When an employer issues a written warning to an employee, the question often arises in practice: does the works council need to be involved? The answer surprises many, as the legal position is clearer than one might expect.
No legal obligation to inform the works council
The Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) contains no provisions regarding written warnings. This is because a written warning is not a legal concept, but has been developed through case law. Accordingly, there is no obligation on the employer to inform the works council of a warning that has been issued or to consult the works council beforehand.
In many companies, however, the works council is informed simply to foster a spirit of trust and cooperation. This is not, however, a legal requirement. The works council generally has no right of co-determination in the case of a written warning, as it does in the case of dismissal.
No general right to information prior to termination
Another question that frequently arises in practice is: Can the works council demand that the employer provide it with details of any previous warnings issued before a dismissal takes place? After all, under Section 80(2) of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG), the works council is, in principle, entitled to receive the documents it requires to carry out its duties.
However, the Federal Labour Court has ruled that, prior to the giving of notice of dismissal, there is no general duty on the works council under works constitution law that requires the submission of such letters of warning. There is therefore no blanket right to information. There must always be a specific task that justifies the need for information (Federal Labour Court, ruling of 17 September 2013, case number 1 ABR 26/12).
Exception: Where the warning leads to dismissal
The situation is different if a dismissal does in fact take place on the basis of a previous written warning. In this case, the employer must provide the works council with full information as part of the consultation procedure under section 102(1) of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG). This also includes the content of the written warning itself.
One point that is often overlooked is particularly important here: if the employee concerned has responded to the written warning in writing and has filed a so-called ‘statement of objection’ in their personnel file, the employer must also inform the works council of this objection. If this is not done, the consultation with the works council is deemed incomplete, and the dismissal is invalid.
What does this mean for employees?
Employees who have received a written warning may consult a works council member if they wish to inspect their personnel file. This follows from the statutory right to inspect personnel files. Anyone who feels they have been wrongly given a written warning can also draft a written counterstatement and have it included in the file. This document may play an important role later on in proceedings relating to protection against unfair dismissal.
Anyone who is unsure whether a warning letter they have received is legally valid, or how they should respond to it, should seek advice on employment law before taking any action.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.