­dence nor occa­sio­nal visits are suf­fi­ci­ent. The jud­ge­ment of 15 April 2026 (case num­ber 4 K 1457/25) con­cerns a case that is typi­cal of many inhe­ri­tance situa­tions in practice.

What had happened?

A ten­ured pro­fes­sor inhe­ri­ted her father’s detached house fol­lo­wing his death in June 2021. Howe­ver, she lived and work­ed in ano­ther town, whe­re she had owned her own flat sin­ce April 2021. Alt­hough her pri­ma­ry resi­dence was for­mal­ly regis­tered at the inhe­ri­ted house in her home town, she in fact spent very litt­le time there.

To make mat­ters worse, the father of his wife – that is, the claimant’s mother – had gran­ted her a life-long right of usu­fruct over the house in his will. A right of usu­fruct means that the mother was per­mit­ted to con­ti­nue using the house, even though her daugh­ter had legal­ly beco­me the owner.

The tax office refu­sed to grant the tax exemp­ti­on. The clai­mant brought an action against this decis­i­on. The tax court dis­missed the claim.

Why does the tax exemption not apply?

The inhe­ri­tance tax exemp­ti­on for child­ren who inhe­rit a fami­ly home is set out in Sec­tion 13(1)(4c) of the Inhe­ri­tance Tax Act. Among other things, it requi­res that the heir take imme­dia­te per­so­nal use of the pro­per­ty, i.e. move in within appro­xi­m­ate­ly six months of the ope­ning of the suc­ces­si­on and estab­lish their actu­al cent­re of life there.

The court found that neither the decea­sed father nor the daugh­ter could be shown to have had their cent­re of life in the house. A mere for­mal regis­tra­ti­on as a pri­ma­ry resi­dence is not suf­fi­ci­ent for this pur­po­se. The decisi­ve fac­tor is whe­re a per­son actual­ly has the cent­re of their life – whe­re they sleep, go about their dai­ly rou­ti­ne and main­tain social ties. In this case, that was cle­ar­ly in the other town.

Usufruct precludes personal use

The Tax Court cited a fur­ther, sepa­ra­te ground for refu­sing the tax exemp­ti­on. As the mother is per­mit­ted to con­ti­nue using the house by vir­tue of her right of usu­fruct, and the daugh­ter can effec­tively be excluded from using it, the heir is not dee­med to be using the pro­per­ty for her own pur­po­ses. The Inhe­ri­tance Tax Act express­ly excludes the exemp­ti­on whe­re the inhe­ri­ted pro­per­ty is encum­be­red by an obli­ga­ti­on to trans­fer it or a com­pa­ra­ble right that pre­vents per­so­nal use.

Who is responsible for proving that the requirements have been met?

The Tax Court also empha­sis­ed that the bur­den of pro­of lies with the heir. Anyo­ne clai­ming the tax exemp­ti­on must pro­ve that all the con­di­ti­ons have been met. In the pre­sent case, this pro­of was not pro­vi­ded, even fol­lo­wing an oral hea­ring at which evi­dence was taken.

What does this mean for heirs?

Anyo­ne who inhe­rits a paren­tal home and wis­hes to cla­im the tax exemp­ti­on should check at an ear­ly stage whe­ther the con­di­ti­ons are actual­ly met. The­se include actual­ly moving in within six months, giving up one’s pre­vious main place of resi­dence, and unrest­ric­ted per­so­nal use of the pro­per­ty wit­hout any con­flic­ting third-par­ty rights such as usu­fruct or right of resi­dence. Anyo­ne in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should seek tax advice in good time to avo­id unex­pec­ted addi­tio­nal tax payments.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this