Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Bequeathing a family home: the garden and access road may also be tax-free

Bequeathing a family home: the garden and access road may also be tax-free

Anyo­ne who inhe­rits their par­ents’ home and moves in the­re them­sel­ves can bene­fit from an important inhe­ri­tance tax exemp­ti­on. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has now cla­ri­fied that this tax exemp­ti­on appli­es not only to the buil­ding its­elf, but also to any asso­cia­ted gar­den are­as and access paths. Howe­ver, this is sub­ject to the con­di­ti­on that the­se are­as are asses­sed as a sin­gle eco­no­mic unit tog­e­ther with the resi­den­ti­al property.

What are the family home rules all about?

Sec­tion 13(1)(4c) of the Inhe­ri­tance Tax Act pro­vi­des for a tax exemp­ti­on for what is known as the ‘fami­ly home’. Under this pro­vi­si­on, child­ren may inhe­rit their par­ents’ home tax-free if the parent lived in the pro­per­ty them­sel­ves until their death, the child moves in imme­dia­te­ly after the inhe­ri­tance takes effect, and the living area does not exceed 200 squa­re met­res. This pro­vi­si­on is inten­ded to pre­vent child­ren from having to sell their par­ents’ home sole­ly becau­se of a high inhe­ri­tance tax liability.

The case: Tax office excluded the garden and path

In the case deci­ded by the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH), a son had inhe­ri­ted his late father’s owner-occu­p­ied house and had moved in the­re. The tax office reco­g­nis­ed the tax exemp­ti­on in prin­ci­ple, but limi­t­ed it to the built-up plot of land. The adjoi­ning gar­den are­as and a path forming part of the pro­per­ty were not taken into account and were the­r­e­fo­re sub­ject to inhe­ri­tance tax.

The son con­tes­ted this and the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court ruled in his favour.

Federal Fiscal Court ruling: The economic entity is the decisive factor

In its jud­ge­ment of 17 June 2026 (Case No. II R 27/23), the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court ruled that the con­cept of ‘bene­fiting pro­per­ty’ must be unders­tood in the con­text of valua­ti­on law. The decisi­ve fac­tor is not how many indi­vi­du­al par­cels of land are ente­red in the land regis­ter. Rather, what mat­ters is which are­as the so-cal­led ‘local tax office’ – that is, the tax office in the loca­li­ty whe­re the pro­per­ty is situa­ted – has iden­ti­fied as an eco­no­mic unit.

If the gar­den, access road and resi­den­ti­al buil­ding are used joint­ly and asses­sed accor­din­gly, all the­se are­as may be eli­gi­ble for tax exemp­ti­on. This takes account of the rea­li­ty of ever­y­day life: a fami­ly home does not usual­ly con­sist sole­ly of four walls, but includes the enti­re plot of land used direct­ly for that purpose.

Important advice for heirs: Act promptly

Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) has also high­ligh­ted a cri­ti­cal point. Anyo­ne who dis­agrees with the ext­ent of the tax-exempt pro­per­ty must chall­enge the deter­mi­na­ti­on of the eco­no­mic unit made by the local tax office at the ear­liest oppor­tu­ni­ty. This decis­i­on is issued sepa­ra­te­ly from the actu­al inhe­ri­tance tax assessment.

In sub­se­quent inhe­ri­tance tax pro­cee­dings, objec­tions regar­ding the ext­ent of the pro­per­ty can no lon­ger be suc­cessful­ly rai­sed. The inhe­ri­tance tax office is bound by the deter­mi­na­ti­on made by the local tax office.

What does this mean in practical terms for heirs?

  • Check which are­as the tax office has iden­ti­fied as a sin­gle eco­no­mic unit at the loca­ti­on of the property
  • Lodge an appeal against the assess­ment noti­ce if the gar­den or other ancil­la­ry are­as are missing
  • Don’t wait until you recei­ve the inhe­ri­tance tax assess­ment, becau­se by then it will be too late

This ruling is rele­vant to all heirs who inhe­rit a fami­ly home and, in doing so, have inhe­ri­ted more than just the plot of land on which the pro­per­ty stands. Anyo­ne who is unsu­re as to which are­as are cover­ed and how to chall­enge assess­ment noti­ces should seek tax or legal advice at an ear­ly stage.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this