Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

The Federal Fiscal Court clarifies: When is only a single fee payable for a binding ruling from the tax office?

BFH ruling: Resol­ving seve­ral tax issues rela­ting to a sin­gle pro­ject trig­gers only one fee. What appli­cants need to know. 
The Federal Fiscal Court clarifies: When is only a single fee payable for a binding ruling from the tax office?

The Federal Fiscal Court clarifies: When is only a single fee payable for a binding ruling from the tax office?

Anyo­ne app­ly­ing to the tax office for a bin­ding ruling must pay a fee. But how many fees are paya­ble if a pro­ject invol­ves seve­ral stages and rai­ses various tax issues? In a recent jud­ge­ment, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has laid down important prin­ci­ples on this matter.

What is a binding statement?

A bin­ding ruling under Sec­tion 89 of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO) is an offi­ci­al assu­rance from the tax office as to how it will assess, for tax pur­po­ses, a plan­ned situa­ti­on that has not yet come to pass. Tax­pay­ers use this mecha­nism to obtain legal cer­tain­ty befo­re making major decis­i­ons. The­re is a char­ge for pro­ces­sing such requests: under Sec­tion 89(3), first sen­tence, of the AO, the tax office levies a fee for each application.

One project, one fee

In its jud­ge­ment of 25 Febru­ary 2026 (case num­ber II R 38/23), the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) cla­ri­fied that the issue of fees does not depend on the num­ber of legal ques­ti­ons rai­sed or the num­ber of types of tax con­cer­ned. The decisi­ve fac­tor is whe­ther the request for infor­ma­ti­on is based on a sin­gle set of facts.

As an exam­p­le, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) cites the res­truc­tu­ring of share­hol­dings, which takes place in seve­ral stages and is sub­se­quent­ly to be trans­fer­red to fami­ly mem­bers by way of anti­ci­pa­ted suc­ces­si­on. Even if this invol­ves inco­me tax, gift tax and other types of tax, and seve­ral indi­vi­du­al mea­su­res are plan­ned, it con­sti­tu­tes a sin­gle pro­ject. Con­se­quent­ly, only one fee may be char­ged in total.

No limitation period for the fee

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) has also ruled that fees for bin­ding rulings are not sub­ject to the limi­ta­ti­on peri­od for tax assess­ment. Whilst the­se are ancil­la­ry tax pay­ments, the gene­ral limi­ta­ti­on rules set out in Sec­tions 169 et seq. of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO) app­ly only whe­re the law express­ly so pro­vi­des. This is not the case here. The BFH also rejec­ted an ana­log­ous appli­ca­ti­on of the one-year limi­ta­ti­on peri­od for enforce­ment cos­ts under Sec­tion 346(2) of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO), on the grounds that anyo­ne who sub­mits a request for infor­ma­ti­on them­sel­ves is awa­re of the obli­ga­ti­on to pay fees and does not requi­re any spe­cial protection.

Fee payable even if the application is rejected or withdrawn

Anyo­ne who with­draws their appli­ca­ti­on for a bin­ding ruling, or who­se appli­ca­ti­on is rejec­ted by the tax office, must still pay the fee. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) jus­ti­fies this on the grounds that even a nega­ti­ve respon­se pro­vi­des cla­ri­ty for the appli­cant: they now know how the tax office asses­ses their plans for tax pur­po­ses and can adjust their plan­ning accor­din­gly. Fur­ther­mo­re, the fee is inten­ded to cover the admi­nis­tra­ti­ve cos­ts incur­red, regard­less of the outcome.

What does this mean for clients?

Anyo­ne plan­ning a com­plex pro­ject that invol­ves seve­ral types of tax or seve­ral con­se­cu­ti­ve steps does not neces­s­a­ri­ly have to pay mul­ti­ple times. If all the mea­su­res are eco­no­mic­al­ly and fac­tual­ly lin­ked, the enti­re pro­ject is regard­ed as a sin­gle mat­ter. This can signi­fi­cant­ly redu­ce the cost of a bin­ding ruling. At the same time, it is important to note that with­dra­wing the appli­ca­ti­on does not pre­vent the fee from being char­ged. When plan­ning to app­ly for a bin­ding ruling, it is the­r­e­fo­re advi­sa­ble to pre­sent the pro­ject in a com­pre­hen­si­ve and coher­ent man­ner from the out­set. Tax advi­sers or soli­ci­tors can help to draft the appli­ca­ti­on in such a way as to cle­ar­ly demons­tra­te the uni­fied natu­re of the project.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this