Anyone who inherits a house in which a parent used to live often hopes to qualify for the tax exemption for what is known as the ‘family home’. However, in a recent ruling, the Munich Finance Court has made it clear that this exemption is subject to strict conditions. Neither a registered primary residence nor occasional visits are sufficient. The judgement of 15 April 2026 (case number 4 K 1457/25) concerns a case that is typical of many inheritance situations in practice.
What had happened?
A tenured professor inherited her father’s detached house following his death in June 2021. However, she lived and worked in another town, where she had owned her own flat since April 2021. Although her primary residence was formally registered at the inherited house in her home town, she in fact spent very little time there.
To make matters worse, the father of his wife – that is, the claimant’s mother – had granted her a life-long right of usufruct over the house in his will. A right of usufruct means that the mother was permitted to continue using the house, even though her daughter had legally become the owner.
The tax office refused to grant the tax exemption. The claimant brought an action against this decision. The tax court dismissed the claim.
Why does the tax exemption not apply?
The inheritance tax exemption for children who inherit a family home is set out in Section 13(1)(4c) of the Inheritance Tax Act. Among other things, it requires that the heir take immediate personal use of the property, i.e. move in within approximately six months of the opening of the succession and establish their actual centre of life there.
The court found that neither the deceased father nor the daughter could be shown to have had their centre of life in the house. A mere formal registration as a primary residence is not sufficient for this purpose. The decisive factor is where a person actually has the centre of their life – where they sleep, go about their daily routine and maintain social ties. In this case, that was clearly in the other town.
Usufruct precludes personal use
The Tax Court cited a further, separate ground for refusing the tax exemption. As the mother is permitted to continue using the house by virtue of her right of usufruct, and the daughter can effectively be excluded from using it, the heir is not deemed to be using the property for her own purposes. The Inheritance Tax Act expressly excludes the exemption where the inherited property is encumbered by an obligation to transfer it or a comparable right that prevents personal use.
Who is responsible for proving that the requirements have been met?
The Tax Court also emphasised that the burden of proof lies with the heir. Anyone claiming the tax exemption must prove that all the conditions have been met. In the present case, this proof was not provided, even following an oral hearing at which evidence was taken.
What does this mean for heirs?
Anyone who inherits a parental home and wishes to claim the tax exemption should check at an early stage whether the conditions are actually met. These include actually moving in within six months, giving up one’s previous main place of residence, and unrestricted personal use of the property without any conflicting third-party rights such as usufruct or right of residence. Anyone in a similar situation should seek tax advice in good time to avoid unexpected additional tax payments.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.