Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Termination invalid: a scanned copy of a registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt is not sufficient as evidence

Fede­ral Labour Court (BAG): A scan­ned regis­tered let­ter does not pro­ve that the let­ter actual­ly ended up in the let­ter­box. The noti­ce of ter­mi­na­ti­on is invalid. 
Termination invalid: a scanned copy of a registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt is not sufficient as evidence

Termination invalid: a scanned copy of a registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt is not sufficient as evidence

Anyo­ne who ter­mi­na­tes an employee’s con­tract or invi­tes them to take part in a work­place inte­gra­ti­on pro­gram­me must, in the event of a dis­pu­te, pro­ve that the let­ter was actual­ly recei­ved. This may sound tri­vi­al, but it has signi­fi­cant con­se­quen­ces in prac­ti­ce. A recent ruling by the Fede­ral Labour Court illus­tra­tes just how deli­ca­te the choice of deli­very method can be.

What had happened?

An employee had been in post sin­ce 2015 and had been on repea­ted long-term sick lea­ve in pre­vious years. The com­pa­ny invi­ted him on seve­ral occa­si­ons to take part in the work­place inte­gra­ti­on manage­ment sche­me (BEM), a pro­cess desi­gned to help employ­ers work with employees on sick lea­ve to find ways for them to return to work. The employee accept­ed an invi­ta­ti­on in August 2022. A sub­se­quent invi­ta­ti­on in Octo­ber 2023 went unans­we­red. In Decem­ber 2023, the employ­er final­ly ter­mi­na­ted the employee’s con­tract on grounds of ill health.

The employee con­tes­ted this and denied ever having recei­ved the BEM invi­ta­ti­on dated Octo­ber 2023. This rai­sed a key ques­ti­on: Can the employ­er pro­ve that the employee recei­ved it?

Scanned registered post with return receipt fails as evidence

The employ­er had sent the let­ter as a so-cal­led ‘scan-and-post’ regis­tered let­ter via Deut­sche Post. With this method, the post­man scans the parcel’s bar­code at the let­ter­box, signs digi­tal­ly on his device and only then posts the let­ter. The data is auto­ma­ti­cal­ly trans­fer­red to the track­ing system.

The Fede­ral Labour Court did not regard this as suf­fi­ci­ent pri­ma facie evi­dence that the let­ter had actual­ly been pos­ted. The reaso­ning was that the scan mere­ly pro­ves that the post­man was stan­ding in front of the let­ter­box and ope­ra­ted the machi­ne. Whe­ther he actual­ly pos­ted the let­ter after­wards can­not be estab­lished with suf­fi­ci­ent cer­tain­ty. The post­man could have been dis­trac­ted in the mean­ti­me. The court expli­cit­ly drew a com­pa­ri­son with the older, non-digi­tal pro­ce­du­re, in which only a pro­of of pos­ting and track­ing infor­ma­ti­on were available, and which like­wi­se did not con­sti­tu­te pri­ma facie evidence.

The dis­mis­sal was the­r­e­fo­re inva­lid. In the absence of a pro­ven, or at least pro­per­ly offe­red, BEM, the employ­er lacked an essen­ti­al basis for demons­t­ra­ting that the dis­mis­sal on grounds of ill health was pro­por­tio­na­te. Nor was the com­pa­ny able to pro­vi­de evi­dence that a BEM would have been futi­le in any case.

Fede­ral Labour Court (BAG), jud­ge­ment of 7 May 2026, Case No. 2 AZR 184/25; lower court: Ham­burg Regio­nal Labour Court (LAG), jud­ge­ment of 14 July 2025, Case No. 4 SLa 26/24

What does this mean for employers?

Under Sec­tion 130(1), first sen­tence, of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB), the bur­den of pro­of regar­ding the receipt of a let­ter lies with the sen­der. This appli­es to noti­ces of ter­mi­na­ti­on as well as to invi­ta­ti­ons to par­ti­ci­pa­te in a return-to-work pro­gram­me (BEM), writ­ten war­nings and other important documents.

  • A simp­le regis­tered let­ter sent via the scan­ning ser­vice is not suf­fi­ci­ent as proof.
  • It is safer to hand it over in per­son with a receipt, or to have it deli­ver­ed by a cou­rier who pro­vi­des writ­ten con­fir­ma­ti­on of delivery.
  • Deut­sche Post has sin­ce amen­ded its deli­very pro­ce­du­re: the post­man must now pro­vi­de addi­tio­nal digi­tal con­fir­ma­ti­on after pos­ting the item. It remains to be seen whe­ther the Fede­ral Labour Court will con­sider this suf­fi­ci­ent in future.

In the case of red­un­dan­ci­es due to ill­ness, employ­ers should also docu­ment that the BEM was not mere­ly offe­red as a for­ma­li­ty, but was actual­ly imple­men­ted, or explain why, in excep­tio­nal cir­cum­s­tances, it was not requi­red. Anyo­ne who is unsu­re about this should seek legal advice at an ear­ly stage.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this