When children inherit a family home from their parents, this acquisition is exempt from inheritance tax under certain conditions. In a recent ruling, the Federal Fiscal Court has now clarified the geographical scope of this exemption where the residential property also includes a garden plot or a path.
What is the ‘family home exemption’ all about?
Under the Inheritance Tax Act, children may inherit a house or flat tax-free if the parent lived there themselves until their death, the child moves in immediately after the inheritance takes effect, and the living area does not exceed 200 square metres. If the floor area is larger than this, the tax relief is granted on a pro rata basis.
It had previously been unclear whether this tax exemption also extended to adjacent areas used in conjunction with the residential property, such as a garden on a separate plot of land or a strip of land used as a path.
The case: Six plots of land, one estate
In the case in question, a son had inherited several parcels of land following his father’s death in 2020. The residential property stood on one particular parcel of land. In addition, there was an adjoining garden plot and an L‑shaped access plot, which was used in conjunction with the residential house. The relevant tax assessment office had grouped all three plots of land together as a so-called economic unit and determined their total value as a single figure.
However, the inheritance tax office granted the tax exemption only for the plot of land on which the house was built, excluding the garden and the path. The son challenged this decision; although his appeal was initially dismissed by the Finance Court, he was successful before the Federal Fiscal Court.
BFH: The economic entity is the decisive factor
The Federal Fiscal Court ruled that the scope of the tax exemption is determined not by the individual parcel of land, but by the economic unit as established by the tax office responsible for valuation. Where there are several parcels of land which are used jointly as a residential property with a garden and access road, and where this joint purpose is apparent to outsiders, they constitute a single unit for valuation purposes. And this unit is then entitled to the full benefit of the exemption (Federal Fiscal Court, judgement of 17 June 2026, ref. II R 27/23).
The assessment notice issued by the local tax office is binding. This means that the inheritance tax office is bound by the valuation set out in that notice and cannot, on its own initiative, narrow the scope of the property in question.
Retroactive taxation applies to all sub-plots
Important to note: Anyone claiming the tax exemption for their family home, including the garden and access area, is subsequently bound by the ten-year period for all these areas. If the child moves out within ten years or no longer uses the areas for residential purposes, the tax exemption ceases to apply with retroactive effect. This then also applies to the garden and the access area.
What does this mean for heirs in practice?
The ruling has specific implications for anyone who inherits a family home that also includes ancillary land on separate plots. The key factor is the valuation notice issued by the tax assessment office. Anyone who disagrees with the scope of the economic unit as determined in that notice must challenge it at that stage. It will no longer be possible to raise such an objection during the subsequent inheritance tax proceedings.
Heirs should therefore have the assessment notices carefully checked and, if anything is unclear, seek legal or tax advice at an early stage.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.