Anyone who manages a flat whilst also acting as an estate agent may not charge a commission for doing so. This was ruled by the Federal Court of Justice in its judgement of 21 May 2026, thereby putting a clear stop to a widespread practice in the property sector (BGH, ref. I ZR 224/25).
What had happened?
A property owner had entrusted a commercial property manager with the management of 129 residential units and 134 garages. The property manager was contractually authorised to carry out all day-to-day management tasks, including the conclusion of new tenancy agreements on behalf of the owner. For day-to-day management, he received a monthly flat-rate fee per unit. In addition, the management contract provided for a commission of two months’ basic rent for each successful new letting.
During the term of the contract, the property manager invoiced commissions totalling around 16,800 euros. Following the termination of the contractual relationship, the owner demanded the return of this money. The case eventually reached the Federal Court of Justice.
The Federal Court of Justice’s ruling
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) upheld the ruling of the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf and found in favour of the owner. The decision is based on the Residential Property Agency Act (WoVermittG). According to Section 2(2), first sentence, No. 2 of that Act, a letting agent may not charge a commission if they are also the property manager of the flat in question. In the BGH’s view, this prohibition applies not only to the tenant but also to the landlord.
In its reasoning, the court stated that the wording of the provision did not contain any restriction to agreements with tenants. The protective purpose of the law also supports a broad interpretation: if the landlord pays the commission, he can pass this on to the tenant economically by charging a higher rent. The tenant would thus be indirectly burdened with costs, even though they never commissioned the property manager themselves.
The court also found no constitutional concerns. The property manager’s freedom to choose a profession, as enshrined in Article 12 of the Basic Law, is not disproportionately restricted by the statutory ban on commission. In introducing this provision, the legislature deliberately sought to address abuses in a tight housing market.
What does that mean in practice?
The ruling has far-reaching implications for property managers and owners alike. Many existing property management contracts contain commission clauses of this kind, which are now invalid following this ruling. This has two consequences:
- Looking ahead:Commissions already agreed upon for new tenancies can no longer be legally enforced.
- As for the past:Commissions that have already been paid may, under certain circumstances, be reclaimed, provided that the limitation period has not yet expired.
Owners who have made such payments in the past should check whether they are entitled to a refund. Property managers, for their part, should review their contract templates and check current contracts for relevant clauses.
Any owner or property manager who is unsure how to deal with existing contracts or payments already made should seek legal advice at the earliest opportunity.
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.