Anyone who terminates an employee’s contract or invites them to take part in a workplace integration programme must, in the event of a dispute, prove that the letter was actually received. This may sound trivial, but it has significant consequences in practice. A recent ruling by the Federal Labour Court illustrates just how delicate the choice of delivery method can be.
What had happened?
An employee had been in post since 2015 and had been on repeated long-term sick leave in previous years. The company invited him on several occasions to take part in the workplace integration management scheme (BEM), a process designed to help employers work with employees on sick leave to find ways for them to return to work. The employee accepted an invitation in August 2022. A subsequent invitation in October 2023 went unanswered. In December 2023, the employer finally terminated the employee’s contract on grounds of ill health.
The employee contested this and denied ever having received the BEM invitation dated October 2023. This raised a key question: Can the employer prove that the employee received it?
Scanned registered post with return receipt fails as evidence
The employer had sent the letter as a so-called ‘scan-and-post’ registered letter via Deutsche Post. With this method, the postman scans the parcel’s barcode at the letterbox, signs digitally on his device and only then posts the letter. The data is automatically transferred to the tracking system.
The Federal Labour Court did not regard this as sufficient prima facie evidence that the letter had actually been posted. The reasoning was that the scan merely proves that the postman was standing in front of the letterbox and operated the machine. Whether he actually posted the letter afterwards cannot be established with sufficient certainty. The postman could have been distracted in the meantime. The court explicitly drew a comparison with the older, non-digital procedure, in which only a proof of posting and tracking information were available, and which likewise did not constitute prima facie evidence.
The dismissal was therefore invalid. In the absence of a proven, or at least properly offered, BEM, the employer lacked an essential basis for demonstrating that the dismissal on grounds of ill health was proportionate. Nor was the company able to provide evidence that a BEM would have been futile in any case.
Federal Labour Court (BAG), judgement of 7 May 2026, Case No. 2 AZR 184/25; lower court: Hamburg Regional Labour Court (LAG), judgement of 14 July 2025, Case No. 4 SLa 26/24
What does this mean for employers?
Under Section 130(1), first sentence, of the German Civil Code (BGB), the burden of proof regarding the receipt of a letter lies with the sender. This applies to notices of termination as well as to invitations to participate in a return-to-work programme (BEM), written warnings and other important documents.
- A simple registered letter sent via the scanning service is not sufficient as proof.
- It is safer to hand it over in person with a receipt, or to have it delivered by a courier who provides written confirmation of delivery.
- Deutsche Post has since amended its delivery procedure: the postman must now provide additional digital confirmation after posting the item. It remains to be seen whether the Federal Labour Court will consider this sufficient in future.
In the case of redundancies due to illness, employers should also document that the BEM was not merely offered as a formality, but was actually implemented, or explain why, in exceptional circumstances, it was not required. Anyone who is unsure about this should seek legal advice at an early stage.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.