Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Fibre-optic roll-out: The owner must give their consent – a tenancy agreement is not sufficient

Fibre-optic roll-out: The owner must give their consent – a tenancy agreement is not sufficient

A tele­com­mu­ni­ca­ti­ons pro­vi­der laid fib­re-optic cables in a block of flats wit­hout aut­ho­ri­sa­ti­on, instal­led dis­tri­bu­ti­on boxes, dril­led holes in the buil­ding struc­tu­re and con­nec­ted flats up to the fourth flo­or. All of this was done wit­hout the owner’s know­ledge. The company’s jus­ti­fi­ca­ti­on was that a ten­ant had taken out a fib­re-optic con­tract, and that was suf­fi­ci­ent. The Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Karls­ru­he has cle­ar­ly rejec­ted this argument.

What the court ruled

In its jud­ge­ment of 24 June 2026 (Case No. 6 W 15/26), the Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Karls­ru­he ruled enti­re­ly in favour of the owner. The con­sent of an indi­vi­du­al ten­ant does not replace the owner’s con­sent. The court orde­red the com­ple­te rem­oval of all instal­led fix­tures and pro­hi­bi­ted the con­trac­tor from car­ry­ing out any fur­ther buil­ding works on any of the owner’s pro­per­ties wit­hout her express con­sent. Any brea­ches are lia­ble to result in an admi­nis­tra­ti­ve fine of up to 250,000 euros.

When, in fact, is there an obligation to grant temporary residence?

Sec­tion 145(1) of the Tele­com­mu­ni­ca­ti­ons Act (TKG) pro­vi­des, under cer­tain con­di­ti­ons, for an obli­ga­ti­on on the part of the owner to allow access. Howe­ver, this only appli­es if no equi­va­lent net­work infra­struc­tu­re is available within the buil­ding. In the pre­sent case, the buil­ding alre­a­dy had a high-per­for­mance net­work with down­load speeds of up to ten giga­bits per second. The reques­ted con­nec­tion, with a speed of 300 mega­bits per second, could the­r­e­fo­re be accom­mo­da­ted wit­hout any dif­fi­cul­ty. In the court’s view, the­re was the­r­e­fo­re no obli­ga­ti­on to tole­ra­te the installation.

European Gigabit legislation does nothing to change this

The pro­vi­der also invo­ked the Euro­pean Giga­bit Infra­struc­tu­re Regu­la­ti­on (GIV). Artic­le 11(4) of the GIV does grant net­work ope­ra­tors the right to extend their net­work into the user’s home. Howe­ver, the Hig­her Regio­nal Court made it clear that this right always requi­res the owner’s con­sent. EU law the­r­e­fo­re does not over­ri­de pro­per­ty rights.

Exercising one’s own authority despite an alternative offer

One fur­ther fac­tor car­ri­ed par­ti­cu­lar weight: the owner had alre­a­dy con­cluded a con­tract with ano­ther com­pa­ny for the roll-out of fib­re-optic cables to all the pro­per­ties and had offe­red the clai­mant pro­vi­der the oppor­tu­ni­ty to share use of the com­ple­ted net­work. The pro­vi­der refu­sed and began con­s­truc­tion on its own initia­ti­ve. The court dee­med this cour­se of action to be an unlawful act of self-help.

What does this mean for landlords and flat owners?

This ruling sends an important mes­sa­ge to all owners of blocks of flats and housing asso­cia­ti­ons. Any land­lord who dis­co­vers that a tele­coms pro­vi­der is car­ry­ing out buil­ding works in the buil­ding wit­hout pri­or con­sul­ta­ti­on can invo­ke this ruling. An inte­rim injunc­tion is an effec­ti­ve means of taking swift action in such cases.

  • A tenant’s con­sent is not suf­fi­ci­ent for the instal­la­ti­on of fib­re-optic cables in the building.
  • An obli­ga­ti­on to grant access under the Tele­com­mu­ni­ca­ti­ons Act (TKG) appli­es only if no equi­va­lent infra­struc­tu­re is available.
  • Car­ry­ing out unaut­ho­ri­sed exten­si­on work despi­te an alter­na­ti­ve offer being available is unlawful.
  • Com­ple­te rem­oval and ces­sa­ti­on of the acti­vi­ty may be enforced through the courts.

In indi­vi­du­al cases, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice, par­ti­cu­lar­ly if buil­ding work has alre­a­dy been car­ri­ed out wit­hout con­sent or if a ser­vice pro­vi­der insists on an alle­ged right of access.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this