Anyone who inherits their parents’ home and moves in there themselves can benefit from an important inheritance tax exemption. The Federal Fiscal Court has now clarified that this tax exemption applies not only to the building itself, but also to any associated garden areas and access paths. However, this is subject to the condition that these areas are assessed as a single economic unit together with the residential property.
What are the family home rules all about?
Section 13(1)(4c) of the Inheritance Tax Act provides for a tax exemption for what is known as the ‘family home’. Under this provision, children may inherit their parents’ home tax-free if the parent lived in the property themselves until their death, the child moves in immediately after the inheritance takes effect, and the living area does not exceed 200 square metres. This provision is intended to prevent children from having to sell their parents’ home solely because of a high inheritance tax liability.
The case: Tax office excluded the garden and path
In the case decided by the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH), a son had inherited his late father’s owner-occupied house and had moved in there. The tax office recognised the tax exemption in principle, but limited it to the built-up plot of land. The adjoining garden areas and a path forming part of the property were not taken into account and were therefore subject to inheritance tax.
The son contested this and the Federal Fiscal Court ruled in his favour.
Federal Fiscal Court ruling: The economic entity is the decisive factor
In its judgement of 17 June 2026 (Case No. II R 27/23), the Federal Fiscal Court ruled that the concept of ‘benefiting property’ must be understood in the context of valuation law. The decisive factor is not how many individual parcels of land are entered in the land register. Rather, what matters is which areas the so-called ‘local tax office’ – that is, the tax office in the locality where the property is situated – has identified as an economic unit.
If the garden, access road and residential building are used jointly and assessed accordingly, all these areas may be eligible for tax exemption. This takes account of the reality of everyday life: a family home does not usually consist solely of four walls, but includes the entire plot of land used directly for that purpose.
Important advice for heirs: Act promptly
However, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has also highlighted a critical point. Anyone who disagrees with the extent of the tax-exempt property must challenge the determination of the economic unit made by the local tax office at the earliest opportunity. This decision is issued separately from the actual inheritance tax assessment.
In subsequent inheritance tax proceedings, objections regarding the extent of the property can no longer be successfully raised. The inheritance tax office is bound by the determination made by the local tax office.
What does this mean in practical terms for heirs?
- Check which areas the tax office has identified as a single economic unit at the location of the property
- Lodge an appeal against the assessment notice if the garden or other ancillary areas are missing
- Don’t wait until you receive the inheritance tax assessment, because by then it will be too late
This ruling is relevant to all heirs who inherit a family home and, in doing so, have inherited more than just the plot of land on which the property stands. Anyone who is unsure as to which areas are covered and how to challenge assessment notices should seek tax or legal advice at an early stage.
Source: BFH press releases
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.