Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Bequeathing a family home: Federal Fiscal Court upholds tax exemption for gardens and paths

Bequeathing a family home: Federal Fiscal Court upholds tax exemption for gardens and paths

When child­ren inhe­rit a fami­ly home from their par­ents, this acqui­si­ti­on is exempt from inhe­ri­tance tax under cer­tain con­di­ti­ons. In a recent ruling, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has now cla­ri­fied the geo­gra­phi­cal scope of this exemp­ti­on whe­re the resi­den­ti­al pro­per­ty also includes a gar­den plot or a path.

What is the ‘family home exemption’ all about?

Under the Inhe­ri­tance Tax Act, child­ren may inhe­rit a house or flat tax-free if the parent lived the­re them­sel­ves until their death, the child moves in imme­dia­te­ly after the inhe­ri­tance takes effect, and the living area does not exceed 200 squa­re met­res. If the flo­or area is lar­ger than this, the tax reli­ef is gran­ted on a pro rata basis.

It had pre­vious­ly been unclear whe­ther this tax exemp­ti­on also exten­ded to adja­cent are­as used in con­junc­tion with the resi­den­ti­al pro­per­ty, such as a gar­den on a sepa­ra­te plot of land or a strip of land used as a path.

The case: Six plots of land, one estate

In the case in ques­ti­on, a son had inhe­ri­ted seve­ral par­cels of land fol­lo­wing his father’s death in 2020. The resi­den­ti­al pro­per­ty stood on one par­ti­cu­lar par­cel of land. In addi­ti­on, the­re was an adjoi­ning gar­den plot and an L‑shaped access plot, which was used in con­junc­tion with the resi­den­ti­al house. The rele­vant tax assess­ment office had grou­ped all three plots of land tog­e­ther as a so-cal­led eco­no­mic unit and deter­mi­ned their total value as a sin­gle figure.

Howe­ver, the inhe­ri­tance tax office gran­ted the tax exemp­ti­on only for the plot of land on which the house was built, exclu­ding the gar­den and the path. The son chal­len­ged this decis­i­on; alt­hough his appeal was initi­al­ly dis­missed by the Finan­ce Court, he was suc­cessful befo­re the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court.

BFH: The economic entity is the decisive factor

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court ruled that the scope of the tax exemp­ti­on is deter­mi­ned not by the indi­vi­du­al par­cel of land, but by the eco­no­mic unit as estab­lished by the tax office respon­si­ble for valua­ti­on. Whe­re the­re are seve­ral par­cels of land which are used joint­ly as a resi­den­ti­al pro­per­ty with a gar­den and access road, and whe­re this joint pur­po­se is appa­rent to out­si­ders, they con­sti­tu­te a sin­gle unit for valua­ti­on pur­po­ses. And this unit is then entit­led to the full bene­fit of the exemp­ti­on (Fede­ral Fis­cal Court, jud­ge­ment of 17 June 2026, ref. II R 27/23).

The assess­ment noti­ce issued by the local tax office is bin­ding. This means that the inhe­ri­tance tax office is bound by the valua­ti­on set out in that noti­ce and can­not, on its own initia­ti­ve, nar­row the scope of the pro­per­ty in question.

Retroactive taxation applies to all sub-plots

Important to note: Anyo­ne clai­ming the tax exemp­ti­on for their fami­ly home, inclu­ding the gar­den and access area, is sub­se­quent­ly bound by the ten-year peri­od for all the­se are­as. If the child moves out within ten years or no lon­ger uses the are­as for resi­den­ti­al pur­po­ses, the tax exemp­ti­on cea­ses to app­ly with retroac­ti­ve effect. This then also appli­es to the gar­den and the access area.

What does this mean for heirs in practice?

The ruling has spe­ci­fic impli­ca­ti­ons for anyo­ne who inhe­rits a fami­ly home that also includes ancil­la­ry land on sepa­ra­te plots. The key fac­tor is the valua­ti­on noti­ce issued by the tax assess­ment office. Anyo­ne who dis­agrees with the scope of the eco­no­mic unit as deter­mi­ned in that noti­ce must chall­enge it at that stage. It will no lon­ger be pos­si­ble to rai­se such an objec­tion during the sub­se­quent inhe­ri­tance tax proceedings.

Heirs should the­r­e­fo­re have the assess­ment noti­ces careful­ly che­cked and, if any­thing is unclear, seek legal or tax advice at an ear­ly stage.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this