Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Tax evasion or reckless tax avoidance: what does this mean for the limitation period?

Tax evasion or reckless tax avoidance: what does this mean for the limitation period?

Anyo­ne who fails to sub­mit a tax return, despi­te being obli­ged to do so, risks more than just having to pay back tax. In a recent jud­ge­ment dated 13 March 2026 (Ref. 4 K 135/19 E), the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court has cla­ri­fied why the pre­cise clas­si­fi­ca­ti­on of the con­duct as tax eva­si­on or reck­less tax avo­id­ance has signi­fi­cant impli­ca­ti­ons for the ques­ti­on of how long the tax office is still per­mit­ted to assess taxes.

What had happened?

A mar­ried cou­ple had regu­lar­ly filed inco­me tax returns up until 2008. From 2009 onwards, the wife also took up employ­ment as an employee. Both their wages were taxed under tax clas­ses III and V. This meant that the cou­ple were legal­ly obli­ged to sub­mit an annu­al inco­me tax return, as sti­pu­la­ted in Sec­tion 46 of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG). This obli­ga­ti­on appli­es when­ever both spou­ses recei­ve wages and the less favoura­ble tax class V has been chosen.

The cou­ple did not sub­mit any tax returns for 2009 and 2010. The tax office did not noti­ce this until 2018 and sub­se­quent­ly issued tax assess­ment noti­ces. The cou­ple invo­ked the sta­tu­te of limitations.

The issue of limitation periods

Under tax law, the­re are dif­fe­rent time limits within which the tax office is still per­mit­ted to assess taxes. The stan­dard assess­ment peri­od is four years. In cases of reck­less tax eva­si­on, this is exten­ded to five years; in cases of tax eva­si­on, it is exten­ded to as many as ten years.

The court the­r­e­fo­re had to deter­mi­ne which of the­se time limits appli­ed in this case. Tax eva­si­on requi­res intent; in other words, the tax­pay­er must at least have accept­ed, with appr­oval, that they were pay­ing too litt­le tax. The Müns­ter Fis­cal Court was not con­vin­ced that the cou­ple had acted with such intent. It con­side­red it pos­si­ble that the cou­ple sim­ply assu­med that the inco­me tax deduc­ted at source would cover their tax lia­bi­li­ty in full, as had been the case in pre­vious years.

Carelessness is sufficient to extend the limitation period

Reck­less tax eva­si­on, on the other hand, does not requi­re intent. It is broad­ly equi­va­lent to gross negli­gence, but is asses­sed in the light of the individual’s per­so­nal capa­bi­li­ties. Anyo­ne who, given their cir­cum­s­tances and know­ledge, would have been in a posi­ti­on to find out about their tax obli­ga­ti­ons is acting reck­less­ly if they fail to do so.

The court empha­sis­ed that, when the wife took up employ­ment and was ther­eby obli­ged to inform her employ­er of her inco­me tax bra­cket, it should have been obvious to the cou­ple that this might ent­ail fur­ther tax impli­ca­ti­ons. They should have sought advice from a qua­li­fied advi­ser. They fai­led to do so. This con­sti­tu­ted reck­less tax eva­si­on, and the five-year limi­ta­ti­on peri­od appli­ed. The tax office was the­r­e­fo­re still able to assess taxes retro­s­pec­tively for 2010. The limi­ta­ti­on peri­od had only expi­red for 2009.

What does this mean for taxpayers?

The ruling shows that igno­rance does not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly pro­tect against an exten­ded limi­ta­ti­on peri­od. Anyo­ne who­se inco­me situa­ti­on chan­ges – for exam­p­le, by taking on a second job within the house­hold – should check whe­ther this gives rise to an obli­ga­ti­on to decla­re it. If in doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to con­sult a tax advi­ser at an ear­ly stage.

  • Stan­dard limi­ta­ti­on peri­od: 4 years
  • For reck­less tax eva­si­on: 5 years
  • For tax eva­si­on: 10 years

In spe­ci­fic indi­vi­du­al cases, tax advice should be sought in order to assess one’s own risk.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this