Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Warning letters and the works council: Who needs to be informed, and when?

Does the works coun­cil have to be infor­med when a writ­ten war­ning is issued? The Fede­ral Labour Court (BAG) has pro­vi­ded a clear ans­wer to this ques­ti­on – with one important excep­ti­on in the case of dismissals. 
Warning letters and the works council: Who needs to be informed, and when?

Warning letters and the works council: Who needs to be informed, and when?

When an employ­er issues a writ­ten war­ning to an employee, the ques­ti­on often ari­ses in prac­ti­ce: does the works coun­cil need to be invol­ved? The ans­wer sur­pri­ses many, as the legal posi­ti­on is clea­rer than one might expect.

No legal obligation to inform the works council

The Works Con­sti­tu­ti­on Act (BetrVG) con­ta­ins no pro­vi­si­ons regar­ding writ­ten war­nings. This is becau­se a writ­ten war­ning is not a legal con­cept, but has been deve­lo­ped through case law. Accor­din­gly, the­re is no obli­ga­ti­on on the employ­er to inform the works coun­cil of a war­ning that has been issued or to con­sult the works coun­cil beforehand.

In many com­pa­nies, howe­ver, the works coun­cil is infor­med sim­ply to fos­ter a spi­rit of trust and coope­ra­ti­on. This is not, howe­ver, a legal requi­re­ment. The works coun­cil gene­ral­ly has no right of co-deter­mi­na­ti­on in the case of a writ­ten war­ning, as it does in the case of dismissal.

No general right to information prior to termination

Ano­ther ques­ti­on that fre­quent­ly ari­ses in prac­ti­ce is: Can the works coun­cil demand that the employ­er pro­vi­de it with details of any pre­vious war­nings issued befo­re a dis­mis­sal takes place? After all, under Sec­tion 80(2) of the Works Con­sti­tu­ti­on Act (BetrVG), the works coun­cil is, in prin­ci­ple, entit­led to recei­ve the docu­ments it requi­res to car­ry out its duties.

Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Labour Court has ruled that, pri­or to the giving of noti­ce of dis­mis­sal, the­re is no gene­ral duty on the works coun­cil under works con­sti­tu­ti­on law that requi­res the sub­mis­si­on of such let­ters of war­ning. The­re is the­r­e­fo­re no blan­ket right to infor­ma­ti­on. The­re must always be a spe­ci­fic task that jus­ti­fies the need for infor­ma­ti­on (Fede­ral Labour Court, ruling of 17 Sep­tem­ber 2013, case num­ber 1 ABR 26/12).

Exception: Where the warning leads to dismissal

The situa­ti­on is dif­fe­rent if a dis­mis­sal does in fact take place on the basis of a pre­vious writ­ten war­ning. In this case, the employ­er must pro­vi­de the works coun­cil with full infor­ma­ti­on as part of the con­sul­ta­ti­on pro­ce­du­re under sec­tion 102(1) of the Works Con­sti­tu­ti­on Act (BetrVG). This also includes the con­tent of the writ­ten war­ning itself.

One point that is often over­loo­ked is par­ti­cu­lar­ly important here: if the employee con­cer­ned has respon­ded to the writ­ten war­ning in wri­ting and has filed a so-cal­led ‘state­ment of objec­tion’ in their per­son­nel file, the employ­er must also inform the works coun­cil of this objec­tion. If this is not done, the con­sul­ta­ti­on with the works coun­cil is dee­med incom­ple­te, and the dis­mis­sal is invalid.

What does this mean for employees?

Employees who have recei­ved a writ­ten war­ning may con­sult a works coun­cil mem­ber if they wish to inspect their per­son­nel file. This fol­lows from the sta­tu­to­ry right to inspect per­son­nel files. Anyo­ne who feels they have been wron­gly given a writ­ten war­ning can also draft a writ­ten coun­ter­state­ment and have it included in the file. This docu­ment may play an important role later on in pro­cee­dings rela­ting to pro­tec­tion against unfair dismissal.

Anyo­ne who is unsu­re whe­ther a war­ning let­ter they have recei­ved is legal­ly valid, or how they should respond to it, should seek advice on employ­ment law befo­re taking any action.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this